The AFC West has turned quarterback debates into a weekly sport of their own, and heading into 2026, the order still starts with the same familiar name at the top. Patrick Mahomes remains the standard in the division, even with the Chiefs asking him to carry more of the load than ever. From there, the conversation gets much more interesting.
Kansas City’s offense has made life harder on Mahomes in recent years. The offensive line hasn’t held up the way it once did, the receiver group has taken a hit, and the running game has been almost nonexistent, which is part of why the team brought in Kenneth Walker in free agency.
Even so, Mahomes is still the most established quarterback in the AFC West by a wide margin. He’s a 3-time Super Bowl champion, a multiple-time MVP, and even coming off injury, he’s still the one you’d trust most if you needed a big season.
His touchdown percentage has settled around 4.5 percent over the last three years, and that may just be where the floor lives now. But if you’re betting on anyone in this division to throw 45 touchdowns in a season, Mahomes is still the obvious pick.
The No. 2 spot goes to Bo Nix, and that alone says plenty about how fast his stock has risen. There are fair arguments against putting him this high, and there’s even a case for him being the best quarterback in the division over the last two seasons.
But what Nix has already done in two years is hard to ignore. He’s helped the Broncos reach the playoffs in each of his first two seasons, guided them to the AFC Championship Game last year, and built a reputation as one of the NFL’s most clutch quarterbacks.
Including the playoffs, he has produced 11 game-winning drives. He’s also one of the better dual threats at the position.
The criticism is that he still isn’t the most efficient quarterback snap to snap, and that part of his game has to improve this season. Still, when the moment gets big, he finds a way to make it work, and he’s done it against top defenses.
Justin Herbert lands at No. 3, which is where the talent-versus-results debate really starts to bite. If this were only about physical gifts, Herbert would be the easy answer at the top of the list.
He has the strongest arm in the division, can make every throw, and remains one of the best quarterbacks in football at escaping the pocket and extending plays. But the postseason resume is impossible to ignore.
Since being drafted in 2020, Herbert has played in three playoff games, and his numbers in those games have been rough enough to raise real questions about what comes next. For all the reputation he’s built, he still hasn’t delivered in the biggest moments.
At this stage, it’s fair to expect more.
Kirk Cousins comes in last for the Raiders, whether he ends up as the presumptive starter in 2026 or the team leans into Fernando Mendoza as the future. Either way, Las Vegas is at the bottom of this quarterback group.
Cousins is no longer in his prime, but he can still play competent football. He showed that late last season with the Falcons, who were a sinking ship, and he managed some inspired stretches down the stretch.
The problem is that his ceiling is limited now. He can still function in the pocket, but he’s not the kind of quarterback who creates much on his own anymore.
His last full season as a starter was ugly, with 16 interceptions and 13 fumbles in 14 starts. He did clean up some of the turnover-worthy plays last season, but at 37, turning 38 in August, the range of outcomes is narrow: a decent floor, and not much more.
In Other News...
Overlooked Broncos Receiver Is Suddenly Forcing A Real Camp Conversation
Pat Bryant spent the latter part of the 2025 season earning more work in Denvers offense, and the second-year receiver now looks like one of the more interesting names to watch when camp opens again. Injuries slowed him before the year was over, but Broncos coach Sean Payton has already pointed to Bryants development and growing confidence as he heads into his second season.
For a player who entered the league without much fanfare, that kind of momentum matters. Bryants rise has been enough to make him a legitimate candidate for a bigger role in 2026, and if that progress carries over into training camp, he could turn from a depth piece into a real part of the conversation on offense. [Read more 🡒]
Broncos Nearly Landed A Wild Coaching Twist Nobody Saw Coming
Bill Belichick spent the 2024 season on the outside looking in after his departure from New England, and the unusual possibilities around his next stop briefly reached all the way to Denver. An ESPN report said Sean Payton and the Broncos at least kicked around the idea of a one-year setup that would have put Belichick in position to keep chasing NFL history, a reminder of how far teams will go when a coaching legend is suddenly available.
The idea never got past the concept stage, in part because of how many moving pieces it would have required, and Belichick ultimately moved on to a year off before his planned 2025 arrival at North Carolina. He also reportedly checked in with the Jets about their opening, which only adds to the sense that the coaching carousel around him was never going to be simple. For Denver, it remains one of those fascinating what-ifs that says plenty about both Paytons creativity and Belichicks lingering pull. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Puts Broncos In Top 10 And The AFC West Debate Will Rage
The Broncos head into the 2026 campaign with almost the same roster that helped them build real momentum a year ago, and that continuity is a big reason national evaluators are paying attention. ESPNs Mike Clay, Aaron Schatz and Seth Walder each saw enough to place Denver eighth in their consensus roster rankings, a nod that reflects how far the group has come as it tries to push from promising to legitimate contender.
What makes the conversation around Denver so interesting is where the roster is strongest and where it still feels unfinished. ESPN pointed to the offensive line as a clear asset, but tight end remains the spot that could keep the Broncos from looking complete, with Evan Engram coming off a season in which his role never fully matched the expectations around him. For a team trying to chase a Super Bowl run in a loaded division, that kind of imbalance is exactly the sort of detail that will keep the AFC West debate going. [Read more 🡒]