Alim McNeill’s contract is already getting dragged into the national conversation, and the latest shot came from CBS Sports.
Garrett Podell named McNeill to his NFL “All-Overpaid Team” for 2026, putting the Lions defensive lineman at defensive tackle and pointing to both the injuries and the production dip that have followed his big extension.
“He's been unable to stay on the field of late, a common theme for the Lions' defense these days, missing a combined 14 games since 2023. In 2025, his 52.5 defensive grade ranked 89th out of 127 interior defensive linemen grades by Pro Football Focus.
McNeil's career-high 5.0 sacks came back in 2023, and he's accumulated just 4.5 across the last two seasons. Detroit needs much more out of McNeil with three years remaining on this albatross.
”
McNeill signed a four-year, $97 million extension before the 2024 season, and he still has three years left on the deal. That contract currently ranks 10th among defensive tackles in average annual value.
Last season was all about getting back on the field after the torn ACL he suffered in December 2024. He didn’t make his season debut until October 20 against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and over 10 games he finished with 14 tackles, one sack and three quarterback hits.
That version of McNeill never quite looked like the disruptive interior presence Detroit had before the injury. The ACL tear came the season after his extension, and it left real questions about his long-term health.
Still, when he’s right, McNeill gives the Lions exactly what they need inside: a strong run defender who can collapse the pocket as a pass rusher. He said he understands why 2025 didn’t match his standard, but believes he’s ready to show something different now.
“Physically I just wasn't all the way there like I wanted to be,” he said. “…Now I’ve got two legs and I have no excuse, and I feel wonderful out here now. I really feel like I'm back to me playing like me, getting off the ball like me, getting off blocks like I usually do.”
Detroit needs that version badly. A healthy McNeill would pair with second-year tackle Tyleik Williams to give the Lions a sturdier interior, while also adding the kind of pass-rush help the team missed last season. With Aidan Hutchinson expected to draw plenty of attention, somebody else up front has to cash in when the protection slides.
“Sometimes Mac (McNeill) is going to have to take advantage of that matchup. Then your nose tackle or the other defensive end has to win,” head coach Dan Campbell said.
"There will be times when Mac or Hutch isn't doubled, and they have to win. Mac has the ability to win one-on-one."
The pressure on the front seven is obvious, especially early in the season, because the secondary remains shaky and the defense will need help from the line and linebackers to cover for it.
That makes this a defining year for McNeill. If he rebounds, the contract starts to look a lot more reasonable. If he doesn’t, the criticism only gets louder.
It all comes down to whether he can stay healthy and deliver what Detroit paid for.
“(My job) is to stop the run and get to the quarterback,” he said. “So that falls on us directly. I take that super personal and we're going to go into the season thinking that same way.”
In Other News...
Dan Campbells Lions Bet On Roster Depth After Another O-Line Setback
The Lions spent the 2026 summer without any joint practices, and Dan Campbells reasoning came back to the same place he has leaned on so often: roster depth and internal competition. With injury concerns part of the calculation, Campbell pointed to a group he believes can push itself without outside help, including several players who made the NFLs Top 100, a sign that Detroit feels it can keep its edge in-house while sorting through camp.
Cade Mays wrist fracture has only sharpened that test up front. The newly signed center is expected to miss 8-10 weeks, leaving Tate Ratledge and Juice Scruggs to handle the work at center for now and adding another layer of uncertainty to an offensive line already dealing with a setback. For a team that wants answers from its own locker room, the next stretch will say a lot about how real that depth actually is. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Get An Early Break In A Week 1 Matchup That Matters
The Lions will head into a Week 1 matchup that already looks a little different after New Orleans lost one of its most important offensive pieces in camp. Alvin Kamara is expected to miss at least a month with a sprained MCL, which means he should be out for the season opener against Detroit as the Saints settle in under new head coach Kellen Moore.
Jordyn Tyson is also set to miss about two months because of a hamstring injury, further thinning out a Saints offense that was counting on getting through the early part of the season intact. For Detroit, it is the kind of early break that can matter in September, especially in a game where every edge helps shape the tone of the schedule. [Read more 🡒]
Lions Still Have Big Lineup Questions Heading Into Saturday
Saturdays second preseason game against the Washington Commanders comes with a familiar summer task for the Lions: sorting out a few of the most important spots on the roster before the games start counting. Right tackle is still up for grabs between rookie Blake Miller and veteran Larry Borom, while the edge rush picture has D.J. Wonnum and Ahmed Hassanein pushing to make their case. The secondary is no less unsettled, with Rock Ya-Sin seemingly in line to start opposite D.J. Reed and Keith Abney II battling Roger McCreary for the nickel job.
The back end of the defense has only become trickier with Brian Branch and Kerby Joseph on the physically unable to perform list, leaving Detroit to manage some early-season uncertainty at a premium position group. For a team that likes to build its identity on depth and versatility, these are the kinds of decisions that can shape how the first month looks, even if the final answers are still a little ways off. [Read more 🡒]