Jaishawn Barham gave the Cowboys exactly the kind of debut that gets everyone talking, but the bigger takeaway from Saturday’s win over the Arizona Cardinals was the continued concern around Drew Shelton.
Barham was finally on the field after a groin injury kept him out of Week 1, and he wasted no time making an impression. In 22 snaps, the third-round pick finished with four tackles, three defensive stops, and a 90.1 player grade from PFF, the best mark on the Cowboys. He flashed everywhere - plugging run lanes, standing up ball-carriers, and showing real awareness in coverage.
While Barham looked like a difference-maker, Shelton turned in another rough outing that the Cowboys can’t shrug off. After switching sides with Nate Thomas to work at left tackle, Shelton didn’t look much more comfortable. His run blocking was a little better, but only a little, and his 47.9 grade was the lowest of any Cowboys offensive lineman who played at least 10 snaps.
The pass protection numbers were even uglier. Over 25 pass-blocking snaps, Shelton gave up four pressures, two hurries, and a sack, which led to a 3.0 pass-blocking grade from PFF.
That follows a shaky showing against the Seahawks, when he allowed three pressures, a hurry, and two quarterback hits at right tackle. Changing sides didn’t solve anything.
Shelton’s preseason line makes the problem plain: this is not a player ready to be trusted. He needs a lot of work, which isn’t shocking for a Day 3 rookie, but it does matter when he looks overmatched at both tackle spots.
The encouraging part is that he’s a strong athlete, and one year in Klayton Adams and Conor Riley’s system could change the picture. Right now, though, he doesn’t look playable.
That leaves Nate Thomas as the likely swing tackle unless Dallas brings in a veteran. And that’s where things get interesting for a team that may have to start thinking through emergency plans if one of the tackles goes down.
One option would be to move Tyler Guyton to right tackle, slide Tyler Smith to left tackle, and insert T.J. Bass at left guard, giving Dallas its best five linemen on the field.
Another would keep Guyton at left tackle, Tyler Smith at left guard, Cooper Beebe at center, Tyler Booker at right guard, and Nate Thomas at right tackle. If Guyton were the one who got hurt, the Cowboys could be looking at a mix of Nate Thomas and Tyler Smith at left tackle, Tyler Smith or T.J.
Bass at left guard, Beebe at center, Booker at right guard, and Terence Steele at right tackle.
Those are the kinds of conversations that have likely already come up at The Star.
What’s clear now is that Shelton is not part of the starting picture. The Cowboys had hoped he could challenge Guyton for left tackle reps, but he’s not even putting heat on Thomas for the swing tackle job. At this point, he looks headed toward being a healthy scratch when the games count.
And with less urgency to add to the running back room after Saturday’s performance, Dallas may turn its attention to a veteran offensive tackle before Week 1.
In Other News...
Eagles Rookie Is Giving Cowboys Fans A Reason To Laugh
Training camp has already given Cowboys fans one small comfort in Philadelphia, and it comes courtesy of a rookie tight end who was supposed to help stabilize the Eagles passing game. Eli Stowers, a second-round pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, has instead spent much of camp and the preseason fighting to find his footing, with his blocking and receiving both drawing scrutiny as the Eagles try to sort through a depth chart battered by injuries at receiver.
For Dallas, the details are almost beside the point. Any time a division rival invests premium draft capital and then sees the early returns wobble, it invites the kind of unflattering comparisons that stick around, and Stowers has already been mentioned in the same breath as JJ Arcega-Whiteside, another second-round Eagles pick who never lived up to the billing. The bigger issue for Philadelphia is immediate pressure, because the injuries around him leave the rookie with even less margin for error as the season approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Suddenly Have A Real Roster Decision At Two Key Spots
The Cowboys got a useful look at a few roster battles in their second preseason game, and it did more than just fill out the exhibition calendar. Joe Milton kept building his case to be the backup quarterback, while wide receivers Camden Brown and Jonathan Mingo both put themselves in the conversation for final roster spots. With cutdowns approaching, Dallas is watching not just who plays well, but who keeps stacking productive snaps when the competition gets tighter.
Snap counts are becoming part of the conversation too, which is usually a sign the decisions are getting real. The Cowboys are sorting through a deeper receiving mix and weighing how much value each player brings beyond one good night in August, and they are also open to exploring trades if that helps shape the 53-man roster. For a team trying to balance upside, depth and certainty, the next few evaluations may matter as much as anything that happened in the preseason opener. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Suddenly Face A Tough QB Roster Decision
Dak Prescott is locked in as the Cowboys starter, but the competition behind him has become one of the more interesting roster questions in camp. Sam Howell and Joe Milton III have both put together strong preseason stretches, enough to make Dallas at least consider carrying all three quarterbacks on the 53-man roster even though teams usually prefer to keep just two.
Todd Archer of ESPN projects that possibility, and it speaks to how much the backup battle has shifted from a routine depth issue to a real decision point. The Cowboys still have not settled the spot behind Prescott, and with the preseason winding down, the outcome is less about naming a favorite and more about deciding whether either Howell or Milton has done enough to force an extra quarterback onto the roster. [Read more 🡒]