The Jason Robertson situation has become one of the most intriguing contract stories in the league, and the latest wrinkle is salary arbitration.
On The Chris Johnston Show, Julian McKenzie and Chris Johnston dug into the players who filed, with Robertson of the Dallas Stars sitting at the center of the conversation. McKenzie also pointed to other names in the mix, including Kirby Dach of the Montreal Canadiens, Jet Greaves from Columbus, Cole Perfetti in Winnipeg and Trevor Zegras from Philadelphia.
Johnston said the arbitration filings immediately change the timeline for those players. “Yeah, it sets the clock right for those players.
Those guys are actually not eligible because they filed for arbitration for offer sheets. So you know the Robertson situation, I think, is the most prominent among the players you mentioned.”
That’s where the Dallas angle gets especially messy. Robertson is one year from being a UFA, but he still has a restricted free agent season to sign.
Johnston laid out the bind clearly: if he and the Stars go all the way through an arbitration case, he would effectively be walked to free agency. At the same time, Dallas would still have a season where Robertson has no trade protection, which means the Stars could keep him on the trade market.
There is still a path to a long-term deal before the hearing, whenever it gets scheduled. But Johnston made it sound like Dallas has one big decision coming before then: either get into the contract range Robertson will accept and get it done, or risk heading into a year where the most likely outcomes are playing him out to free agency next July or moving him during the season.
That’s part of what makes this case stand out. Johnston said teams and players usually don’t enjoy arbitration because it forces both sides to tear into the other’s case. Still, he said these hearings often serve as the mechanism that pushes a contract across the finish line.
Robertson may be the exception. Johnston said, “I truly believe maybe it’s just best for him to get a one-year award. It’s probably going to be a pretty good amount of money, and then he’s in a position to be a free agent next summer.”
The Stars already tried to trade him and couldn’t complete a deal with Seattle because he had not signed a long-term extension. That only adds another layer to what Johnston called an interesting arbitration case if it happens.
McKenzie didn’t hide the appeal of what could come next if Robertson reaches free agency. “I’m not saying I want it to get to a point where Jason Robertson goes to free agency, but the Jason Robertson sweepstakes in free agency next summer is way sexier than anything we’ve heard around free agents this year.
Especially considering what the class was supposed to look like, maybe as of like a year or two years ago, and then the names just kept falling off the board. We, we, we need sexy names back on the free agent board, CJ.
We need that back.”
Johnston noted that restricted free agents are now part of the bigger picture because offer sheets are in play. But he also said Robertson’s preference may not be the dramatic route.
“Well, you, you have restricted free agents to focus on now too, with the offer sheet thing being in play. I mean, you know, the interesting thing about the Robertson situation is the feeling is he doesn’t want to leave Dallas.”
Johnston added that Robertson is trying to get fair value for his services, but doesn’t want to be anywhere else. Even if the sides find common ground on a big extension, there would still be a year in which the Stars could theoretically trade him, since he is not eligible for trade protection this coming season.
So Robertson is stuck in the middle of a lot of moving parts: arbitration, trade uncertainty, a possible one-year award, and the possibility of reaching July 1, 2027 as a UFA. Johnston summed up the uncertainty by saying Robertson is one of the league’s top scorers over the last several years, with special offensive gifts, but the exact path from here is still unresolved.
In Other News...
Jason Robertson Situation Is Starting To Feel Very Real For Stars Fans
Jason Robertsons restricted free agency has become one of the more closely watched situations around the Stars, and the longer it stretches on, the more real it starts to feel for a fan base that would rather be talking about building around its best young scorer than wondering how long this can drag out. Dallas has every reason to want this resolved cleanly, but the gap between what Robertson may be looking for and what the club is prepared to commit has kept the conversation alive well beyond the usual summer noise.
Around the league, teams are already positioning themselves for the possibility that this gets uncomfortable, with Pittsburgh among the clubs keeping an eye on the situation and Los Angeles also viewed as a team preserving flexibility for bigger moves down the road. For the Stars, the concern is not just losing a top-end talent, but watching a negotiation turn into a broader market story, the kind that starts with one unsigned player and ends with a lot of people asking what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Jason Robertson Situation Just Became More Serious For The Stars
Jason Robertsons contract situation has lingered long enough to become one of the more notable storylines around the Stars, and it is no longer just about finding the right number. He remains unsigned while negotiations continue, and the broader market for restricted free agents has only added to the leverage on the player side, making these talks feel more delicate than a standard extension chase.
What gives this one extra weight is that Dallas is not operating in a vacuum. Pittsburgh has reportedly shown interest in acquiring Robertson, which is the kind of outside attention that can sharpen the urgency on both sides of a negotiation. For the Stars, the concern is not just keeping a top player in place, but navigating a situation where fit, stability and long-term comfort may matter just as much as the contract itself. [Read more 🡒]