The Mavericks made a bold bet last weekend, sending Ryan Nembhard and their final tradeable second-round pick in a three-team deal to land former first overall pick Zaccharie Risacher. For a team working with limited assets, that kind of move makes sense on paper: swing for talent, even if the player’s value has already taken a hit.
But history says these reclamation projects are a mixed bag at best.
Since 2010, there have been several former top-3 picks who were traded within their first three NBA seasons, and the results have ranged from salvageable to flat-out bleak. James Wiseman is one of the clearest cautionary tales.
He was taken second in the infamous 2020 NBA Draft after playing only three games at Memphis, then saw his career derailed by a torn meniscus late in his rookie season and setbacks that wiped out his second year. By his third season, he was dealt to the Detroit Pistons in a four-team trade that sent Gary Payton II to Golden State.
Since then, he has played just five games over the last two seasons with the Indiana Pacers because of injury.
Markelle Fultz followed a different path, but the end result has still been frustration. Shoulder problems wrecked his early years, and he managed only 33 games across his first two seasons.
The 2019 offseason trade sent him from the Philadelphia 76ers to the Orlando Magic for Jonathan Simmons, a 2019 second-round pick, and a 2020 first-round pick that became Tyrese Maxey. Fultz became a useful player in Orlando, with multiple double-digit scoring seasons, but he also had multiple seasons in which he appeared in fewer than 20 games.
Lonzo Ball’s story looked more promising for a while. He had a shaky start with the Lakers, then became a much better player in New Orleans and Chicago before being folded into the Anthony Davis trade.
A devastating knee injury in Chicago changed everything. He missed nearly three straight seasons and has not played more than 35 games since the 2020-21 season.
D’Angelo Russell is another case where talent was never really the issue. He put up 15.6 PPG in his second season with the Lakers, but the locker-room trust was damaged after the infamous snitching incident with Nick Young.
Los Angeles moved him to the Brooklyn Nets with Timofey Mozgov during the 2018 Draft in a deal that brought back Kyle Kuzma and Brook Lopez. Russell made an All-Star team a year later, averaging 21.1 PPG and 7.0 RPG, but things have gone downhill since then.
He has bounced from the Nets to the Warriors, Timberwolves, Lakers, Nets again, Mavericks, Wizards, and now the Grizzlies, and he’s virtually unplayable now.
If the Mavericks are looking for the most relevant warning sign, Jahlil Okafor fits the bill. He was a major prospect out of high school and a consensus First Team All-American at Duke, but his game never translated cleanly to the NBA.
He did have a strong rookie year on a terrible 76ers team, yet the decline came fast. Early in the 2017-18 season, Philadelphia traded him, Nik Stauskas, and a second-round pick for Trevor Booker.
After his second NBA season, he never averaged more than 9 PPG again.
Anthony Bennett remains the low point of this kind of conversation. The first overall pick in 2013 was a miss from the start, and Bill Simmons’ “Woah!”
when the selection was made has become part of draft lore for a reason. Bennett lasted four seasons with four teams - Cleveland, Minnesota, Toronto, and Brooklyn - and after his lone year with the Cavaliers, he was included in the Kevin Love trade.
He never averaged more than 5.2 PPG.
Derrick Williams also gets a mention, even if his case was less catastrophic. Plenty of people liked him coming out of Arizona, and Minnesota took him second overall in 2011.
He struggled to find a real role alongside Ricky Rubio and Kevin Love, then was traded midway through his third season to Sacramento for Luc Mbah A Moute. He never made much of an impact anywhere else.
Derrick Favors is a different kind of example because he was part of the package for Deron Williams going to the Nets, so the circumstances were unusual. Still, he never quite became the third-overall star some projected. From 2013 to 2019, he averaged 13.3 PPG and 7.7 RPG for mostly competitive Jazz teams, which is solid production, just not what teams usually dream about at that draft slot.
There are success stories in the mix, though, and that’s what gives Dallas any reason to hope. Elton Brand was drafted first overall by the Bulls in 1999, won Rookie of the Year, and was moved after two years as Chicago tried to build around Tyson Chandler and Eddy Curry in the 2001 NBA Draft. The Bulls probably should have kept him; he was a consistent 20 and 10 threat for most of a decade.
Chauncey Billups is the best-case scenario for a player like Risacher. Boston took him third overall in 1997, then traded him to Toronto midway through his rookie season in a large package for Kenny Anderson.
Toronto flipped him to Denver that offseason, and after two underwhelming years with the Nuggets, he signed with Minnesota and began to turn things around alongside Kevin Garnett. Two years later, he joined Detroit, fully broke out, averaged 17.0 PPG and 6.3 APG over the next six seasons, made four All-Star Games, and won Finals MVP in 2004.
Jason Kidd was also traded midway through his third season with the Mavericks, though that situation came with locker-room drama and other complications. Even so, Kidd had obvious talent.
That’s the tightrope Dallas is walking with Risacher: the upside is real, but the recent history of former top-3 picks changing teams early does not exactly scream certainty.
In Other News...
Mavericks Suddenly Linked To A Surprising Young Wing In Reset Move
Bennedict Mathurin has surfaced in a fresh round of Mavericks chatter as Dallas looks for ways to reset its wing rotation, and the fit is easy enough to understand. The 22-year-old brings shot creation and athleticism that would give the Mavericks a different kind of perimeter threat, while also lining up with a longer-term approach if the front office decides to pivot from older, more expensive pieces.
The path to getting there is what makes the idea complicated. Mathurin is a restricted free agent, and the discussion around his next deal has opened the door to a sign-and-trade framework that would require real maneuvering on the Dallas side, including moving Klay Thompsons expiring contract and future draft capital. Even in a market full of speculative fits, this one stands out because it would ask the Mavericks to balance immediate roster change against the cost of chasing a young wing who could alter the shape of the team. [Read more 🡒]
Mavericks Are Still Tempting Disaster With Kyrie Irving's Biggest Risk
Dallas spent much of the offseason trying to beef up its frontcourt, but the more fragile part of the roster still looks like the one that runs through Kyrie Irving. The Mavericks have not done much to fortify point guard depth behind him, even though Irving is the primary organizer of the offense and is coming off a season lost to injury.
The concern is less about whether Dallas has bodies on the roster and more about whether it has a trustworthy plan if Irving is unavailable again. The current options are young, awkward fits, and the team has already seen how quickly a season can unravel when it has to improvise at that spot, which is why the need for a veteran backup point guard still hangs over the roster. [Read more 🡒]