The Cowboys came out of Sunday night’s loss to the Giants with a whole lot of problems and not a single clean win to hang their hat on. Dallas’ first drive never found a rhythm, Jaxson Dart kept the New York offense rolling, and the defense that was supposed to look transformed after all the offseason investment looked far too familiar instead.
That’s why Week 1 leaves this report card with no easy escapes. No one earned an A, and the grades tell the story of a team that was off from top to bottom.
Tyler Guyton was one of the few bright spots. The Cowboys’ left tackle handled a tough assignment against Brian Burns, the 14th-ranked player in the NFL, and Burns’ 16.5-sack season in 2025 made the matchup even trickier. Guyton gave up no pressure in 20 pass-blocking matchups against Burns, which is a strong night by any standard even if it wasn’t spotless.
Cobie Durant also held up well. Dart didn’t need to throw all over Dallas, but when he did test the secondary, Durant stayed tight, played with some edge, and broke up a pass that really should have been picked off.
Caleb Downs had one of the game’s flashiest moments when he came free on a blitz, hit Dart for a sack, and forced a fumble. The problem for Dallas was that the ball never came back to them. It was a nice debut play, but not one that will stand out much after the final score.
Donovan Ezeiruaku was active all night and led the team with ten tackles. He added two pressures and forced a fumble, but again the Cowboys couldn’t fall on the ball. He also had one rough read when Dart rolled left and Ezeiruaku bit inside on the fake, but he was still among the more productive defenders in a bad outing.
Dak Prescott’s night was more complicated. He wasn’t the reason Dallas lost, but the interception before halftime changed the game fast.
The Giants turned that into a touchdown before the break, then opened the third quarter with another score. The passing game never really produced the kind of explosive plays Dallas needed, and George Pickens’ deep-ball drop didn’t help.
Javonte Williams might have been the only player in line for an A before one mistake dragged him down. He scored twice and ran with force, but the unsportsmanlike penalty after his second touchdown hurt Dallas badly by putting Brandon Aubrey in position to kick a long extra point instead of letting Brian Schottenheimer go for two. For a veteran, that kind of penalty can’t happen.
Terence Steele held up better than expected given the pressure around him entering the season. The Giants’ front is a real test, and Abdul Carter made life difficult, but Steele won a couple of battles on the edge and didn’t surrender a sack. Still, pressure from that side found Prescott too often.
Jaishawn Barham’s NFL debut had some encouraging moments and some rough ones. He opened with a stop in the backfield that nearly turned into a suplex and drew a penalty risk, but his angles in run support weren’t always sharp.
On Devin Singletary’s touchdown, it looked like he eased up before the back crossed the goal line. There’s still plenty to work with, especially with DeMarvion Overshown expected to miss time with a hamstring injury.
The Cowboys’ pass rush as a whole never got enough done. The Giants’ offensive line was built up for a reason, but Dallas still needed more heat on Dart and didn’t come close often enough. Rashan Gary, Quinnen Williams, Malachi Lawrence, and Kenny Clark were supposed to help tilt the game toward the defense, and instead the Giants lived in a clean pocket.
Communication was the other major failure. Brian Schottenheimer’s Monday review centered on the defense needing to talk better, which is hardly encouraging when that was the same issue the team spent the offseason trying to fix. Players being out of position or not getting the right call helped sink Dallas, and Christian Parker has a lot to clean up after the Cowboys walked out of MetLife Stadium with their first loss of the season.
In Other News...
ESPN Just Reignited An NFL Double Standard Debate Fans Know Well
ESPNs Monday Night Football coverage of the Broncos-Chiefs game briefly shifted away from the action when sideline reporter Laura Rutledge explained why Denver defender Jonathon Cooper was unavailable, noting his placement on the commissioners exempt list after domestic violence charges. The mention instantly turned a routine injury-and-availability update into something much bigger, because it touched on one of the NFLs most sensitive and inconsistently handled issues.
Former Broncos safety Justin Simmons was quick to criticize ESPN for bringing Coopers legal situation into the broadcast, and the reaction rippled well beyond the sideline report. Some former players and fans defended the network, arguing the explanation was relevant context for his absence, while others zeroed in on the broader double standard debate that always seems to follow when similar situations come up with different players and different teams. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Rookie Already Drawing Heat At The Worst Possible Time
Jaishawn Barhams first NFL game came with a little more responsibility than anyone probably expected. With DeMarvion Overshown sidelined by a hamstring injury, the Cowboys rookie linebacker was thrown into a bigger role and ended up playing 34 defensive snaps in his debut, a workload that gave the team a real look at where he stands early in his career.
The evaluation was mixed. Pro Football Focus had Barham as the fourth-highest-graded defender on the roster, which is a promising sign for a player making his first appearance, but one missed effort on a crucial play quickly became part of the conversation after it helped set up a touchdown. If Overshown remains out, the Cowboys may have to lean on Barham again soon, which makes the next few games an important test for how quickly he can turn raw opportunity into trust. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Suddenly Have More Than One Problem After Week 1
The Cowboys came out of Week 1 with more than a loss on the ledger. Dallas looked unsettled on both sides of the ball against the Giants, with the offense unable to find much rhythm around Dak Prescott and the defense failing to provide the usual cushion the team expects early in the season. It was the kind of opener that leaves a staff sorting through several different issues at once instead of one clean fix.
DeMarvion Overshowns injury only added to the unease on a defense already trying to regain its footing, and even Brandon Aubreys status as a reliable edge has started to draw more attention after the shaky showing. For a team that entered the season expecting to compete right away, the challenge now is figuring out which problems are temporary and which ones might linger long enough to shape the next few weeks. [Read more 🡒]