Michigan’s latest off-field mess has only sharpened the contrast with Michigan State’s NCAA punishment, and the gap is hard to ignore.
For months, Wolverines fans have leaned on the “wins forfeited” graphic that includes Michigan State, Penn State, and Ohio State, using it as a jab at rivals who’ve already been hit by the NCAA. But Michigan’s own sign-stealing scandal has been treated far more lightly than many expected. The punishment handed down included fines, a short suspension for then-head coach Sherrone Moore, a 10-year NCAA “ban” for Jim Harbaugh, an eight-year ban for Connor Stalions, and four years of probation with lost official visits and limits on some recruiting communication.
For a case tied to one of the biggest scandals in college athletics, that looks light.
Michigan State’s case, by comparison, brought a $30,000 fine, a penalty equal to 1.5% of the football budget, limited official visits, fewer recruiting days, several show-cause orders or “bans” for staffers, and 14 vacated wins over a three-season span. That came after the Spartans played an ineligible player, and the school fully cooperated with the NCAA. Former athletic director Alan Haller negotiated the deal before leaving.
The latest wrinkle comes from former Michigan assistant Chris Partridge, whose wrongful termination lawsuit against the university could push the NCAA to act more aggressively. In the suit, Partridge alleges that athletic director Warde Manuel and then-school president Santa Ono knew about the sign-stealing and told staffers not to bring information to compliance or the NCAA. If that allegation proves true, it points to more than just cheating - it suggests an effort to keep the whole thing buried.
Partridge also alleges that Manuel knew about the affair between Paige Shiver and Sherrone Moore and did nothing to address it. According to the lawsuit, that was swept under the rug even as the situation spiraled after it became public. Moore was then accused of stalking, harassing, and nearly harming himself after the news came out.
None of that has been proven in court, and the article makes clear these are allegations from Partridge. But if they hold up, the NCAA’s response to Michigan will look even more inadequate than it already does. The argument here is simple: if Michigan State got hammered for an ineligible player, Michigan should face something far more severe if these claims are substantiated.
In Other News...
Dylan Larkin Suddenly Looms Over One Massive Red Wings Question
The Red Wings have spent the summer watching a lot of noise swirl around other teams and other names, from Montreals reported lack of real interest in Anthony Mantha to the Predators having to trim a crowded roster and sort through trade possibilities. Even the Patrick Kane speculation has kept the rumor mill busy elsewhere, while Detroit has remained in a familiar spot where the biggest questions are still about the shape of its own roster and whether the club has done enough to move closer to contention.
What makes Dylan Larkin suddenly loom over all of it is the possibility that the dynamic around Detroit could change if Steve Yzerman is no longer the one steering the front office. The Red Wings have not exactly made offseason moves that scream playoff push, so any shift at the top would naturally send a ripple through the organization and back toward its captain. For a team still trying to define its next step, that kind of uncertainty is hard to ignore. [Read more 🡒]
Steve Yzerman Just Forced A Massive Red Wings Turning Point
The offseason around the Red Wings keeps getting busier, and one of the more notable moves came in Winnipeg, where Cole Perfetti landed a five-year extension that keeps him in place through the 2030-31 season. It is the kind of long-term commitment that helps a team settle its core, and it comes as Detroit continues to navigate a very different kind of uncertainty at the top of its own organization.
Edmonton also made a significant swing in reshaping its goaltending picture, adding Tristan Jarry, Devon Levi and Frederik Andersen to a roster that now looks markedly different in net. For Detroit, the bigger question is what comes next in its front office search, with the organization now weighing its options and trying to determine who will guide the next phase of the rebuild. [Read more 🡒]
Three Forgotten Red Wings Defense Prospects Still Matter More Than Fans Think
A few of the Red Wings 2023 draft defensemen have kept moving along in college hockey this season, even if they have slipped out of the daily conversation around Detroits prospect pool. Larry Keenan at UMass, Jack Phelan at Wisconsin and Brady Cleveland at Minnesota Duluth have all carved out meaningful roles, with each one showing the kind of defensive growth that keeps pro teams watching closely.
Keenan has added offense to his game while still handling the work that matters most in his own end, Phelan has settled in as a dependable stay-at-home presence, and Cleveland continues to bring the size and edge that made him such an intriguing pick in the first place. None of that guarantees a quick path to the NHL, but it does mean Detroit still has three blue-line projects worth tracking as their college seasons unfold and the club weighs future contract decisions. [Read more 🡒]