Steve Yzerman put together plenty of wins during his run as general manager of the Detroit Red Wings. He rebuilt the prospect pipeline, landed core pieces such as Moritz Seider, Lucas Raymond and Simon Edvinsson, and gave the franchise a much clearer path forward.
But if there’s one draft move that still hangs over his Detroit tenure, it’s the 2021 decision to trade up for Sebastian Cossa instead of taking Jesper Wallstedt. The price of that move also came back to sting the Red Wings when the pick they sent to Dallas later became Wyatt Johnston.
Detroit started the 2021 NHL Draft with the 6th overall pick and the 23rd overall selection. Wanting to address a long-term need in goal, Yzerman moved up with the Dallas Stars to get the 15th pick.
The Red Wings gave Dallas the 23rd overall pick, the 48th overall pick and the 138th overall pick in exchange for the slot they used on Cossa.
Cossa was a big-name goalie prospect for a reason. He stood 6-foot-6 and had just turned in a dominant season with the Edmonton Oil Kings, finishing 17-1-1 with a 1.57 goals-against average and a .941 save percentage.
The problem with the pick was never that Cossa was a bad prospect. It was that another elite goalie was still sitting there.
Jesper Wallstedt was available at No. 20 when the Minnesota Wild took him. He had already played professionally in Sweden’s SHL and arrived at the draft as the top European goaltender on NHL Central Scouting’s list. A lot of scouts saw him as the safer bet because of his technique, maturity and experience against older competition.
Cossa had the size and upside. Wallstedt had the polish.
Then there’s the part that really twists the knife for Detroit: Dallas used the pick it got from the Red Wings to take Wyatt Johnston at No. 23. Johnston has since become one of the NHL’s best young forwards and a major piece of the Stars’ future.
That’s what makes this one so hard to shake. At the time, Detroit was trying to solve a real organizational need in net, and no draft pick comes with a guarantee. But looking back, the combination of the assets sent away, Wallstedt still being on the board and Johnston becoming an impact player makes the Cossa trade-up look like one of the most questionable calls of the Yzerman era.
Calling Cossa a bust would be too early. Goaltenders take their own path, and he still has time to become the player Detroit hoped it was getting. Even so, this is the kind of draft decision that keeps the what-ifs alive.
In Other News...
Red Wings May Have A Familiar Answer For This Crucial Front Office Job
The Red Wings search for a new Director of Hockey Operations has naturally turned into a familiar kind of conversation around the organization: who knows the franchise, who can help shape the next phase, and who has the front-office chops to handle a job that matters more than it might sound at first glance. Among the names circulating, Ryan Martin stands out as someone with real Detroit roots and a long track record in hockey operations, which gives the discussion a different feel than the usual round of outside candidates.
Martins appeal comes from more than just familiarity. He spent 16 years in Detroits front office and built a reputation around contract work and talent evaluation, the sort of background that can translate well in an interview room if the club wants a modern voice who already understands the pressure points of the job. Brendan Shanahan, Shawn Horcoff and Kris Draper are also part of the broader fan conversation, but the Red Wings next move will say plenty about whether they want a fresh perspective, a trusted name, or some blend of both. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Cup History Is Suddenly Back In A Strange Spotlight
A strange little piece of Red Wings history has been pulled back into the spotlight after Carolina used all 55 name slots on the Stanley Cup, matching the maximum Detroit reached in 1997-98. That old Red Wings engraving now matters again because it is the last time a team filled the Cup to capacity, a reminder that the trophys surface can become a snapshot not just of champions, but of how a franchise chooses to define its season and its people.
For Detroit fans, the comparison is especially notable because that 1997 engraving included nine members of the Ilitch family, showing the organization was willing to use the full allotment for owners and executives as well as players and hockey staff. The current debate around Carolina has only sharpened attention on the NHLs formal rules for Cup engravings, which spell out who qualifies and how exceptions are handled when a name does not fit the standard criteria. [Read more 🡒]