Red Wings Suddenly Have A Tough Decision In Net

Daniil Tarasov's standout performance this season has forced the Detroit Red Wings to re-evaluate their goaltending strategy ahead of an impending contract decision.

Daniil Tarasov was supposed to be insurance. Instead, six weeks into the season, he’s forcing the Red Wings to think about the future of their crease.

Detroit signed Tarasov on July 1 to a 1-year, $2 million deal, and the plan looked simple enough: bring in a dependable backup and move on. But Tarasov has played his way into something bigger. His contract is up after this season, and if he keeps this up, the Red Wings will have to decide whether to extend him early or let next summer’s market decide what he’s worth.

The numbers explain why this has already become a real issue. Tarasov is second among qualified NHL goalies with a .931 save percentage, according to CBS Sports’ goaltending leaderboard. His 31-save shutout in Tampa on Saturday was his second shutout in nine appearances with Detroit, and it pushed him into a much larger role than anyone likely expected when the season began.

Ted Kulfan wrote after Saturday’s win that Tarasov is expected to get “the majority of playing time for the near future,” and that’s the heart of the matter. A goalie signed to back up is now carrying the load, and his deal doesn’t match the job he’s doing.

The Red Wings do have some time before they can make a move. NHL teams can’t extend players on 1-year contracts until Jan. 1, which gives Detroit about six more weeks to keep evaluating Tarasov before talks can start. That window matters because the price tag will only climb if he keeps producing at this level.

There’s another wrinkle here, too: John Gibson is in the same contract lane. His 8-year, $51.2 million deal carries a $6.4 million cap hit and runs out after this season. If Detroit stands pat, it could head into next summer without either goalie under contract.

That’s what turns Tarasov from a nice surprise into a front-office decision. The case for moving early is obvious.

If he keeps stacking elite numbers, his value rises fast, and locking him in before he reaches the market would almost certainly be cheaper than trying to replace him there. It would also give the Red Wings some stability in net at a time when Gibson’s future is unresolved.

Still, there’s reason to be cautious. The sample is small, and Tarasov’s track record before arriving in Detroit was uneven.

In 98 NHL games with Columbus and Florida, he went 32-49-9 with a 3.30 goals-against average and an .897 save percentage, according to the team announcement. He also posted an .895 save percentage with the Panthers last season, a reminder of how quickly goalie numbers can swing.

So the Red Wings don’t need to rush into a long-term commitment. They need more than nine appearances before handing out real term and money.

The prospect picture also shapes the decision. Trey Augustine, Detroit’s top prospect, is 21 and was projected to reach the NHL in 2028-29, according to NHL.com’s preseason prospect rankings.

He’s spending this season with the Grand Rapids Griffins. Michal Postava, who made his NHL debut in October, gives the organization another young option as well.

That timeline suggests a bridge, not a permanent solution. Detroit may not need Tarasov for the long haul, but it could absolutely need him for the next two or three seasons while Augustine develops.

For now, patience makes sense. Once Jan. 1 arrives, though, the Red Wings should be ready. If Tarasov is still performing near the top of the league, a short extension would fit the moment: enough years to cover the gap before Augustine is ready, not so much term that Detroit gets trapped if Tarasov comes back to earth.

A 2- or 3-year deal would keep the cost manageable and preserve flexibility. It would also reward a goalie who arrived in July as a backup and has already changed the conversation in Detroit.

In Other News...

Red Wings Rookies Are Already Creating One Tough Early Decision

The Red Wings opened the season with five rookies on the roster, and that youth movement has already made the early part of the year worth watching. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard has stood out right away, bringing a physical edge that has put him near the top of the league in hits while also chipping in offensively. For a team trying to blend development with competitiveness, that kind of immediate impact is exactly what can change the conversation around a young player.

The tougher part is figuring out how the rest of the rookie group fits as the season settles in. Nate Danielson and Axel Sandin-Pellikka have had their ups and downs with consistency and lineup placement, while William Wallinder has slowly earned more ice time and responsibility on the blue line. That leaves Detroit with an early roster puzzle that is bigger than just who stays up, because the way these rookies are handled could shape both the lineup now and the clubs longer-term plans. [Read more 🡒]

Red Wings Face One Huge Larkin Decision As Wild Keep Calling

The calls keep coming for Dylan Larkin, and the Minnesota Wild have been persistent in trying to pry the former Red Wings captain away from Detroit. Multiple offers have reportedly been put on the table, with packages built around names such as Danila Yurov, Charlie Stramel, Ryan Hartman and first-round draft picks, but interim GM Shawn Horcoff has not moved on any of them as the Red Wings weigh whether the return would actually help them now.

That is the heart of the decision facing Detroit, because this is not just about moving a recognizable veteran. The Red Wings are said to be looking for players who can step into the lineup and make an immediate difference, while the Wild are dangling the kind of future value that can be tempting in a bigger reset. For now, though, there is no completed deal, and the longer this drags on, the more it feels like one of those franchise-defining calls that can shape the next phase of the rebuild. [Read more 🡒]

Red Wings Goalie Debate Just Got Harder To Ignore

Daniil Tarasov has made the Red Wings goaltending picture a lot more interesting in a short amount of time. His early work in net has been hard to ignore, with strong results in both save percentage and goals-against average, giving Detroit something it has badly needed as it tries to steady the position.

Todd McLellan still has not gone as far as naming Tarasov the starter, though, and that keeps the discussion open for now. Gibson has not helped quiet it, given his rough stretch and recent losses, so the question in Detroit is no longer whether the competition matters, but how long the staff can keep treating it like a normal rotation battle. [Read more 🡒]