Sean Payton Suddenly Faces One Huge Broncos Question

As the Denver Broncos face offensive challenges, Coach Sean Payton is likely to reclaim play-calling duties in a bid to revitalize the team's performance.

Sean Payton may be ready to reclaim one of the biggest levers in Denver’s offense.

The possibility surfaced on October 7 when former Broncos receiver Brandon Stokley said he had heard Payton would take back play-calling duties in Week 5 against the Los Angeles Chargers. “I’m hearing that Sean Payton is going to be taking over play calling this week,” Stokley wrote on X. “Should be an interesting week.”

A day later, Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk said his group had “confirmed” that Payton would resume calling offensive plays. If that happens, Davis Webb’s run as the Broncos’ offensive play-caller would be over. Denver promoted Webb to offensive coordinator this offseason and handed him those responsibilities, but the setup appears to be headed for a change.

The move would come against the backdrop of a sluggish start. Denver opened the season with a 31-10 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs and mustered only 176 total yards in that game. Florio pointed to those struggles as the reason the Broncos might be moving back toward Payton running the offense.

The timing also lines up with the schedule. With the Chargers up next in Week 5, the change would give Payton a chance to settle back into the job before Denver turns around quickly for Thursday Night Football against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 6.

“Ultimately, it’s Payton’s team,” Florio wrote. “He needs to do whatever he thinks he should do to help the Broncos meet the high bar for 2026 that was created by their success in 2025.

And the clock is ticking. Loudly.”

Not everyone around the team seemed to be hearing the same thing. KOA’s Benjamin Allbright pushed back after Stokley’s report, saying a Broncos source told him, “Saw that - hadn’t heard it and it didn’t look that way in practice.” Allbright later said that source contacted him on Wednesday night and that the message suggested “the whole building wasn’t on the same page.”

Payton, meanwhile, downplayed the conversation around who is actually making the calls. During his October 7 media session, he said, “I think our focus needs to be more on the specifics and the detail of each play regardless,” and added, “I think the most important job I have is, really, evaluating the whys.”

Last season, Denver finished 10th in total offense and 14th in scoring. Through four games this year, the Broncos sit 27th in both categories. Now Payton may be preparing to take direct control as Denver searches for answers.

In Other News...

Sean Payton's Pat Surtain Update Should Relieve Broncos Fans

The Broncos got a meaningful bit of news on Pat Surtains ankle injury this week, with Sean Payton saying he does not expect the star cornerback to land on injured reserve. Surtain is still unlikely to suit up in Week 5, but the tone of the update suggests Denver believes the issue is short-term rather than something that will push one of its most important defenders out for an extended stretch.

For a team that leans heavily on Surtains presence in the secondary, that matters. He has already been one of Denvers most reliable players this season, and the Broncos are hoping to have him back within three weeks as they try to keep the defense on track without its top cover man. The exact return date is still uncertain, but for now the outlook appears much better than the worst-case scenario. [Read more 🡒]

Bo Nix Sends Clear Message As Broncos Criticism Keeps Growing

Bo Nix has been around long enough now to understand the noise that comes with playing quarterback in Denver, especially when the offense stumbles. After the Broncos loss to the 49ers, Nix spoke about how he handles the wave of reaction that follows every game, making it clear that the opinions he values most come from inside the building, not from fans or analysts.

For a Broncos offense still trying to find its footing as the season goes on, that approach matters. Nixs focus on coaches and teammates speaks to the kind of weekly reset Denver needs right now, with scrutiny growing and patience thinning around a unit that knows it has work to do. [Read more 🡒]

Broncos Trade Chip Just Got More Interesting After Lions' Defensive Mess

The Lions defensive issues have put a spotlight on their secondary, and the conversation has already drifted toward possible fixes. One idea floated by ESPNs Ben Solak points back to Denver, where cornerback Riley Moss has quietly become a name worth monitoring as the Broncos weigh how much value he might carry on the trade market.

Moss is only 26 and was a third-round pick, the kind of young defender a team would prefer to keep unless the return is meaningful. For Detroit, the appeal is obvious given the early-season struggles on that side of the ball, but any attempt to pry him loose would likely take a sizable draft haul and that is where the real question begins. [Read more 🡒]