The Detroit Lions are heading into their bye week with their defense still under a microscope, and the biggest question around Kelvin Sheppard is no longer just about play-calling. ESPN analyst Bill Barnwell pointed the finger at the roster itself, arguing that Detroit’s problems on that side of the ball go beyond the coordinator.
Barnwell’s view was blunt. He noted that the Lions are "a disaster on defense, ranking 29th in points allowed per drive and last in EPA per play. They can't get off the field on third down and have allowed teams to convert 81% of their red zone trips into touchdowns, the third-worst figure in the league."
He then pushed the conversation toward personnel rather than scheme. "Is that on coaching?
I'm skeptical. Watching the Lions closely, I see a defense that simply doesn't have enough talent as opposed to one that makes routine schematic mistakes.
The Lions comfortably have the worst secondary in the NFL, a product of injuries (which have cost them one of the league's best safety duos in Brian Branch and Kerby Joseph) and off-field behavior (leading to the release of 2024 first-round pick Terrion Arnold, who admittedly wasn't living up to expectations before being cut amid felony charges of armed robbery and kidnapping)."
That line of thinking puts plenty of pressure on general manager Brad Holmes and how the roster was built this offseason. It also explains why several names in the secondary - Clark, McCreary, Izien and others - have been mentioned as players who’ve flashed at times but still need much more consistency.
The Lions did at least give Sheppard and the defense something to build on in Week 5. After a rough stretch and a tough loss in Week 4 that raised questions about whether Detroit should move on from Sheppard if things didn’t improve, the unit answered with a 45-21 win over the Arizona Cardinals. That result bought Sheppard more time, at least for now.
Detroit’s defense looked far better against Arizona, especially during a stretch of five straight stops in the first half that helped the Lions seize control. Dan Campbell noticed the difference immediately and made sure to praise Sheppard and his staff afterward.
"I thought we were sticky in coverage, very disciplined minus a couple of plays. I thought (Kelvin) Sheppard and the staff did an outstanding job and the players really responded.
They took it to heart and tried to do all the little things right and play with aggressiveness and just really set the tone for the day. The offense fed off of that.
Once we found our rhythm, the defense fed off of them and special teams."
Campbell still made it clear that one strong afternoon doesn’t erase the larger issue. "I just thought it was a great team effort.
We cleaned up a lot of the little stuff. It's not good enough.
We're gonna have to be a hell of a lot better when we play Green Bay coming out of the bye, but that was a step in the right direction. It got us to win number three."
There’s still time for the Lions to alter the picture. Brian Branch is expected back, and Detroit could also pursue help at cornerback before the November 10 deadline. If that kind of talent arrives, some of the current problems might look a lot less severe.
For now, though, Sheppard remains in the middle of the storm. The win over Arizona eased the pressure, but it didn’t erase it. Both the coordinator and the defense still have plenty to prove.
In Other News...
Lions May Have A Cheap Secondary Fix They Didn't Expect
Alontae Taylors situation in Tennessee is suddenly worth watching, and not just because the Titans have already started to shuffle pieces around in their secondary. The cornerback, who had built a reputation for stronger play with the Saints, has seen that stock dip since arriving in Tennessee, and now Detroit is being mentioned as a possible landing spot if the Lions decide they want another inexpensive way to bolster their back end.
For a Detroit defense that has been searching for answers in the secondary, Taylor is the kind of name that can make sense on paper: young enough to matter, experienced enough to help, and potentially available if Tennessees view of his fit keeps going south. Nothing has been finalized, but the possibility alone is enough to keep an eye on, especially if the Lions are looking for a move that could change their defensive depth without costing them much. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Face A Tough Week 7 Test If One Defensive Issue Lingers
The Lions are headed into a Week 7 home meeting with the Packers in a spot that should draw plenty of attention, especially with Green Bay bringing a very different look than the version Detroit saw in past seasons. The Packers have made major changes in both the coaching staff and the roster, including the arrival of Jonathan Gannon as head coach along with a number of personnel moves on both sides of the ball, and that kind of turnover can make an opponent harder to project from one week to the next.
For Detroit, the bigger concern is whether a lingering defensive issue shows up again at the wrong time. The Lions can get by when their defense is organized and on schedule, but this matchup has the feel of one where any uncertainty could matter, particularly against a Packers team still sorting out its identity. If the same problem hangs around into Sunday, it could turn a straightforward divisional test into a much trickier afternoon than the Lions want. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Could Have A Trade Deadline Decision Fans Wont Like
At 3-2, the Lions are still in the mix to act like buyers at the trade deadline, but the next few weeks could force a much tougher conversation if the results go sideways. In that scenario, Detroit would have to balance the push to stay competitive with the reality of roster spots, contracts and what kind of long-term value it wants to preserve.
That is where the uncomfortable part comes in, because the list of possible trade chips is not the kind of inventory fans want to see discussed in October. Amani Oruwariye, Levi Onwuzurike, Logan Stenberg, Jalen Reeves-Maybin and Brock Wright are all being mentioned as players who could go if the Lions decide to sell, and the broader picture gets even trickier when the tight end situation enters the equation. With those upcoming games carrying extra weight, the front office may be staring at a deadline decision that says as much about the season's direction as the standings do. [Read more 🡒]