The Cavaliers made the splash, but it’s fair to wonder whether they actually made themselves better.
Cleveland landed Peyton Watson in a five-team deal that sent out Max Strus and an unprotected first-round pick, and that wasn’t the full cost. To get the move done, the Cavaliers also had to clear payroll and extend Watson for 4 years at $88 million. That meant moving Dennis Schroder as well, stripping away more of the veteran depth that mattered to them in the playoffs.
That part matters, especially for anyone who watched Cleveland against Detroit last spring. Strus and Schroder were both real factors for the Cavaliers in that series, and both are now gone. Watson brings youth and upside, sure, but Cleveland paid for it by thinning out the group that already knew how to win games in the postseason.
And the production profile is not exactly screaming certainty.
Watson has averaged three points per game in his limited playoff experience, and the “breakout” season people are leaning on deserves a closer look. Last year was the first time he averaged double figures, finishing at more than 14 points per game, but he played only 54 games and did most of that damage while Nikola Jokic was out.
Jokic missed time from January 2-29, which lined up with Watson’s best stretch. He got a bigger role and took advantage, but that kind of role won’t be waiting for him in Cleveland, where he projects as the fourth option.
Take those Jokic-less games away, and Watson was closer to eight points per game. The Nuggets also passing on paying him even $22 million a year says something, especially for a team that is cheap but also smart.
The fit comparison with Strus is part of why this trade feels so debatable. Watson is bigger and more athletic and clearly the better defender, and he’s much younger. But Strus was better on the glass, and he was the better 3-point shooter too, even though he took about twice as many threes per game while posting roughly the same percentage.
A lot of the optimism around Watson is built on those 13 standout games when Jokic was sidelined, and that’s a risky way to project the future. Cleveland clearly wanted a younger piece to pair with Evan Mobley and Donovan Mitchell in the post-Harden years, and there’s logic in chasing that kind of upside.
Still, the Cavaliers had to sacrifice important depth and take on more payroll to do it, and they may have paid a premium for an unproven player.
From a Pistons perspective, the best part might be simpler than all the trade math: Max Strus is no longer in a Cavaliers uniform.
In Other News...
John Collins Could Change How The Pistons Close Games
The Pistons went into the offseason looking for a different kind of answer in crunch time, and John Collins is part of that search. Detroit added the power forward to help stabilize a clutch offense that too often leaned on options that did not create enough pressure late in games, and his presence gives the group a new look around the arc and at the rim.
Collins brings a blend of shooting, finishing and offensive rebounding that should widen the floor for Detroit when possessions get tight. Tobias Harris was part of the late-game mix last season, but Collins offers a more varied way to attack those closing stretches, and the Pistons are counting on that versatility to give them more solutions when the outcome is still up for grabs. [Read more 🡒]
Pistons Have A Jalen Duren Decision They Cant Afford To Rush
The market for young, homegrown talent keeps getting more complicated, and the Pistons are watching that reality play out far beyond Detroit. With Jalen Duren eligible to enter the kind of contract conversation that can shape a franchise for years, the front office has reason to be deliberate, especially after seeing how quickly another promising core can become expensive once extensions start stacking up.
Denvers recent handling of its own young pieces has only reinforced that caution, showing how a big commitment to one player can squeeze a team into harder choices elsewhere. For Detroit, the lesson is simple enough: Duren matters, but the wrong timing or the wrong number can force a roster into decisions it would rather not make. [Read more 🡒]