Lions Rookie Debate Is Already Centered On One Crucial Position Battle

The future of the Detroit Lions' success in the 2026 NFL season hinges on standout performances from rookies Derrick Moore and Blake Miller, who are both strong contenders for the team's Rookie of the Year.

The Detroit Lions’ 2026 rookie class may be small in terms of premium draft capital, but it already looks like it could matter in a big way. Detroit made only two picks in the first three rounds, yet five rookies landed on the 53-man roster, and at least three of them are expected to take on significant-to-major roles this season.

So who ends up as the team’s Rookie of the Year?

Around the staff, the race has basically narrowed to two names: Derrick Moore and Blake Miller.

Moore is the pick for Ryan Mathews, Brandon Knapp and Jeremy Reisman. Mathews pointed to the Lions trading up to land Moore in the second round, a move that signals how strongly they view him as a difference-maker. He also noted that Moore’s preseason work and training camp showing suggested he is exactly what Detroit needed on the defensive line.

Knapp made the case from the other side of the line, saying Moore gets the edge because of the players around him. With Aidan Hutchinson, Alim McNeill, Tyliek Williams and DJ Wonnum in the mix, Knapp expects opposing offenses to focus heavily on Hutchinson and the interior, which should leave Moore with plenty of one-on-one chances to cash in.

Reisman also landed on Moore, while making it clear this wasn’t a knock on Miller. He wrote that Moore could deliver a bigger overall positive impact because of the position he plays, where his wins matter more and his mistakes are easier to cover up. Reisman added that Moore should get on the field early as a pass-rushing specialist and could finish with 6-8 sacks.

Miller, though, had the larger share of support. John Whiticar, Erik Schlitt, Al Karsten, Morgan Cannon and Anthony Balaj all chose the first-round right tackle.

Whiticar called Miller the favorite for the award, saying that while Moore, Keith Abney and Skyler Gill-Howard could all help right away, Miller is the one to beat because of where he plays and the importance of the position on the offensive line. He said Miller has both the talent and the opportunity to stand out as a rookie.

Schlitt agreed, calling Miller a day-one starter who looks like a ready-made NFL right tackle. He expects rookie growing pains, but also believes Miller will be a steady presence and a key piece in the run game.

Karsten took the long view, saying Miller will go through some early peaks and valleys before proving the Lions made a smart investment in the trenches by Halloween. He expects the offensive line to start looking “scary” by then, which would help Drew Petzing use the team’s skill-position talent more freely. Karsten called Miller one of the most important stabilizing rookie additions of the Dan Campbell-Brad Holmes era.

Cannon described his pick as the chalky one, but still went with Miller, praising his battle-tested college background at Clemson and the athletic profile that could really show once he settles in as a pro. Cannon said that if Miller can lock down the right side opposite perennial All-Pro Penei Sewell, the Lions should feel good about the selection.

Balaj also backed Miller, saying that while Skyler Gill-Howard and Moore may provide the flashier moments, Miller has already shown enough through the end of training camp to ease concerns. For Balaj, a rookie tackle stepping into the starting lineup without much trouble is a major win for the organization.

That leaves the Lions with a clear early storyline: Moore is the disruptive defensive front option with upside to pop, while Miller is the plug-and-play lineman who could become the steadying force. Either way, Detroit’s 2026 rookie class is already positioned to play a real role.

In Other News...

Lions Get A Brutal O-Line Warning Before Jared Goff's Season Begins

PFFs latest 2026 offensive line rankings offered a sobering reminder that even a roster built to win up front can feel fragile once injuries enter the picture. The Lions came in at No. 19, a mark that lands well below the expectation around a group that has usually been one of the team's biggest strengths and, in this case, slipped largely because of the injury to starting center Cade Mays.

The drop from 13th to just inside the top 20 is the kind of warning sign Detroit cannot ignore with Jared Goffs season approaching. Analyst Gordon McGuinness pointed to the lines current composition as the concern, and for a team that has leaned on protection and continuity to keep its offense on schedule, the question now is whether the group can hold up long enough to avoid becoming a problem before the games even start. [Read more 🡒]

Lions Suddenly Have A Week 1 Depth Concern Fans Should Watch

The Lions got through Thursdays practice with a fairly routine injury report as they turn their attention to the Saints, but there was still a little uncertainty attached to the week. Several players were full participants, while Derrick Moore, Mekhi Wingo and Christian Izien were limited as the team continued sorting through a few lingering health issues ahead of game planning.

Dan Campbell offered a cautious read on where things stand, and the overall tone sounded more hopeful than alarmed. Even so, any limited practice reps this late in the week are worth watching for a Detroit roster trying to get everyone lined up before Week 1, especially with a matchup against New Orleans approaching fast. [Read more 🡒]

Lions Open Week 1 With Pressure On Unproven Replacements

The Lions will begin their 2026 season at home against the Saints, and Week 1 already carries an added layer of scrutiny beyond the usual opener nerves. Detroit enters with key safeties Kerby Joseph and Brian Branch unavailable early, which pushes a handful of lesser-established names into more visible roles right away.

Jake Bates, Ennis Rakestraw, Thomas Harper, Avonte Maddox, Chuck Clark and Christian Mahogany all enter the opener with something to prove, whether it is due to injuries, past inconsistency or simple roster uncertainty. For a team trying to get its season off on the right foot, those replacement-level decisions could matter quickly, especially in a game where early missteps tend to linger. [Read more 🡒]