J.J. McCarthy’s NFL story has taken a sharp turn, and the Giants are suddenly the team benefiting from it.
What looked like a stalled career in Minnesota has become a fresh start in New York, and McCarthy is already making it count. The former first-round pick, taken 10th overall by the Vikings in the 2024 draft after they traded up to get him, never found his footing there.
Injuries played a part, but so did his own uneven development as a pro. Minnesota had already seen enough to know Kevin O’Connell - despite his reputation as one of the league’s best offensive minds - was not going to be the one to turn McCarthy from a Michigan-style game manager into a franchise quarterback.
So on September 28, the Vikings sent McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick. At the time, he was buried on the depth chart behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz, and his value had cratered.
New York, meanwhile, was scrambling after Jaxson Dart suffered meniscus and MCL injuries in his left knee in Week 2 against the Los Angeles Rams. The Giants needed help behind Jameis Winston.
McCarthy needed a reset.
That reset arrived in the most unexpected way possible during the Giants’ 34-27 Week 6 loss to the New Orleans Saints. After Winston threw an interception with 12:28 left and New York trailed 34-10 despite jumping out to a 10-0 lead, head coach John Harbaugh turned to McCarthy for a spark.
What followed was more than that. In less than a full fourth quarter, McCarthy went 11 of 21 for 243 yards, a touchdown, an interception, and a 90.0 passer rating.
The eye-opening part wasn’t just the volume - it was the way he attacked downfield and kept hitting explosive throws on the money.
That performance earned him a spot in Secret Superstars for Week 6, and it also earned him the starting job for Week 7 against the Houston Texans. DeMeco Ryans’ defense wasn’t the 2025 version that looked like the NFL’s best, but it still presented a real test.
McCarthy handled it. In a 27-21 overtime win, he completed 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards with no touchdowns, no interceptions, and a 99.1 passer rating. The Giants leaned on the run game, but McCarthy kept delivering accurate throws, and the offense started to show how its route concepts are helping him operate within what he can do right now.
There’s also been a fit issue here that seems to be working in his favor. McCarthy has connected with offensive coordinator Matt Nagy, senior offensive assistant Greg Roman, and passing game coordinator/quarterbacks coach Brian Callahan. Those hires didn’t exactly set the offseason buzzing, but they’ve given him a structure that suits him.
“Preparation,” McCarthy said after the Texans game, when asked how the tight-window throws have been such a big part of his recent performances. “I feel like preparation, over the years of playing football, you just refine the routine each and every week.
I feel like I’m in a really good spot right now, just Monday through Saturday and just being able to have that trust in these guys as early as now, since I’ve been here. I haven’t been here long, but I trust those guys every time the ball comes out of my hand.
I trust the offensive line up front. I trust the backs are going to get us in great situations when I do hit the checkdowns, but at the end of the day, it’s the players around me.”
Now the 4-2-1 Giants turn to a 2-6 Philadelphia Eagles team that has been a major disappointment, with Vic Fangio’s defense taking a surprising step back. Fangio praised New York on Tuesday and singled out McCarthy, too.
“They’ve got a really good offense. They’ve got skill at the receiving position.
They did a nice job raiding the Ravens, not only for John [Harbaugh], but for [TE Isaiah] Likely and [FB Patrick] Ricard. They’ve got a lot of the Ravens-type offense that they had when Greg [Roman] was there, and they’ve intermixed Kansas City-type passing in there with Matt [Nagy].
They’ve got it going right now. They’ve got good wideouts, good tight ends, two good backs.
The quarterback has come in, in a short period of time, and really done a nice job, for them to get him for a [fifth-round] pick is a steal.”
If McCarthy keeps this going and pushes the NFC East-leading Giants to the playoffs for the first time since the 2022 season, this won’t just be a comeback story. It’ll be the start of a whole new chapter.
In Other News...
Cowboys May Catch Colts Right Before A Deadline Shakeup
The Colts are expected to keep the phone lines warm, but not much more, until after their Week 9 meeting with the Cowboys. Indianapolis has already drawn inquiries on several players, including Jonathan Taylor, Josh Downs and Grover Stewart, and the timing matters because the trade deadline is set for Nov. 10, leaving a narrow window for any deal to get done.
For Dallas, that means Sunday could come just before a busy stretch of roster chatter around an opponent that may look different by the time the deadline passes. Jordan Schultz reported the Colts intend to revisit offers after the Cowboys game, which puts a spotlight on a team that could be weighing multiple possibilities at once and leaves plenty of uncertainty about how aggressive Indianapolis will ultimately be. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Pass Rusher Fires Back As Defensive Frustration Boils Over
Quinnen Williams has been one of the few bright spots on a Cowboys defense that has spent much of this season fighting uphill, and his message in a recent news conference was plain enough: the group needs to execute. With Dallas sitting near the bottom of the league in both yards and points allowed, the frustration around the unit has only grown, and Williams, who leads the team in sacks, has become one of the most visible voices trying to steady it.
Skip Bayless latched onto Williams repeated use of that word and twisted it into a much darker interpretation, saying the pass rusher was calling for players to be "executed on the field." Williams pushed back on social media, turning a routine football point into another flashpoint around a defense already under pressure. For a Cowboys team still searching for answers, even the language around accountability is becoming part of the story. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Injury Report Raises New Concern As George Pickens Role Looms
The Cowboys Week 9 injury report brought a familiar kind of midseason unease, with 16 players listed and seven of them not practicing. Among the names drawing the most attention were Jake Ferguson, Caleb Downs, P.J. Locke and Malachi Lawrence, a group that underscores how thin the roster can look when the weeks workload starts to pile up.
Caleb Downs and P.J. Locke are both in concussion protocol, and Malachi Lawrence is expected to miss a few weeks, leaving Dallas with more uncertainty than it would like this early in November. At the same time, Brian Schottenheimer is trying to navigate George Pickens limited snaps, a situation he tied to the receivers injuries while acknowledging the offense needs to do a better job getting him involved. [Read more 🡒]