Broncos Face A Tough Keep-Or-Lose Decision On Key Defensive Pieces

Amid a crucial playoff push, Mark Schlereth outlines the Denver Broncos' strategic offseason priorities focused on retaining three key defensive free agents to sustain their competitive edge.

The Broncos’ offseason decisions are already coming into focus, and Mark Schlereth has a pretty clear order for how Denver should handle its own free agents.

On a recent edition of “Stokley and Evans, with Mark Schlereth” on 104.3 The Fan, Mike Evans asked Schlereth for the quick version of which pending free agents matter most.

“Give me your, off the cuff, top free agents that you feel most important to re-sign,” Evans said.

Schlereth didn’t hesitate to start with nickel cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian.

“Obviously I think that McMillian is right up there. A guy that you need to re-sign,” Schlereth said.

That tracks with how important McMillian has become for Denver. He went from an overlooked piece to a major part of last season’s AFC Championship run, and his overtime interception against Buffalo in the Divisional Round stands out as one of the biggest plays of the Bo Nix era.

He has also kept the nickel job this season, to the point that 2025 first-round pick Jahdae Barron has barely gotten on the field. If McMillian walks, the Broncos would be left trying to replace a player who has already proven he belongs.

Schlereth then added two more names to the top of his list.

“I’m thinking McMillian, I’m thinking Moss. Man, safety Brandon Jones. Brandon Jones has been good,” Schlereth said.

Riley Moss brings a trickier debate. He was flagged 12 times last season, but Schlereth has long defended him by pointing out that Moss plays opposite Pat Surtain II, which means quarterbacks challenge him far more often than they challenge Surtain. Schlereth has also noted that Moss’s physical style naturally leads to more flags than some other corners draw.

Jones may not get the same attention, but Schlereth’s praise says plenty. Playing next to Talanoa Hufanga, Jones has been part of a secondary that has kept teams out of the end zone even while the defense has surrendered plenty of yards.

Joel Klatt recently pointed out that Denver’s scoring defense has been far better than its total defense, and the back end has been a major reason why. Letting a steady starting safety leave would create a hole the Broncos don’t have an obvious answer for.

Schlereth wrapped it up bluntly.

“Those are the 3 guys that I look at and think, ‘Those should be the guys that you go after,'” Schlereth said.

That leaves out two other notable pending free agents: tight end Evan Engram and receiver and return man Marvin Mims. Engram was brought in to solve the tight end spot, but that move hasn’t delivered the way Denver hoped.

Schlereth has said this offseason that the Broncos still haven’t figured out tight end, and Engram’s drops were part of the criticism after the San Francisco loss. Mims, meanwhile, is an All-Pro returner and has made some of the biggest plays of the Nix era, but he wants a larger role as a receiver.

That doesn’t look likely behind Jaylen Waddle, Courtland Sutton and Pat Bryant, which could push him toward more money and more targets elsewhere.

The financial piece is where this gets tricky. In the summer, Josh Dover argued that Denver had enough cap space to extend both McMillian and Moss instead of choosing one.

Since then, the Broncos have moved closer to Nix’s second contract, and that will shape their spending more than anything else. Every dollar used to keep the secondary intact will affect what remains for the quarterback and the rest of the roster.

For Schlereth, though, the priority is obvious: keep the defense’s core together first, and sort out the offense after that.

In Other News...

Broncos Have A Problem That Could Catch Up Fast

The Broncos are sitting at 7-2 coming out of the bye, and that record has bought them time to enjoy the view from the top of the AFC. But the numbers underneath the standings tell a less comfortable story. Denver has not been running the ball with much authority, and it has had trouble consistently stopping the run, two issues that tend to matter more once the games get tighter and the weather gets colder.

Troy Renck and Sean Keeler both pointed to the same basic playoff truth: when Denver can get to 90 rushing yards or more and keep an opponent under 90 on the ground, the path gets a lot cleaner. Renck also argued the Broncos need to shake up the way they handle the offensive line and the backfield if they want the ground game to become more dependable, because the margin for error shrinks fast once the postseason pressure arrives. [Read more 🡒]

Broncos Await Crucial Raiders Decision On Their Most Dangerous Weapon

The Broncos are keeping a close eye on Las Vegas tight end Brock Bowers, who sat out practice with an ankle injury as the Raiders opened their week of prep. Bowers was hurt in the previous game and is still considered day-to-day, leaving the Raiders to plan for a matchup with Denver without knowing how much of their top pass-catching threat they will have available.

For Denver, the uncertainty matters because Bowers has become the focal point of the Raiders' passing game and can change a defensive plan in a hurry. Las Vegas has not ruled him out for the upcoming game, but until his status becomes clearer, the Broncos have to prepare for a version of the Raiders offense that could look very different depending on how much he can handle. [Read more 🡒]

Broncos Playoff Push May Hinge On These Injured Starters Returning

The Broncos have spent much of the 2026 season patching holes in a defense that has been hit hard by injuries, especially in the secondary. Three starters there have missed time, along with a reserve corner and a rotational defensive lineman, while the offense has also felt the impact with a starting wide receiver sidelined. For a team trying to hold its ground in the playoff race, the margin for error has been thin, and every week has seemed to bring another reminder of how fragile the depth chart can be.

Help may finally be on the way as Denver heads into the stretch run. Safety Talanoa Hufanga has been working back from an ankle sprain, and running back RJ Harvey is nearing his chance to rejoin the mix after landing on injured reserve, giving the Broncos a possible boost at two spots that have been stretched by attrition. With the postseason picture tightening, the timing of those returns could matter as much as anything else the team does down the line. [Read more 🡒]