Jim Nill spent the offseason trying to land a headline-grabber, and the Dallas Stars ended up with something messier: a pair of blockbuster swings that never quite cleared the bar.
The biggest near-miss centered on Zach Werenski. Dallas had a deal in place with the Columbus Blue Jackets, only for Werenski to stop it himself.
That turn sent the Stars scrambling, especially after details of the framework leaked and Thomas Harley’s name surfaced as the centerpiece. Harley signed an eight-year deal last season that keeps him in Dallas through 2033-34, so getting pulled into trade chatter less than a year later was hardly ideal for anyone involved.
The Stars now have to move forward as if everything is fine, even though that kind of news rarely disappears cleanly. Jim Nill, though, does not sound like someone ready to abandon the idea. On The Sheet with Jeff Marek, Keith Kavanaugh of PuckPedia brought up the Werenski situation and said, “You mentioned… you still don’t think the Stars’ deal is off the table for Zach Werenski…” Marek answered immediately: “Nope, I don’t.”
That lines up with the sense that Dallas is still watching Werenski closely. Werenski has made it pretty clear he wants to stay in Columbus and see it through there, but if that changes, the Stars appear ready to jump back in.
For Harley, that leaves an awkward reality hanging over things. It’s one thing to hear your name in trade rumors.
It’s another to know the team may still be willing to move you if the right door opens.
And Werenski wasn’t the only star Dallas nearly moved.
Jason Robertson was part of another major offseason standoff, with the Stars and Seattle Kraken working through a framework that would have sent him out. An extension was also part of the conversation, and it was a big one: eight years at $15 million AAV. Robertson passed on that route and shut down the trade.
That would be a major storyline on its own. Put it next to the Werenski situation, and the picture gets even stranger.
Trading two of your best players in one offseason is rare enough. Coming up empty on both deals and then trying to keep the room steady afterward makes the whole thing even more delicate.
Robertson eventually signed a one-year deal worth $12 million AAV, keeping him in Dallas for at least another season, but the business side didn’t stop there. To make the money work, Nill also had to move young talent in Mavrik Bourque, a decision Marek said did not sit well with many players.
Marek revisited Robertson’s deal back in July on The Sheet and said, “One person mentioned to me that they were of the belief that had Jason Robertson come in on 12 million earlier, there was perhaps another deal that Dallas could’ve done… and they would’ve been able to keep Mavrik Bourque.”
So now Dallas heads into the season with the same high-end talent, the same appetite for a major move, and a lot more noise around the edges. Nill is still trying to keep the roster strong while chasing the kind of splash that can change everything, but that approach can make life uneasy for the players living through it.
The Stars are still a real contender and should be in the mix with Colorado and Minnesota again for the Central Division. But they may also be one of the most interesting teams in the league for reasons that go beyond the standings.
With Jim Nill still hunting for the next big deal and Jason Robertson moving toward unrestricted free agency in 2027, Dallas is entering the year with elite talent and plenty of tension. That combination usually keeps things interesting.