Another week, another Cowboys loss, and another round of power rankings reminding Dallas that the rest of the league is done pretending this is a serious contender.
That was the big takeaway as the 2026 NFL Week 11 rankings rolled in: the Cowboys are sliding, the defense is unraveling, and the gap between what Dallas wants to be and what it actually is keeps getting wider. Early-season optimism is long gone now, especially after the shellacking from the San Francisco 49ers. Thanksgiving is approaching, and the reality check has arrived with it.
At the top, nothing changed. The Buffalo Bills held firm at No. 1, followed by the 49ers at No. 2 and the Jacksonville Jaguars at No.
- The Detroit Lions moved up to No. 4, while the Cincinnati Bengals climbed to No.
- The Chicago Bears stayed put at No. 6, and the Minnesota Vikings made one of the bigger jumps of the week, rising to No.
The Vikings’ surge came with Kirk Cousins back in the mix, while the Green Bay Packers dropped to No. 9 after getting “wrecked” by Minnesota in Cousins’ return. The Denver Broncos remained at No. 8, the Seattle Seahawks held at No. 10, and the Los Angeles Rams moved up to No.
- The Kansas City Chiefs sat at No. 12, the Pittsburgh Steelers fell to No. 13, and the Cleveland Browns continued their unexpected climb to No.
The New England Patriots slipped to No. 15, in part because they’ll be without Drake Maye for a bit. The New York Giants stayed at No.
16, Houston dropped to No. 17, and Tampa Bay checked in at No. 18.
Carolina moved to No. 19, Atlanta to No. 20, and then came Dallas at No.
That placement says plenty. The Cowboys are no longer being treated like a team on the edge of something bigger. They’re being treated like a team drifting toward irrelevancy.
Washington landed at No. 22, with the Raiders at No. 23, the Ravens at No. 24, the Saints at No. 25, and the Colts at No. 26 after finally winning a game. Arizona fell to No.
27, Miami was No. 28, Philadelphia No. 29, the Chargers No. 30 after finally getting a win, the Jets No. 31, and the Titans at No.
The Cowboys’ own ranking came with the bluntest possible read: “This team isn’t threatening anybody.”
The broader story around Dallas is the same one that keeps showing up from different angles. The offense is good enough to keep the team hanging around. The defense is wrecking everything else.
One ranking noted that Dallas’ defense “couldn’t stop a nosebleed,” while another pointed out that the offense remains strong enough in most weeks to keep the Cowboys in the playoff hunt. But the defense, as the piece put it, won’t give them a real chance to win anything significant without changes.
That was reinforced by the 46-40 loss to San Francisco, when Dallas surrendered 584 yards and allowed three touchdowns of at least 66 yards. The Cowboys have now given up at least one score from 55 yards or longer in each of their past three games.
Brian Schottenheimer didn’t hide from it afterward.
“I thought the second half was unacceptable,” Schottenheimer said, according to the team’s site. “Tackling was atrocious. We’re going to do a deep dive and see why.”
The offense, for what it’s worth, is still doing enough to matter. Dallas is fifth in points scored, eighth in yards gained, fifth in EPA per play and sixth in DVOA.
That should be enough to win a weak division. But the defense keeps dragging the whole operation down, even if DVOA still gives the Cowboys a 32.4% chance to win the NFC East.
There was at least one bright spot on the defensive side, even if it came in the middle of all the mess. Todd Archer’s non-QB MVP at midseason was DT Quinnen Williams.
He leads the team with six sacks, which is the most for a Dallas defensive tackle in a season since 2017. He’s also second in quarterback pressures, leads the NFL with 15 tackles for loss and is tied for fifth with three forced fumbles.
The problem is obvious: he needs help.
Dallas also got a separate note of movement in one ranking, rising four spots despite the ugly loss. The explanation was simple enough: the offense is still capable, but the defense is a disaster. USA Today dropped the Cowboys to No. 22, while Yahoo moved them down to No. 22 as well, with the same basic conclusion - the defense is a mess, and even Post Malone looked fed up after what happened Sunday.
The Athletic had Dallas at No. 19, down from No. 17, and highlighted Ryan Flournoy as its breakout player. The third-year receiver, a sixth-round pick in 2024, caught six passes for 71 yards and a touchdown against San Francisco and now has 38 receptions for 466 yards this season.
The final word on the Cowboys was the one that fit best: the defense has gotten worse, not better.
In Other News...
Penguins Nearly Made A Franchise-Changing Swing Before Everything Shifted
Last years contract standoff around Jason Robertson briefly put the Stars at the center of a potential blockbuster, with Pittsburgh reportedly close to making a run at the winger before the situation cooled. Robertson ultimately stayed in Dallas on a one-year deal, and the ripple effect was felt elsewhere when the Penguins landed his younger brother, Nick Robertson, instead.
Pittsburghs outlook has changed dramatically since then. After a rough start to the current season, the Penguins have moved away from the idea of a big swing and toward a more familiar path of dealing veterans and retooling for the future, which makes that near-miss with Robertson look even more significant in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]
Stars Have A Chance To Make This Vegas Rematch Matter Even More
The Stars overtime win over Vegas was more than just another mark in the standings. They erased a late two-goal deficit to beat a familiar opponent, and in the process kept rolling through a stretch that has them looking like one of the leagues steadier teams. A five-game winning streak tends to sharpen the mood around a club, especially when it comes against the kind of Western Conference competition Dallas may have to navigate again later.
Dallas still has work to do in the Central Division race, sitting on 28 points and chasing both Minnesota and Colorado, but the next meeting with Vegas carries a little extra weight now. The Stars have handled Pacific Division teams perfectly so far this season, and every result like this one adds to the sense that they can turn a regular-season rematch into something more meaningful down the line. [Read more 🡒]
Stars Suddenly Have A Blue Line Question Before A Big Rematch
The Stars have settled into a good rhythm after a run of recent wins, including an overtime victory against the Vegas Golden Knights, but their blue line is still carrying a little uncertainty as the rematch approaches. Coach Glen Gulutzan offered updates on Kyle Burroughs, Trey Taylor and Tyler Myers, and the picture is mixed enough to keep the back end worth watching.
Burroughs and Taylor have handled third-pair duty with limited mistakes, giving Dallas some stability in a depth role, while Myers remains doubtful because of an upper-body injury. For a team trying to keep its momentum rolling against a familiar opponent, the question is less about who has been steady and more about whether the Stars will have enough of their preferred pieces available when the puck drops. [Read more 🡒]
