Urban Meyer is not mincing words about Michigan’s quarterback situation. After watching the latest stretch, he says Tommy Carr has earned the starting job over Bryce Underwood, and the biggest reason is simple: Carr has fit the offense far better.
Meyer laid out his case on Dan Dakich’s Outkick show, pointing to the fact that Carr has been able to step in and run the same system with far less disruption than Underwood has brought to the table. That, in Meyer’s view, matters even more this late in the year.
“Tommy Carr is a guy that Kyle Whittingham has been talking (about),” Meyer said. “I talk to Coach Whitt every couple of weeks.
And he loves the kid. But he actually loved Bryce Underwood.
He's a great worker, incredible talent. He's the only first-round talent I saw on that field.
We covered him a couple times this year. He's a freak athlete.
"Against Oklahoma, he ran, and he played a really good game against Iowa. So I thought he was starting to come together.
And then it hasn't been good. So normally when you have like a Chris Leak and a Tebow, they're two completely different offenses.
And you have a different game plan. I watched what they did with Tommy Carr.
They ran the exact same. He scored on a Bryce Underwood play.
And he almost scored on another Bryce Underwood play. So they're running the same offense.
So the transition wasn't that difficult.
If you have two different styles of offenses, it really cuts into your practice time, especially this late in the year. So, but I think that Coach Whitt can say whatever he wants, Tommy Carr is your starting quarterback.
Oh, yeah, it's over. He has to, yeah.
He scored 21 points. They lose that game if Bryce Underwood's in that game."
Even with that blunt endorsement for Carr, Meyer did not write off Underwood. He said the quarterback still showed the kind of engagement that suggests Michigan isn’t done with him.
“The positive is, and I watch closely, is he was so engaged,” Meyer said. “He must be a hell of a guy. You know, he must be.
“A lot of times you would think he might pack his bags and go, but he was engaged. He's fully engaged.
He's still relatively young. I'm not giving up on Bryce Underwood.
I saw what I saw. I see a freak athlete that probably played before he was ready.
So I would not give up on that kid. And what does that mean?
For Kyle Whittingham, all he's got to do is find a way to compete against Indiana. He can't worry about that.
At some point, you gotta worry about that. Not now.”
Meyer’s comments come ahead of Michigan’s meeting with Indiana on Saturday in Ann Arbor. Kickoff is set for 12:10 p.m. EDT, with Meyer on site for Fox’s broadcast.
In Other News...
Jahmyr Gibbs Faces A Familiar Packers Problem At The Worst Time
Jahmyr Gibbs has been one of the NFLs most dangerous finishers this season, and Detroit is leaning on him again as it tries to get back on track in the division. The Lions head into another meeting with Green Bay looking for their first win over the Packers since 2024, and Gibbs will be central to that push after emerging as the offenses touchdown leader.
The matchup, though, has not always brought out his biggest rushing afternoons. In six career games against Green Bay, Gibbs has averaged 48.2 rushing yards and scored twice, even as the Packers run defense has been merely average this season. Detroit knows what it needs from its backfield, but this remains one of those rivalries where production has been harder to bank on than the name on the stat sheet suggests. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Run Defense Just Got A Brutal Week 7 Twist
The Lions run defense is about to get a very different test in Week 7. Josh Jacobs has been activated to the Packers roster, giving Green Bay a needed boost after he missed the entire season to this point and the offense sputtered to the bottom of the league on the ground. For Detroit, the timing matters because this matchup now looks less like a chance to feast on a struggling rushing attack and more like a battle against a back who can change the feel of a game.
Jacobs return comes after his off-field situation shifted enough to clear the way back onto the roster, and Green Bay suddenly has a player it has been missing all season. For the Lions, it adds a layer of urgency to a unit that has built its identity on controlling the line of scrimmage. The Packers may still be trying to find their footing, but this is no longer the same rushing opponent Detroit was preparing for a week ago. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Have A Tom Kennedy Replacement Decision Still Hanging Over Sunday
Tom Kennedys injury leaves the Lions with a straightforward special teams problem and a familiar name ready to step in. Detroit special teams coordinator Dave Fipp said DeAndre Carter brings the kind of experience the team wants in the return game, and the veteran is the logical option to take on both punt and kickoff duties after Kennedy goes down.
The wrinkle is procedural, not positional. Carter is still on the practice squad, so Detroit has to make a roster move before he can actually suit up on game day, either by signing him to the active roster or elevating him for the matchup. For now, the Lions have a clear answer in mind, but the final paperwork still has to be sorted before Sunday. [Read more 🡒]