Bo Nix has a chance to make the 2024 quarterback class look even better, but right now Drake Maye has the edge in the race to be the group’s headliner.
That’s the big takeaway from a fresh look at the first six quarterbacks taken in the 2024 NFL Draft, a class that made history when six passers came off the board in the first 12 picks. Nix was the sixth one selected, going 12th overall to the Denver Broncos, behind Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Maye, Michael Penix and J.J. McCarthy.
The gap between the top six and the rest of the draft was massive. The next quarterback didn’t come off the board until the fifth round, when Spencer Rattler went 150th overall. Rattler has 16 starts, six more than McCarthy, who missed the entire 2024 season with injury.
So how do the six first-rounders and near-first-rounders stack up? In the most basic passing numbers, Nix has made a strong case for himself, even if Maye still owns the best overall profile.
Maye leads the group in career passer rating at 103.1, while Nix sits third among the six. Nix does have the most touchdown passes in the class with 54, but he’s also thrown the most passes, with 1,179 attempts.
Maye tops him in completion percentage at 69.8 percent, and Daniels is right there too at 66.6 percent. Nix ranks third in that category.
The interception numbers tell a similar story. Nix sits fourth in interception rate, with only Maye and McCarthy worse. McCarthy’s number is the outlier here at 4.9 percent, far behind the rest of the class.
Where Nix really stands out is in sack avoidance. He leads the six with a sack percentage of 3.8 percent, while McCarthy has been sacked on 10 percent of his career dropbacks.
That 3.8 percent mark also puts Nix in the neighborhood of Drew Brees, and he’s not yet eligible for the career sack-rate leaderboard because he doesn’t have the required 1,550 passing attempts. If he stays healthy, he should get there this season, though even then he would sit behind Doug Williams at 3.24 and Mark Rypien at 3.58.
The career standard is still led by Peyton Manning and Dan Marino, tied at 3.13 percent.
Nix also leads the class in passing yards per game, team wins, fourth-quarter comebacks and game-winning drives. Team wins are not a quarterback stat, but they’re still part of the picture here.
The one area where he lags badly is yards per completion, where he ranks last. He’s also fourth in success rate on passes.
That success-rate metric is where Maye’s leap really jumps off the page. He went from average in 2024 to near the top of the league in 2025, finishing behind only Brock Purdy among starting quarterbacks at 55.3 percent. League average was 45.2 percent, which is almost exactly where Nix finished 2025.
The broader trend for young starters is encouraging. Over their first three seasons, quarterbacks usually improve their passing success rate at a steady pace.
For the group of recent starters cited here, the average jump from year one to year three was 2.8 percentage points. If Nix follows that path, he would rise to 46.5.
Not everyone follows that script, though. Justin Herbert, Lamar Jackson and C.J.
Stroud all dipped in year three compared to year one. Jackson’s first starting season was counted as 2019, even though he started seven games in 2018; if 2018 is used instead, his numbers look better, going from 43.5 to 46.2.
For now, five of the six quarterbacks from the 2024 class are lined up to start for their teams, with McCarthy the lone exception. He is currently set to back up former No. 1 pick Kyler Murray.
Nix has the volume numbers and the durability edge. Maye has the cleaner efficiency profile. If Nix wants to take over the top spot in this class, he still has some work to do.
In Other News...
Broncos Have A Real Super Bowl Shot But Two Risks Loom
The Broncos enter the 2026 season with a far different kind of ceiling than they had during the Russell Wilson dead-cap drag, and that alone changes the conversation around what this roster can become. With the financial burden finally gone and a strong group in place, Denver can legitimately talk about contending in a way that felt out of reach not long ago.
Even so, the path to a Super Bowl is rarely clean, especially in a conference that still figures to run through familiar heavyweights like Kansas City, Baltimore and Cincinnati. Denver also has to prove last years string of close wins was more than a good run of fortune, and there is still some unknown attached to Davis Webbs first season calling the offense. The pieces are there for a real push, but the Broncos still have to show they can handle the pressure points that usually decide these seasons. [Read more 🡒]
Broncos Have Several Roster Fights That May Be Decided This Week
The Broncos are moving into a stretch where preseason snaps carry a little more weight than usual, with their second exhibition game against the Packers coming at the same time the roster cutdown deadline starts to loom. Several spots still look unsettled, and the next few practices and game reps should go a long way toward sorting out who sticks on the 53-man roster and who gets pushed into the practice squad conversation.
At quarterback, Jarrett Stidham and Sam Ehlinger are still vying for position, while the back end of the roster remains open at running back, tight end, linebacker and safety. Denver also has to factor in the recent addition of Taylor Rapp at safety and a linebacker group dealing with an injury, which only adds to the pressure on players trying to make their case in these final preseason games. [Read more 🡒]
Broncos Still Have One Unsettling Question About Jahdae Barron
Jahdae Barron has already given the Broncos a glimpse of why he was their top pick in 2025, but the early path to a defined role has not been simple. With Riley Moss and JaQuan McMillian also in the mix, Barron is battling for snaps in a secondary that suddenly has more answers than openings, and that has made his fit one of the more interesting issues hanging over Denvers defense.
Vance Joseph has talked about Barron in terms of versatility, with the rookie working at multiple spots in the back end rather than locking into one lane. Sean Payton has also pushed back on any notion of shifting him to safety, which keeps the focus on how the Broncos sort out their corners now and later, especially with future contract decisions looming for Moss and McMillian. Chris Harris Jr. has weighed in on Barrons development, but the bigger question remains whether Denver can turn all that flexibility into a clear starting job soon. [Read more 🡒]