Malachi Lawrence’s NFL debut was the kind of first impression the Cowboys would rather forget.
Dallas used a first-round pick on the Central Florida EDGE rusher in the 2026 NFL Draft, betting on his upside after taking Caleb Downs at No. 11.
Downs was the polished, ready-made choice. Lawrence was the swing on traits - the longer-term project in a draft class where the Cowboys needed pass-rush help and still passed on more proven production from players like Cashius Howell and R Mason Thomas.
That gamble came with some early pain.
In Pro Football Focus’ look at every first-round rookie’s debut, Dalton Wasserman gave Lawrence a rough review. The stat line told the story: one hurry on 11 pass-rush reps, two missed tackles, and major issues holding up against the run. Wasserman wrote:
“Lawrence finished Week 1 as the lowest-graded qualified rookie edge defender. He managed to record one hurry among 11 pass-rush reps but struggled in the run game, playing to a 37.2 PFF run-defense grade.
He twice lost contain on Jaxson Dart on read option plays. Lawrence also missed two tackles on the night.”
The Cowboys’ defensive front never really settled in against the Giants, and Jaxson Dart’s night didn’t turn into the kind of obvious passing script that lets edge rushers hunt freely. That limited Lawrence’s chances to just pin back and attack the quarterback.
He did at least flash a little something in the pass game. Lawrence posted a 64.5 pass-rush grade, which is slightly above average, and he logged a pressure despite playing only 11 pass-rush snaps. But the bigger concern was the part of the game that already showed up as an issue in college: defending the run.
PFF’s broader Week 1 numbers were even harsher, with Lawrence grading as the second-lowest-graded EDGE rusher in the NFL at 34.8. That doesn’t define his career, but it does underline where he is right now.
There was also some awkward usage layered into the night. Christian Parker put Lawrence in the slot twice against Isaiah Likely in zone coverage, a tough ask for a rookie edge defender. The Cowboys drafted Lawrence to rush the passer, not to mirror a receiving tight end in space, so that usage is more of a reminder of the job he’ll eventually have to handle than a reason for panic.
The bigger picture still matters here: Lawrence is a raw prospect, and raw prospects usually need time. One game doesn’t change that.
But Week 1 did offer a blunt lesson for Dallas - rookie EDGE rushers rarely walk in and solve everything right away. The hope now is that Lawrence looks a lot more comfortable in Week 2 against the Commanders.
In Other News...
Former Cowboys Receiver Just Got An Ugly Early Verdict In Miami
Jalen Tolberts first week in Miami did not go the way he could have hoped. The former Cowboys receiver was a healthy scratch for Week 1 even though he arrived as the Dolphins most accomplished pass-catcher, a surprising twist for a player who was expected to add some stability to a young receiver room.
Miami instead leaned into its rookie trio of Caleb Douglas, Chris Bell and Kevin Coleman, leaving Tolbert on the sideline and raising immediate questions about where he fits in the group. For Dallas fans who watched Tolbert try to carve out a role elsewhere, it was an ugly early sign that his next chapter may be off to a far more complicated start than anticipated. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Suddenly Have A DeMarvion Overshown Problem Again
DeMarvion Overshowns return from another injury setback is forcing the Cowboys to revisit a question they have been hoping to answer for a while. Since being drafted in 2023, the linebacker has flashed the kind of speed and playmaking that made him such an intriguing addition, but his availability has been repeatedly interrupted by major injuries, including ACL tears in both knees and a concussion.
Now a hamstring issue is expected to keep him out for 1-2 weeks, and it lands at a difficult moment because he is also in a contract year. Dallas still knows what Overshown can look like when he is healthy, which is what makes the situation so frustrating, but the bigger issue is whether the team can count on that version of him enough to shape what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Admit One Defensive Problem They Cant Ignore Anymore
Communication on defense has become hard to ignore for the Cowboys after the game against the Giants, and the concern has started to surface from the top down. Jerry Jones and Brian Schottenheimer have both acknowledged the problem, and players have followed suit, with the linebacker group drawing the most scrutiny as the team works through the absence of starter DeMarvion Overshown.
The middle of the defense has been the obvious pressure point, and it is the kind of issue that tends to snowball if it is not cleaned up quickly. One possible answer floating around the situation is veteran linebacker Bobby Wagner, whose experience would fit a group looking for steadier communication, but there has been no official move yet, leaving the Cowboys with a problem they know they need to solve. [Read more 🡒]