The Cowboys’ Week 9 inactive list answered one question about George Pickens and immediately opened the door to a bigger one.
Pickens will not play against the Indianapolis Colts, marking the first game he has missed this season and the first time he has not suited up for Dallas. With the trade deadline only days away, that naturally got people talking. But the signs point more toward injury than any sort of last-minute move.
Pickens had been working through issues on the injury report for weeks. He first showed up with a shoulder injury in Week 7, then dealt with shoulder and hamstring problems in Week 8, and entered Week 9 listed only with a hamstring issue. He was tagged questionable before ultimately being ruled out on Sunday.
Dallas also never sounded especially optimistic about his availability. Head coach Brian Schottenheimer said only that he was "hopeful" Pickens would play, and the team elevated a wide receiver from the practice squad on Saturday, which looked like another clue that Pickens might not be available.
That fits with the reporting around the league, too. Nick Harris of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram reported on Friday that the Cowboys have no interest in moving Pickens before the deadline.
As Harris wrote: "The fifth-year pass-catcher and second-year Cowboy is playing this season on the franchise tag after the team elected not to discuss a long-term contract with him in the offseason. Despite trade rhetoric around the time of that decision being announced, the Cowboys never engaged in trying to send him away.
Seven months later, that strategy remains the same ahead of the deadline, according to multiple sources," Harris said.
NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport has said the same thing from his end. "As of right now there’s nothing there," Rapoport said.
For now, the Cowboys appear to be headed past the deadline with Pickens still on the roster and the bigger questions pushed to the offseason. He is set to be a free agent again, and Dallas will have to decide whether to extend him, franchise-tag him again or let him reach the open market.
Stephen Jones has already made clear how complicated that gets. "The situation we have with George Pickens going alongside CeeDee..
I don’t know of any teams that really can pay two top receivers top of the market," Jones said. "So, yeah.
That’s going to be a real difficult situation as we move forward. We’ve managed to figure out how we can do it for this year."
A second franchise tag remains on the table, though it is unclear whether Pickens would be willing to accept that again. If he is not, a holdout could become part of the conversation. Dallas could also tag and trade him.
And if the Cowboys simply let him walk, there is still the possibility of a third-round compensatory pick. That makes free agency a realistic path as well.
In Other News...
Jerry Jones Is Defending A Cowboys Issue Fans Know Too Well
Jerry Jones pushed back on the familiar criticism that the Cowboys have been reluctant to spend for coaching, saying paying top dollar for successful coaches has never been an issue for the franchise. It is the kind of comment that tends to land differently in Dallas, where every move is measured against expectations, and it comes as the team turns its attention to the Colts with a roster already being tested by injuries to multiple starters.
KaVontae Turpin and Malachi Lawrence are among the players ruled out, adding another layer of uncertainty to a week that already carries some urgency. With the NFL trade deadline approaching, the Cowboys are also weighing whether to add a pressure player to help a defense that could use more disruption, leaving the front office with one more decision that will say plenty about how aggressively it wants to chase a fix. [Read more 🡒]
Skip Bayless Just Reopened A Painful Cowboys Coaching What-If
The Cowboys 2024 coaching change has already become one of those familiar Dallas debates, and Skip Bayless jumped right back into it by saying Jim Harbaugh would have been his choice to replace Mike McCarthy. It is the kind of alternative-history conversation that always hangs around this franchise, especially when a job opens and the search quickly turns into a referendum on how Jerry Jones likes to operate.
Bayless also suggested Jones would never go for Harbaugh because of his commanding personality, which is exactly the sort of friction that has fueled plenty of Cowboys what-ifs over the years. Harbaugh, of course, ended up with the Baltimore Ravens, leaving Dallas to keep living with the question of what might have been if the owner had been willing to embrace a coach with that kind of edge. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Rookie Surge Comes With One Growing Concern On Defense
Eight games into the season, the Cowboys rookie class on defense has already become a meaningful part of the conversation. Caleb Downs has brought steady play and a knack for showing up around the ball, while Malachi Lawrence flashed enough early to suggest real upside before the injury bug entered the picture. Jaishawn Barham, meanwhile, helped give the group a strong opening stretch and added to the sense that Dallas may have found multiple young defenders who can matter right away.
The concern now is less about talent than trajectory, because the early promise has not looked equally stable across the board. Downs has remained the most reliable of the group, but Lawrences availability has become an issue and Barhams recent dip has taken some shine off his fast start. For a defense trying to build something sustainable, the rookies have offered reasons for optimism, but they have also introduced a reminder that development rarely moves in a straight line. [Read more 🡒]