The NCAA’s football oversight committee says Michigan’s Week 1 escape against Western Michigan would not have ended the same way if the proper replay timing procedures had been used.
In a Wednesday statement, the committee said the result “would have been different” had officiating protocols been followed correctly. But it also made clear that it “does not have the authority to overturn the contest.”
Michigan’s 13-12 win came after a chaotic finish in which the officiating crew added one second to the clock after the game appeared to be over. That decision set up Bryce Underwood’s 47-yard Hail Mary to JJ Buchanan, turning what looked like a loss into a Wolverines victory.
The Mid-American Conference responded by filing a formal appeal with the NCAA’s FBS Oversight Committee and the College Football Playoff, asking both to recognize Western Michigan as the winner. That request has not been granted.
The fallout has already produced changes. Before Week 2, NCAA secretary rules-editor for football Matt Young issued timing guidance saying decisions should be based on the “embedded game clock contained within the program feed.”
Under that standard, no time would have been restored in the Western Michigan-Michigan game.
The Big Ten has also adjusted how it handles replay review transparency during TV broadcasts, now showing live audio of conversations between field and replay officials along with the video the crew is reviewing.
The game was officiated by a Big Ten crew, and the league said the officials were correct to put a second back on the clock. That view does not line up with the FBS Oversight Committee’s assessment.
In Other News...
Jake Bates Just Changed The Lions Conversation In A Big Way
Week 1 brought plenty of strange endings around the league, but none mattered more in Detroit than the way Jake Bates handled his first real test. In a season opener that ended 31-30 in overtime against the Saints, the Lions leaned on their kicker in a game that had to be decided one point at a time, and Bates answered by making all five of his kick attempts while accounting for seven points, including the extra point that finished it.
For a player who came into the season with preseason questions hanging over him, that kind of night changes the tone around the position immediately. The Lions are 1-0, and while the opener did not settle every concern in the building, it gave Detroit a clean look at a kicker who suddenly has a much different place in the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Brad Holmes May Have Found A Lions Rookie They Can't Ignore
Skyler Gill-Howard arrived in Detroit with the kind of profile that usually points to a practice-squad path, not a quick climb into the game plan. But the rookie defensive tackle worked his way onto the 53-man roster and then made his presence felt right away against the New Orleans Saints, turning in the highest PFF defensive grade among rookie defensive tackles in Week 1 with a 71.6 mark.
For a Lions front that leans on depth and disruption, that kind of debut is exactly the sort of thing that gets attention in the building. Gill-Howard has already sounded comfortable with his role, and with Buffalo next on the schedule, the question now is whether his first real impression turns into something the Lions can keep counting on as the matchups get tougher. [Read more 🡒]
Stephen A. Smith Just Turned One Lions Concern Into A Real Debate
The Lions got the season started with an overtime win over the Saints, but the way they arrived there left plenty of room for national second-guessing. On ESPNs First Take, Stephen A. Smith zeroed in on Detroits defense after the team squandered a 21-point lead, pointing to a performance that still looked too shaky for a club trying to build on last seasons momentum.
Smith had no issue with the offense, which again looked like the kind of unit that can carry a team for long stretches. His concern was whether the defense can clean up enough to keep Detroit in the division hunt and make the playoffs, and it is the sort of question that tends to linger until the Lions prove otherwise. [Read more 🡒]