When the biggest basketball card of the year surfaced just before midnight on Aug. 10, Fanatics moved fast - and then moved even faster.
The one-of-one Topps Cooper Flagg Rookie Debut Patch Auto was pulled during a livestream break by RhodyBreakers of North Kingstown, Rhode Island, and the scramble started almost immediately. Auction houses, marketplaces, collectors and bounty hunters all went after the owner’s attention.
Million-dollar offers began stacking up. Even Flagg’s team, the Dallas Mavericks, got into the mix.
Kevin Lenane, Fanatics’ VP of Marketplace, knew an email wasn’t going to cut it.
After tracking down the shop during the livestream, he called and tried to reach the collector. He was told to send an email because so many people were already calling. Then came the busy signal.
“I haven’t heard a busy signal in a long time,” Lenane joked.
So Fanatics got physical. Lenane asked Fanatics Collect colleague Clay Thomas in Los Angeles to get on a red-eye to Providence.
Lenane himself was on the 6 a.m. ferry from Port Jefferson, N.Y., to Bridgeport, Conn., then in an 110-mile Uber ride to Rhode Island, where he arrived around 9 a.m. The problem was simple: he still hadn’t actually met the collector.
The owner didn’t want to hand over his contact information at first, so Lenane wound up talking with him from a back room at Baseball Cards of Rhode Island on the same landline he had been trying to reach earlier.
The next day, collector Jason Williams came to the shop and spent hours with the Fanatics team talking through marketing, valuation, the auction process and what Fanatics could bring to the table. Williams ultimately chose Fanatics Collect, and the Flagg card will headline the Fanatics Collect September Premier Auction, set for Sept. 10-24.
Lenane said nearly every major auction house and marketplace tried to get to the shop once the card became public. Fanatics’ edge, he said, was simply being there.
“The only way to do that was to be there physically,” Lenane said.
At the top end of the market, Lenane said, the pitch is bigger than fees. Exposure and the story around the card can matter just as much.
“You want to make sure that everyone that might be interested in buying your card knows about it,” Lenane said.
He also pointed to Fanatics’ connections across sports and a Fanatics Collect staff full of serious collectors who understand both the cards and how to sell them. The business, he said, has exploded in size.
“We’re more than 10 times the size we were two years ago,” Lenane said.
Flagg’s card won’t be the only Rookie Debut Patch Auto drawing eyes in September. The auction will also include one-of-one cards from Rookie of the Year runner-up Kon Knueppel and Spurs rookie Dylan Harper, giving the sale three of the rookie class’s most notable cards.
Lenane called Harper and Knueppel essentially “1A and 1B” among the other cards to watch. Harper’s market has climbed sharply in recent months, while Lenane sees Knueppel as the value play entering the upcoming NBA season.
“I would say probably the value pick of the three,” Lenane said of Knueppel. “His market has softened a bit. I think that’s going to change here.”
The grading also adds another layer to the bidding picture. Flagg’s card received a PSA 10 with a 10 autograph, a rare result for thick patch autos. Harper’s card got a PSA 9 with a 10 autograph, and Knueppel’s had not yet been graded.
Lenane described Williams as a real collector, not an investor, pointing to a collection that includes Dale Murphy, Ernie Banks and vintage baseball cards.
“You can tell right away that this guy-he knows his stuff,” Lenane said.
That kind of collector is exactly who Fanatics says it wants to work with, and Lenane said the company tries to stay conservative with estimates instead of chasing a consignment by overselling what a card might bring. Sometimes, he said, the right advice is to point a collector somewhere else.
“If I don’t believe that we’re going to be the best outcome, I’ll let it go,” Lenane said. “There’s been a few times where there’s, ‘Oh, there’s like a big offer,’ and I’m like, ‘You should probably take that. I don’t know if we can get you there.’”
For Lenane, the goal is to build a relationship that lasts beyond one card.
“We want to make sure we’re not doing anything just to win that card,” he said.
In this case, though, Fanatics believed it could deliver real value - and Williams agreed. The ferry, the red-eye and the landline all led to the same place.
In Other News...
Kyrie Irving Trade Buzz Just Hit A Telling New Wall
The latest Kyrie Irving chatter has run into a familiar obstacle in Miami, where the Heats recent free-agent activity has already changed the shape of the conversation. After adding Klay Thompson on a deal that gives the club financial flexibility and room to maneuver, Miami has addressed part of its offseason agenda while still leaving some uncertainty at point guard, which is why Irving has remained a name worth monitoring from afar.
But even with the Heat still looking as if they could use help at the position, the buzz around an Irving-to-Miami move does not seem to be gaining real traction. The roster picture has improved, the appetite for another major swing is hard to read, and Dallas is still expected to be a difficult team to move off its current position if the trade interest keeps coming. [Read more 🡒]
Mavericks Could Be Pulled Into A Familiar Luka Doncic Trade Twist
The Lakers have already added Walker Kessler and Kevon Looney, but they are still hunting for another center and sorting out the power forward spot, which has kept their frontcourt plans fluid as the offseason moves along. For Dallas, that matters because any Lakers pursuit in that area tends to bring up familiar trade possibilities, especially with the two teams having crossed paths before in bigger roster conversations.
One idea now floating around would involve a three-team framework that sends PJ Washington and Jaden Hardy into the mix along with draft compensation, a setup that would also reunite Luka Doncic with a former teammate in Los Angeles. From the Mavericks side, the interest is less about nostalgia than leverage, since a deal like this would be judged on whether it gives Dallas the kind of value it would need to consider parting with one of its more useful rotation pieces. [Read more 🡒]
Mavericks Lost Out As Cooper Flagg Card Drama Takes Another Turn
The saga around Cooper Flaggs most sought-after rookie card has taken another turn, and it has plenty of implications for collectors and anyone tracking the early market around the Mavericks new centerpiece. Jason Williams, the collector who pulled Flaggs one-of-one Rookie Debut Patch Autograph card, has opted to let the public determine its worth instead of settling for private suitors. The card has also picked up a PSA Gem Mint 10 grade, a seal that only adds to the intrigue around a piece already carrying immense attention.
Fanatics Collect is now set to showcase the card in its September Premier Auction from September 10 to 24, where the final price should help define just how high the ceiling is for Flagg memorabilia. For Dallas, it is another reminder of how quickly Flaggs arrival has become a league-wide storyline, with his cards drawing the kind of buzz that usually comes only after a player has already built a rsum. In this case, the market gets the first real say. [Read more 🡒]