The Detroit Pistons’ Isaiah Stewart move has taken another hit, and the John Collins deal is the reason why.
Detroit agreed to sign Collins to a three-year, $51 million contract, and that instantly made the Stewart trade look even shakier. The Pistons were supposed to be hunting for a true second option next to Cade Cunningham.
Instead, they ended up with a player the source frames as an empty-stats big man, and one who is viewed as a step down from Tobias Harris. In the process, Detroit also gave up an elite defender in Beef Stew and came away weaker on that side of the ball.
Collins is entering his fourth team in five years, and his recent production hasn’t changed the bigger picture. Last season with the Clippers, the 6-foot-9 forward averaged 13.6 points, 5.3 rebounds and 0.9 steals in 27.1 minutes per game.
He also shot 55.2 percent from the field and better than 40 percent from three, which will catch the eye. But the advanced numbers in the source tell a less flattering story.
Stewart ranked 90th in the NBA in win shares per 48 minutes, while Collins came in at 189th. Their VORP numbers were identical, but Collins got more than 500 additional minutes. The point is hard to miss: Detroit moved Stewart with big hopes attached, and the return has not matched the ambition.
The on-court impact numbers are ugly too. The Clippers were minus-1.5 with Collins on the floor, and 5.3 points per 100 possessions better when he sat.
That fits the larger pattern. Atlanta moved on from Collins in 2023 because he wasn’t helping them win, and the source argues nothing has really changed since.
He can still fill a box score, but the production hasn’t translated into team success. His teams have not made the playoffs since 2023 and haven’t won a first-round series since 2021.
Stewart, meanwhile, may have struggled to stay on the floor in the playoffs, but he still brings things Detroit can feel: rim protection, rebounding and interior finishing. The defense and energy matter. If Collins isn’t scoring, the value drops off fast.
And that’s the bigger problem for the Pistons. They still need another scorer and playmaker beside Cunningham, ideally someone who can handle the number-two role without hesitation.
Detroit’s interest in Kyrie Irving and Austin Reaves made sense on that front. Instead, the moves this summer have been Isaiah Joe and John Collins.
The shooting concerns got some attention, but the roster still doesn’t look like a true title contender. Cunningham is carrying the load as the lone playmaker and creator, and the team still has to find a real help piece for him.
That won’t be easy, either. The Pistons want to pay Jalen Duren and Ausar Thompson, and that leaves little room for the missing ingredient.
Swapping Beef Stew for Collins and three second-round draft picks was a tough sell from the start, and it looks even worse now. Detroit leaned away from its defensive identity, replaced Tobias Harris with Collins at the four, and didn’t really solve anything. For a team talking championship aspirations, that’s not the kind of upgrade that moves the needle.
In Other News...
Pistons Just Made Their Biggest Cade Cunningham Bet Yet
The Pistons spent the offseason behaving like a team that knows the clock is already ticking on Cade Cunninghams prime. Detroit moved up in the draft to grab Stanford guard Ebuka Okorie, then kept reshaping the roster with additions like Isaiah Joe, Kevin Huerter and John Collins, all part of a clear effort to raise the teams ceiling around its franchise point guard. It is the kind of aggressive lineup surgery that signals the front office wants more than incremental progress.
Detroit also has been willing to part with pieces to make room for that next step, including moving Isaiah Stewart in a deal that further changed the look of the frontcourt. The bigger question now is not whether the Pistons are trying to build around Cunningham, but whether these new layers of shooting, size and versatility are enough to turn a promising core into something that can truly threaten in the East before the opportunity starts to narrow. [Read more 🡒]
Jalen Duren Silence Suddenly Feels Bigger For The Pistons
Jalen Durens restricted free agency has gone quiet at the exact moment the Pistons would prefer it did not, because the market around him has thinned in a way that makes Detroit look more and more like the obvious landing spot. Interest had been tied to teams such as Sacramento, the Lakers and the Celtics, but recent moves around the league have narrowed the field and left the Pistons in position to keep one of the key young pieces of their roster intact.
Detroit has reportedly put a deal on the table that it believes should be enough to bring Duren back, even if it is not the type of extension he had hoped for. The Pistons clearly value the stability he brings to a frontcourt that has to keep growing around Cade Cunningham, and for now the real question is less about whether Detroit wants him than whether any outside option still exists that can realistically change the picture. [Read more 🡒]
Shocking East Trade May Have Just Changed Everything For The Pistons
The Easts latest blockbuster sent shockwaves through the market, with Boston moving Jaylen Brown to Philadelphia for Paul George plus a package of future draft picks. For the Pistons, the move matters well beyond the teams directly involved because it reshapes what wings and other coveted trade targets are suddenly worth around the league, especially for a franchise still mapping out its next aggressive roster upgrade.
Detroit has been keeping an eye on names like Trey Murphy III, and this kind of deal can reset the conversation around what a fair price looks like. If the market for premium two-way talent starts to soften, the Pistons may find more room to maneuver, and they still have enough draft capital on hand to make a serious push if the right player becomes available. [Read more 🡒]