The Red Wings’ goaltending picture through the first quarter of the season has been anything but steady, but one thing is already clear: John Gibson hasn’t been the guy Detroit has needed, while Daniil Tarasov has given the team a real lift.
Through 21 games, the numbers point in the same direction as the eye test. Gibson entered the season as the No. 1 goalie, yet Tarasov has been the better performer by a wide margin.
All situations
TOI
GA
Save %
GAA
GSAA
HDSV %
xG against
John Gibson
689:21
41
0.862
3.57
-8.48
0.727
32.56
Daniil Tarasov
488:27
15
0.931
1.84
8.65
0.880
25.87
(Stats provided by Natural Stat Trick)
Gibson’s rough opening has echoed what happened a year ago. The 33-year-old stumbled out of the gate last season too, going 4-7-1 with a 3.59 GAA and a 0.865 save percentage through November. He settled in once December arrived, then ripped off a 19-5-1 stretch with a 2.06 GAA and a 0.925 save percentage through February.
Detroit is obviously hoping for that kind of turnaround again, but the situation is different this time. Last season, Gibson at least had the built-in excuse of adjusting after being traded to Detroit by the Anaheim Ducks, the only organization he had played for before the move. That explanation is gone now, and if he wants to keep getting the bulk of the starts, he has to rediscover his game.
So far, there have been too many nights where Gibson has simply missed saves an average goalie is expected to make. That’s a sharp drop from last season, when he was stealing games and helping push the Red Wings toward the top of the NHL standings.
This year, he hasn’t stolen one yet. In fact, Detroit has scored four or more goals in three of his four wins, which says plenty about how much support he’s needed to come out on top.
Tarasov, meanwhile, has been a pleasant surprise. Signed to a one-year deal over the offseason, the 27-year-old was expected to give Detroit 25-30 starts, back up Gibson and provide steady, replacement-level play when called upon.
Instead, he’s been far better than that.
Tarasov spent four seasons in Columbus before backing up Sergei Bobrovsky with the Florida Panthers last season, a down year for a team that was without Matthew Tkachuk for most of the season and Aleksander Barkov for all of it. But in Detroit, he’s made timely stops and kept games within reach.
His first start ended in a 1-0 shootout loss to the Montreal Canadiens. Five days later, he followed that with a 2-1 win over the Philadelphia Flyers. Last week, he added his second shutout of the season in a 2-0 victory against the Tampa Bay Lightning.
There’s still a question about whether Tarasov can handle a full-time workload, especially since he has only started more than 30 games once in his career. Last season with the Panthers, he posted a 3.05 GAA and a 0.895 save percentage.
But right now, he’s done enough to make a strong case for being Detroit’s starter for the foreseeable future.
Michal Postava has also gotten his first taste of NHL action early this season, continuing the momentum from last year when he passed Sebastian Cossa as the top goalie for the Grand Rapids Griffins.
Postava first appeared on Oct. 22, coming in for Gibson and allowing one goal on eight shots. Four days later, he made his first NHL start, and it came in a daunting spot against Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and the Edmonton Oilers.
That kind of assignment can go sideways fast, but Postava handled it well. He stopped 24 of 27 shots and helped Detroit win the shootout.
Getting him NHL minutes now matters. The Red Wings already learned the hard way what happens when a young goalie doesn’t get that exposure, after mishandling Cossa’s development by not giving him any NHL minutes last season.
Postava should be on the Red Wings roster full time next season, which would open the door for Trey Augustine to take over as the No. 1 goalie in Grand Rapids before eventually making the jump to the NHL.
In Other News...
Red Wings Trade Talk Around Dylan Larkin Just Got More Serious
The chatter around Dylan Larkin has taken a sharper turn, and it is no longer just the usual deadline-season noise. Elliotte Friedman said the Red Wings would consider moving their captain to the Minnesota Wild if the right offer came along, a notable shift from the idea that Detroit would never entertain the thought because of the loyalty angle attached to its longtime leader.
Simon Edvinsson has also entered the conversation, with Friedman noting that clubs can discuss trades involving the restricted free agent even though nothing has materialized yet. Darren Dreger took it a step further by suggesting Detroit could try to move both Larkin and Edvinsson at the same time, a sign the front office may be weighing bigger roster changes as it looks to address more than one need at once. [Read more 🡒]
Todd McLellan Just Put Detroits Biggest Problem On Blast
Todd McLellan did not sugarcoat where the Red Wings stand after their 3-1 loss to the Bruins, and the frustration was easy to hear in the aftermath. Detroit has been fighting to find any kind of rhythm, and the coach pointed to the same problems that have followed the team through recent stretches: trouble sustaining momentum and too little offense coming from beyond the top of the lineup.
The concern is bigger than one off night because the Red Wings are sitting near the bottom of the standings and need more from their depth if they are going to climb out of it. McLellan also addressed Alex DeBrincats scoring slump, but he made it clear he expects that dry spell to pass, leaving the more pressing issue on the rest of the forward group to answer. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Gave An Unknown Forward An Impossible Debut Mission
When Gordie Howe went down with an injury in 1958, the Red Wings had to reach into the depths of their system and hand Brian Smith an assignment few young forwards could have imagined. Called up from the Hamilton Tiger Cubs, Smith was thrust into a Detroit lineup built around one of the sports biggest stars, and the opportunity came with all the pressure that comes from filling in for a legend.
Smith stuck around long enough to carve out a small place in Red Wings history, eventually scoring his first NHL goal in 1960 before a serious knee injury began to alter the course of his career. His final game in the league came with Detroit in December 1961, closing a brief but memorable run for a player whose debut arrived under impossible circumstances and whose path never quite followed the one that first opened for him. [Read more 🡒]
