Brett Hull thinks the Hockey Hall of Fame should make room for a different kind of player, and he’s got one name at the front of the line: Bob Probert.
Hull, who entered the Hall in 2009 after piling up 741 goals, said there ought to be a separate enforcer category, and that Probert should be the first player honored there. Probert, who died of a heart attack at 45 on July 5, 2010, was part of Detroit’s feared “The Bruise Brothers” tandem with Joey Kocur in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
That pairing did more than police the ice for Steve Yzerman. Probert also had real scoring punch, finishing his career with 163 goals.
His best offensive season came in 1987-88, when he scored 29 goals and was named an All-Star. He also broke Gordie Howe’s franchise record for most playoff points with 21 in 16 games.
“I've said it for years now that Bob Probert should be the first guy in the Hall of Fame in that niche category, the enforcer-type, Ice Guardian guy,” Hull said on “Ice Guardians,” the podcast he hosts with former St. Louis Blues teammate Kelly Chase.
“There was (ex-Montreal Canadien) John Ferguson back in the day and his many Cup wins (five Cups in eight years), but I think Probie would be your inaugural guy.”
Probert was drafted by the Red Wings in the third round in 1983 and went on to collect 3,300 penalty minutes over a 16-year NHL career, good for fifth all-time. The 6-foot-3, 225-pound winger also logged 246 fighting majors, including 14 bouts with Stu “The Grim Reaper” Grimson, who played for Chicago, Hartford, Calgary, Nashville, Anaheim and the Kings.
Hull said the conversation around Hall of Fame standards has shifted over time, and he pointed to that change as part of the case for Probert.
“We talked to Joey Kocur the other day, and we brought up Bobby Probert, and we started talking about the Hall of Fame,” Hull said. “It was always, 500 goals, 1,000 points, five Stanley Cups, whatever their criteria kind of was, and then it started to morph a little bit.
“Then all of a sudden, Guy Carbonneau got in, and it's like, OK, he was obviously a really great player, but if you were gonna define Carbonneau, it would be as a defensive player. So now we're going to acknowledge these guys that maybe didn't get 500 goals.”
Grimson, now an NHL Network analyst, was also on the podcast and backed Hull’s idea. He said Probert belonged in the Hall in an enforcer category and argued that his game went well beyond the fighting reputation.
“He (Probert) was a guy who scored 29 goals and was in the All-Star game,” Grimson said. “I don't think we've ever seen a package as complete as Probie, who could bring that physical element and was just gifted. He was a top-six guy and nobody wanted to fight him.
“Another way of looking at it, too, is the awareness you had to have out there against Probie. He was big and he was trouble. But it was also the space he got, too, right?
“As he was driving to the net, and Steve's got the puck high in the zone, you had to decide, am I going to cross-check him or not? You kind of got him, but you don't kind of got him.”
In Other News...
Red Wings Nearly Landed Quinn Hughes But One Risk Changed Everything
The Red Wings pursuit of Quinn Hughes says plenty about where the organization sees itself and how far it still has to go. Detroit was willing to explore a major swing for one of the NHLs best defensemen, with general manager Steve Yzerman involved in the discussions and the kind of long-term commitment that would have reshaped the blue line. In a division that keeps punishing teams for every misstep, the appeal was obvious: Hughes would have been a franchise-changing fit for a club still trying to climb back into real contention.
But the risk in a move like that is just as obvious, and it is the part that hangs over every big-name chase. A player of Hughes caliber changes the ceiling of a team only if he stays, and the Red Wings have already seen how quickly a bold idea can become a cautionary tale if the fit is not right. For Detroit, the missed opportunity leaves the same familiar questions in place about how aggressively to chase help now, how much future talent to sacrifice, and whether the next big swing will finally be the one that sticks. [Read more 🡒]
Red Wings Finally Seem To Be Chasing The Identity Fans Wanted
The push for a harder edge in Detroit is showing up in more than one place this summer. On the PWHL side, Manon Rheaume is putting together a Detroit roster built around a physical, relentless style, with players known for their toughness and defensive reliability giving that group a clear on-ice personality from the start.
For Red Wings fans, the parallel is hard to miss. Detroit has spent the offseason looking for more bite and more resistance, the kind of roster layering that suggests the organization understands the old complaint about being too easy to play against. Viktor Arvidsson and Keegan Kolesar fit that direction, and Kolesar in particular brings the sort of edge that can change how opponents approach a shift, even if the bigger question is how far this identity shift will go once the lineup is set. [Read more 🡒]