In a move that’s left many scratching their heads, the Detroit Lions opted not to retain defensive end Al-Quadin Muhammad, despite his impressive 11-sack season last year. Instead, they signed D.J. Wonnum on a one-year, $3 million deal, while Muhammad found a new home in Tampa Bay for just $1 million more, plus incentives.
Muhammad’s journey from a sixth-round pick in 2017 to a practice squad player in 2024, and then to a standout pass rusher, is nothing short of remarkable. Yet, when it came time to cash in on his success, the Lions seemed to let him slip away.
The decision raises eyebrows, especially when considering Wonnum’s modest three sacks last season with Carolina. From a pass-rushing perspective, this seems like a downgrade opposite the Lions’ star, Aidan Hutchinson.
So, what’s the story here? Do the Lions know something about Muhammad that the rest of us don’t?
It’s puzzling, especially since Muhammad’s contract in Tampa could reach up to $6 million with incentives. What happened at the negotiating table that allowed him to leave?
Perhaps it’s about future planning. With extensions looming for the 2023 draft class stars like Jack Campbell and Jahmyr Gibbs, maybe the Lions are playing the long game. But this is about the upcoming season, and the questions surrounding Muhammad and Wonnum are plenty.
Did Muhammad turn down a low-ball offer from Detroit? These uncertainties only add to the scrutiny on GM Brad Holmes’ offseason moves. Holmes and head coach Dan Campbell have transformed the Lions’ culture, but after a couple of underwhelming drafts and missing the playoffs in 2025, the pressure is mounting.
Historically, this Lions regime has been about rewarding their own players and securing extensions early. Muhammad, though not originally drafted by Detroit, was a revelation they could have doubled down on. His departure remains a mystery.
Replacing Muhammad with Wonnum, who ranked near the bottom in PFF’s pass rush grades, doesn’t seem to be an upgrade. The Lions might be eyeing the draft for another defensive end or planning another free-agent move.
Whatever their strategy, the Lions’ decision to let Muhammad go speaks volumes. They’re banking on Wonnum rediscovering his 2023 form, where he notched eight sacks, and hoping Muhammad doesn’t shine too brightly for the Buccaneers.