The Red Wings may not have turned free agency into a fireworks show, but they did manage to dodge a move that could have haunted them for years.
That’s the real takeaway from the Darnell Nurse situation. The former Edmonton Oilers defenseman landed with the San Jose Sharks for Shakir Mukhamadullin and Zack Sharp, and in Red Wings terms that would have meant parting with Albert Johansson and William Wallinder. Detroit didn’t go there, and that decision looks awfully wise.
Nurse isn’t being labeled a bad player here. The issue is the price tag, and it’s a brutal one.
He carries a $9.25 million average annual value for the next four seasons, and he’ll be 35 when the deal ends. Even worse, the contract includes a full no-movement clause for the next two seasons before shifting to a modified 10-team no-trade list over the final two.
On the ice, Nurse would have brought some useful numbers. He led the Oilers in hits last season with 137 and blocked shots with 167.
If he had been wearing a Red Wings sweater, those totals would have ranked third on the team in hits behind Marco Kasper’s 186 and Ben Chiarot’s 170, and second in blocked shots behind Moritz Seider’s 180. His 24 points in 82 games would have placed him third among Detroit defensemen last season.
The fit on paper is easy to see. Nurse likely would have landed on the second pair with Justin Faulk and given the Red Wings a version of what Chiarot already provides, only at a much higher cost and with more ice time.
That’s where the problem starts. Detroit would have been adding another older defenseman to a group that already leans that way.
Seider is 25, Edvinsson is 23 and Johansson is 25 on the younger side, while Nurse is 31, Faulk is 34 and Chiarot is 35 on the older end. For a team eight years into a rebuild, that kind of age profile would have been hard to justify.
There’s also the long view. Nurse might have helped the second pair for a season, maybe a little longer.
After that, the deal would have started to get in the way. The Red Wings have younger defensemen waiting for a shot, and bringing Nurse in would have crowded that path.
And this wasn’t the only smart work Steve Yzerman did this week. On Day 1 of free agency, he added an even-strength scorer, a backup goalie and several Grand Rapids players to keep the AHL club solid. He also addressed the team’s need for more toughness by trading for Vegas Golden Knights forward Keegan Kolesar.
Sometimes the cleanest move is the one you never make. In this case, passing on Nurse looks like a gift for Detroit.
In Other News...
Red Wings Just Closed The Door On A Prospect Fans Know Well
Lombardi is moving on after a familiar run through the Red Wings pipeline, and the next stop comes with a clearer path to the NHL. New Jersey has signed the forward to a two-year contract with an average annual value of $875,000, a deal that starts as a two-way arrangement before shifting to a one-way salary in the second year. For Detroit, it ends the possibility of keeping a player who had become a well-known name around Grand Rapids and a reminder of how quickly promising organizational pieces can become trade chips.
The Devils did not just land Lombardis signing rights, either. Detroit got a 2026 fourth-round draft pick back in the exchange, a modest return that suggests the Wings preferred to take something now rather than let the situation linger. Lombardi had earned attention as one of Grand Rapids more dangerous offensive options, the kind of quick, creative playmaker who can make a case for NHL time, but the Red Wings have now closed that door and moved on to the next decision. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings May Finally Need A Risky Swing At Center
Detroits search for a true top-line center keeps circling back to the same uncomfortable reality: if the Red Wings want to land a difference-maker, they may have to do it in a way that tests both their patience and their appetite for risk. The idea gaining traction is an offer sheet, the kind of aggressive move that can pry loose talent from another roster but also comes with a steep price and a very public gamble on how badly a team wants to win the bidding war.
For Detroit, the appeal is obvious because it would force a major reshaping of the middle of the lineup and could change the long-term conversation around Dylan Larkins place in the organization. But the cost of going that route is no small thing, and the Red Wings would have to move quickly if they decided this was the swing worth taking. In a market where center help is hard to find, the question is whether they are ready to pay the price before someone else does. [Read more 🡒]