Red Wings Suddenly Face A Bigger Exit Problem Than Fans Realized

Amid mounting player exits, the Detroit Red Wings face tough decisions on balancing trade value with maintaining their international reputation and team morale.

The Red Wings are juggling three separate player exit requests, and the newest one may be the easiest to resolve. Dylan Larkin wants out.

Simon Edvinsson wants out. Now Théo Rochette reportedly wants to break his deal and head back to Switzerland.

Detroit’s answer has been the same in each case: not on your terms. That stance makes plenty of sense with Larkin and Edvinsson, but Rochette is a different kind of problem - one that could end up costing the organization more than it brings back.

Rochette’s situation surfaced this week, with Grégory Beaud of Swiss outlet Blick reporting that the 24-year-old wants to return to Grégory Beaud reported for Swiss outlet Blick (translated from German). Rochette signed a 1-year entry-level deal with Detroit in June after leading HC Lausanne with 22 goals in 46 games, but his North American start has gone sideways.

He has five points in nine games with the Grand Rapids Griffins, and Swiss Hockey News reported that he stepped away from the team about two weeks ago for personal reasons. That same report said the organization has been reluctant to release him, and that talks between Rochette, the Red Wings and the Griffins are still ongoing.

The contrast with his own words from June is hard to miss. At the time of the signing, Rochette said, “my dream is to play in the NHL, so I don’t want to have any regret not trying,” according to Bob Duff of Detroit Hockey Now.

Detroit’s toughest standoff, though, began with Larkin. He asked for a trade in June and has been on an unpaid suspension since Oct.

  1. The Red Wings have held firm, refusing to move him for less than they believe he is worth.

That approach has drawn heat. Frank Seravalli reported that the decision not to deal with Minnesota comes from the top of the organization, and Elliotte Friedman offered a different read on the situation during the 32 Thoughts podcast.

As Heavy’s Caleb Kerney relayed it, Friedman said that “if Minnesota had Matt Boldy on the table, then the Red Wings would be saying, ‘don’t hang up, where do we sign?’” The point was clear: Detroit’s line is about value, not personal feelings.

Edvinsson has created a similarly tense situation, though the details are different. Seravalli reported this week that he turned down offer sheets so the club couldn’t match them and keep him. Sportsnet’s reporting this week made clear that his camp’s position hasn’t changed: he sees his future somewhere else.

The Red Wings have been willing to let that one run right up to the Dec. 1 deadline rather than settle for a weak return. Tony Wolak has already laid out why a trade now looks more likely than a new contract, and this week’s argument was that Detroit should avoid turning this into another drawn-out Larkin situation.

That’s where Rochette stands apart from the other two. Larkin and Edvinsson are valuable pieces, and other teams would have real interest.

Detroit can justify standing its ground there because the payoff could matter. Rochette, by contrast, is a 24-year-old on a 1-year deal who has played nine AHL games and already left the team.

There is no meaningful trade return waiting there, and keeping him under contract against his wishes doesn’t help the Red Wings or the Griffins on the ice.

There’s also the broader message to think about. Detroit has long mined Europe for talent, and Rochette’s case will not go unnoticed by players and agents there.

Letting him go would signal that the organization will move on when a player clearly doesn’t want to be there. Holding him only adds another unnecessary fight to a team already dealing with two bigger ones.

The three situations are not the same. Larkin’s issues trace back to the previous front office, Edvinsson’s began with a contract dispute, and Rochette’s appears tied to a difficult first season away from home. But treating all three the same way risks turning every departure into a battle.

And the timing matters, too. The Red Wings are 8-11-3, have dropped six of their last seven, and are being run by interim general manager Shawn Horcoff.

He has every reason to protect the club’s leverage in the Larkin and Edvinsson talks. Rochette’s case, though, looks like the one where Detroit should simply move on.

In Other News...

Red Wings Trade Talk Around Dylan Larkin Just Got More Serious

The chatter around Dylan Larkin has taken a sharper turn, and it is no longer just the usual deadline-season noise. Elliotte Friedman said the Red Wings would consider moving their captain to the Minnesota Wild if the right offer came along, a notable shift from the idea that Detroit would never entertain the thought because of the loyalty angle attached to its longtime leader.

Simon Edvinsson has also entered the conversation, with Friedman noting that clubs can discuss trades involving the restricted free agent even though nothing has materialized yet. Darren Dreger took it a step further by suggesting Detroit could try to move both Larkin and Edvinsson at the same time, a sign the front office may be weighing bigger roster changes as it looks to address more than one need at once. [Read more 🡒]

Todd McLellan Just Put Detroits Biggest Problem On Blast

Todd McLellan did not sugarcoat where the Red Wings stand after their 3-1 loss to the Bruins, and the frustration was easy to hear in the aftermath. Detroit has been fighting to find any kind of rhythm, and the coach pointed to the same problems that have followed the team through recent stretches: trouble sustaining momentum and too little offense coming from beyond the top of the lineup.

The concern is bigger than one off night because the Red Wings are sitting near the bottom of the standings and need more from their depth if they are going to climb out of it. McLellan also addressed Alex DeBrincats scoring slump, but he made it clear he expects that dry spell to pass, leaving the more pressing issue on the rest of the forward group to answer. [Read more 🡒]

Red Wings Gave An Unknown Forward An Impossible Debut Mission

When Gordie Howe went down with an injury in 1958, the Red Wings had to reach into the depths of their system and hand Brian Smith an assignment few young forwards could have imagined. Called up from the Hamilton Tiger Cubs, Smith was thrust into a Detroit lineup built around one of the sports biggest stars, and the opportunity came with all the pressure that comes from filling in for a legend.

Smith stuck around long enough to carve out a small place in Red Wings history, eventually scoring his first NHL goal in 1960 before a serious knee injury began to alter the course of his career. His final game in the league came with Detroit in December 1961, closing a brief but memorable run for a player whose debut arrived under impossible circumstances and whose path never quite followed the one that first opened for him. [Read more 🡒]