Now that Alexander Nikishin has landed a cheap one-year deal with the Carolina Hurricanes, Detroit is the club left staring back at the league. Simon Edvinsson is the lone unsigned restricted free agent, and if the Red Wings want him available for this NHL season, they need a contract done before December 1.
That deadline only sharpens the awkwardness around a negotiation that has dragged on far too long. The Red Wings have not made life easy on themselves this offseason, either, with the publicized trade request from former captain Dylan Larkin, the move that turned a former top prospect into another first-round pick, and a GM search that stumbled badly before landing on the man already serving in the interim role.
But the Edvinsson situation has become the most glaring problem of all. Detroit has reportedly been lowballing the 23-year-old defenseman for more than a year, trying to keep his cap hit under Moritz Seider’s $8.55 million number. That approach ignores how much the salary cap has climbed since Seider signed his contract, and it clashes with what Edvinsson’s camp is said to want: a seven-year deal in the $9-10 million range, a figure compared to Zeev Buium’s extension with Vancouver this summer.
What makes this mess so damaging is that Edvinsson has shown plenty of willingness to meet the organization halfway. Even with rumors of an offer sheet floating all summer, he showed up to training camp without a contract, trained with the team, took out his own insurance policy and was literally in the same building as the front office while negotiations continued.
Then camp ended without a deal, and Edvinsson went back to Sweden until further notice. With November around the corner, he reportedly would “prefer a trade” after what has been a totally avoidable breakdown in talks.
This is bigger than one contract dispute. Detroit has missed the playoffs for 10 straight seasons and counting, and the franchise’s standing around the league is nowhere near what it once was. That reality seems lost on old-guard voices like Senior VP Jim Devellano, even as the evidence keeps piling up.
One example came in the 2025 offseason, when Detroit had just missed the postseason for the second straight year but seemed to be trending upward after Todd McLellan’s midseason hire. Even with obvious interest and a clear need for more scoring, then-GM Steve Yzerman’s attempts to contact top free agent forward Nikolaj Ehlers were reportedly ignored.
Put all of that together - the playoff drought, a former captain who wanted out, and an owner out of step with the fan base and media - and the Red Wings are waving a giant warning sign at anyone who might help fix this team. Hardball with a 23-year-old top-pairing defenseman who had been working to get a deal done as recently as August is the kind of thing that can linger.
And there is no practical excuse for it. Near the end of October, the Red Wings led the NHL with $19.68 million in cap space, more than enough to sign Edvinsson at the number his camp wants and still keep plenty of room to spare.
Detroit also has veteran money coming off the books, with John Gibson, Justin Faulk and Andrew Copp all on expiring contracts and none of them likely to return after this season. A long-term deal for Edvinsson should be an obvious move on a roster that is almost certain to get younger, and having a top-line piece locked in is exactly how a team starts building something real.
The longer this drags on, the worse it looks. Detroit already is under a microscope because Edvinsson is the last unsigned RFA in the league, and a short-term deal similar to Nikishin’s would only add another hit to the organization’s reputation.
If the Red Wings want to change the way the rest of the NHL sees them, they need to stop making it harder on themselves. Any meaningful jump in talent will likely have to come from outside the organization, ideally through a trade, and with no-move clauses becoming commonplace, Detroit has to give players a reason to choose it. Finishing the Edvinsson deal would be a good place to start.
In Other News...
Red Wings Face A Real Simon Edvinsson Deadline Problem
Alexander Nikishins one-year deal with the Carolina Hurricanes has trimmed the list of unsigned restricted free agents around the league, and it also leaves Simon Edvinsson in a more uncomfortable spotlight for the Red Wings. Detroit still has the young defenseman in contract talks, and with December 1 looming, the situation has a built-in deadline that makes every day matter a little more than usual.
Shawn Horcoff is trying to get a deal done before that date, but the bigger wrinkle is the one hanging over the negotiations: Edvinsson has indicated he would prefer to be traded, even if he has not formally made that request. For a team that wants to keep building around its blue line, the Red Wings are now juggling both the contract clock and a player's preferred path, which is hardly the kind of offseason business they wanted to carry into the seasons final stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings May Have A New Goaltending Storyline Fans Can't Ignore
Michal Postavas first NHL start gave the Red Wings exactly the sort of goaltending boost they could use, and it came in one of the seasons most pressure-packed settings. Detroit edged the Edmonton Oilers 4-3 in a shootout, with Postava turning aside 25 shots and settling in when the game got tight, including key stops in overtime against a deep Edmonton attack.
The real test arrived in the skills competition, where the rookie held his ground against the leagues top stars and helped keep Detroit alive long enough to finish the job. The Red Wings had already forced extra time with a late push in the third period, and the night ended with Lucas Raymond delivering the shootout winner to cap a result that could make this goalie situation worth watching much closer. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Face One Huge Horcoff Question At A Crossroads
Shawn Horcoffs interim status has turned the Red Wings front office into something of a holding pattern, even as the roster keeps pushing the question of what comes next. Detroit is sitting at a crossroads where the same core can be viewed through two very different lenses, with one path built around immediate help and another aimed at a longer reconstruction around younger talent.
The tension is easy to see in the way the hypothetical trade market is being framed. Dylan Larkin would push the conversation toward established players who can help right away, while Simon Edvinsson points more toward a return that keeps the door open for the future, but Horcoffs temporary job makes it harder to know how aggressively the team can commit to either direction until a more permanent answer arrives. [Read more 🡒]