The NFL’s opening week arrived with a heavy shadow over three former players whose deaths were reported in the days before Sunday’s games.
Alphonso Smith Jr., Matt Suhey and Arthur Marshall all died within the same short stretch, leaving behind very different football stories and very different circumstances. Smith died at 40 in Florida, Suhey was found dead at 68 in his Illinois home, and Marshall died at 57 after battling stomach cancer.
Smith’s death was the most jarring. TMZ reported that he died by suicide at a housing community in Pahokee.
Before his death, he posted a final note that friends later shared. “Do not cry for me!
I tried everything in my power to fight the demons behind the ones that someone put into ME!” he wrote.
He added, “I have HURT so many! I needed help & did not get it!”
Smith came into the league as Denver’s 37th overall pick in 2009 after an All-American career at Wake Forest. He spent one season with the Broncos and then three with Detroit, finishing his NFL career with 42 games and eight interceptions.
Suhey’s death came under different circumstances. After his wife called for help on September 6, police in Deerfield found no suspicious circumstances.
The Lake County Coroner’s Office later ruled the death natural causes. Chief deputy Steve Newton said Suhey had a significant medical history and was already under a doctor’s care.
Officials said the primary physician is completing the death certificate.
Suhey played all 10 of his NFL seasons with the Bears. He ran for 2,946 yards and 20 touchdowns, and he scored the first touchdown in Super Bowl XX. Jarrett Payton later described him as his father’s bodyguard in the backfield.
Marshall’s family said he died September 2. His obituary remembered him in personal terms, saying, “He genuinely cared for people and found joy in helping others,” it said.
The Broncos signed him as an undrafted free agent in 1992, and he later played for the Giants. His best season came that rookie year in Denver, when he caught 26 passes for 493 yards.
He had also been fighting cancer privately.
Three players, three careers, and three endings that landed right before the season began.
In Other News...
Justin Simmons Pulled The Broncos Into A Messy NFL Media Debate
Justin Simmons has dragged the Broncos into an awkward NFL media conversation by raising a pointed question about how stories get covered and why some situations draw far more attention than others. Simmons publicly wondered why the focus has landed on Broncos linebacker Jonathan Coopers domestic violence case while what he viewed as a different off-field controversy involving Patriots coach Mike Vrabel and former NFL reporter Dianna Russini has not drawn the same level of scrutiny.
Vrabel was caught up in an offseason mess after photos of him and Russini at an adults-only resort surfaced, an episode that led to Russinis resignation and an internal investigation by The Athletic. The debate now sits in the background of a Patriots team that already has football problems after dropping its Week 1 game to Seattle, with Drake Maye throwing three interceptions, but Simmons comments have made clear that the Broncos are not looking at this as just another league-wide media skirmish. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Just Reignited An NFL Double Standard Debate Fans Know Well
During ESPNs Monday Night Football broadcast of the Broncos-Chiefs game, sideline reporter Laura Rutledge noted that Denver defender Jonathon Cooper was absent because he had been placed on the commissioners exempt list following domestic violence charges. The mention put a sensitive off-field issue squarely into the middle of a prime-time NFL telecast, and it immediately became more than a routine injury-or-status update for viewers following the Broncos.
Former Broncos safety Justin Simmons took aim at ESPN for bringing Coopers legal situation into the game coverage, and the reaction quickly spread into a wider conversation among former players and fans. The episode has revived a familiar debate about where broadcast reporters should draw the line when a players controversy becomes part of the nights storyline, especially when the game itself is supposed to be the focus. [Read more 🡒]
Patrick Surtain's Blunt Take Sums Up Denver's Early Reality Check
Denvers season opened with a jolt, and not the kind the Broncos were hoping for. An early interception briefly hinted at a fast start, but the offense stalled from there and the loss quickly turned into a reminder that preseason optimism only matters once the games count. Under Sean Payton, the Broncos expected a sharper launch than what showed up in Week 1, making the gap between projections and reality feel especially stark.
Patrick Surtain II didnt sugarcoat it afterward, saying the team needed a serving of humble pie. It was the kind of blunt assessment that tends to land harder because it comes from one of the rosters most respected voices, and it leaves Denver with an early test of response. The talent is there, the expectations remain high, and now the Broncos have to prove this was just a stumble rather than the first sign of a longer adjustment. [Read more 🡒]