A proposed blockbuster between Detroit and Buffalo would check a lot of boxes on paper, but it still leaves the Red Wings staring at the same problem that started this whole mess.
The idea from PuckGM sends Dylan Larkin, unsigned defenseman Simon Edvinsson and prospect Axel Sandin-Pellikka to the Sabres. In return, Detroit would get 2021 first-overall pick Owen Power, along with forwards Noah Östlund, Konsta Helenius and Beck Malenstyn.
It’s the kind of deal that looks busy enough to feel like a solution. It even lines up financially. Power carries an $8.35 million cap hit, which is close to Larkin’s $8.7 million, and Detroit’s projected payroll would land around $82 million, leaving roughly $22 million in room.
But the roster issue doesn’t disappear just because the math works.
Detroit still would need a No. 1 center, and that’s the part this proposal can’t fix. Östlund and Helenius have only 102 combined NHL games, while Larkin has played 818. Last season, Larkin produced 67 points, and Power is a defenseman, not the center the Red Wings would be trying to replace.
That’s why Detroit has pushed for a No. 1 center to come back in any Larkin deal, even though that ask is widely seen as unrealistic. It also explains why this pitch falls short of what the Red Wings say they want.
The Larkin situation is already at a breaking point. He requested a trade in June, has refused to play, and Detroit suspended him without pay.
Edvinsson is in a separate contract standoff, with the two sides unable to agree on an extension before the Dec. 1 deadline that would allow him to play this season. His camp has reportedly wanted either a two-year deal or the seven-year maximum, while Detroit prefers a shorter bridge.
Interim general manager Shawn Horcoff has said he has zero interest in trading him.
Buffalo would get the more straightforward haul in this proposal: a center who scored 70 points in 2024-25 and 67 last season, plus a young defenseman who projects as a top-pairing player and would likely be tied up long term.
Still, there’s another obstacle. Larkin has not included the Sabres on his list of 10 teams he’s willing to join.
So while the trade pitch gives Buffalo production and Detroit a pile of young assets and cap flexibility, it doesn’t solve the central problem in Detroit.
In Other News...
Red Wings Suddenly Have A Goalie Problem They Feared Again
John Gibsons night against Tampa Bay ended early, and for the Red Wings, that was the kind of sight they were hoping not to see again. The veteran goaltender left with a lower-body injury and did not return, forcing Daniil Tarasov into the crease as Detroit tried to navigate the rest of the game without knowing how serious the issue might be.
The immediate concern now is less about one game and more about what comes next. The Red Wings are waiting on word on Gibsons status and how long he might be out, and if the injury keeps him sidelined, Detroit may have to look deeper into its goaltending depth sooner than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Still Have A Ben Chiarot Problem They Can't Ignore
Detroits defense has come a long way overall, but one familiar problem keeps hanging around. Ben Chiarot has struggled in a top-pair role next to Moritz Seider, and the Red Wings cant really afford to keep pretending that pairing is working if they want the blue line to hold up over the long haul. The rest of the group has improved enough to make the issue stand out even more, because the weak link is harder to hide when the unit as a whole is trending in the right direction.
Shawn Horcoff is now in the middle of trying to sort out the roster picture, and the pressure is only going to build as the calendar keeps moving. Detroit is also trying to shore up its defensive depth, which leaves the club weighing a few different paths if Chiarots play does not turn around, including a possible trade or a shakeup in the pairings. The next stretch matters because the Red Wings need a cleaner answer on the back end before the current setup starts to feel even more fragile. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Hit A Frustrating Larkin Roadblock In Trade Talks
The Dylan Larkin trade chatter has taken on a familiar kind of frustration for Detroit, where the Red Wings are trying to navigate a market that has not cooperated. Larkins name has surfaced in reports as the club looks for a workable path forward, but the process has been slowed by the limits already in place, leaving the front office with fewer options than it would like as it weighs what comes next.
There has also been some behind-the-scenes pressure to widen the field, with Detroit still searching for a deal that makes sense under the current restrictions. For a team trying to manage both its present and its future, the stalemate only adds another layer to a situation that has already become more complicated than anyone around the club would prefer. [Read more 🡒]