The Dallas Cowboys spent the offseason trying to reshape their defense, and on that front, they’ve at least made the kind of changes that signal urgency. Matt Eberflus is gone.
Christian Parker is in. A wave of new players has been added.
Whether it all works won’t be known until the games start, but the intent was obvious.
What’s harder to defend is what Dallas did - or didn’t do - at tackle.
The Cowboys have drawn plenty of attention for making Tyler Guyton fight for his job in 2026, and that makes sense. He hasn’t delivered over his first two years. But the bigger miss, the one that could haunt them, is that Dallas didn’t create real competition on both edges of the offensive line.
Terence Steele should have been in that same conversation.
Since 2023, Steele has been a problem, and the numbers back it up. According to Pro Football Focus, he allowed 8 sacks, 54 pressures and 7 penalties in 2023 while posting grades of 57.2 in run-blocking and 45.9 in pass-blocking.
In 2024, he gave up 9 sacks, 41 pressures and 7 penalties, with grades of 78.9 in run-blocking and 57.5 in pass-blocking. In 2025, the line again showed cracks: 6 sacks, 52 pressures and 7 penalties, along with grades of 70.2 in run-blocking and 54.9 in pass-blocking.
Even with that track record, Dallas does not appear interested in making Steele earn the right to keep his starting spot the way it is with Guyton.
The left tackle situation doesn’t look much more convincing. On paper, Guyton is competing with Nate Thomas.
In practice, that battle has not looked especially close. The Athletic’s Jon Machota put it plainly: "It’s a competition between Tyler Guyton and Nate Thomas, but Guyton is the clear favorite," The Athletic's Jon Machota noted.
"He was the one running with the first-team through minicamp practices. As long as he can stay healthy, Guyton should hold down that spot in his third season."
Thomas hasn’t exactly forced the issue, either. The former seventh-round pick struggled in limited action in 2025, finishing with PFF grades of 31.6 in pass-blocking and 52.9 in run-blocking while allowing three sacks and 23 pressures in only 219 pass-blocking snaps.
Dallas did use a fourth-round pick on Drew Shelton out of Penn State, but he was never likely to be immediate competition for Guyton. He needs development time, and there’s no guarantee he becomes a real answer.
That leaves the Cowboys in a tough spot at both tackle positions. If Steele and Guyton don’t bounce back in 2026, Dallas may be forced to lean on Thomas and/or Shelton, and neither one is assured to solve the problem.
There is another option in Tyler Smith, but the Cowboys want to keep him at guard. And if Smith moves outside, that creates another hole because Dallas would then have to count on T.J. Bass as a starter.
With the defense still needing to prove itself, the Cowboys are likely to depend heavily on their offense. That’s why the lack of a stronger plan at both tackle spots stands out so much.
In Other News...
Jerry Jones Is Already Facing Heat Over One Cowboys Defensive Call
The Cowboys decision to move on from Osa Odighizuwa is already drawing scrutiny, and it is easy to see why. Dallas has been working to trim salary-cap commitments and stockpile draft capital, and the trade was part of that broader plan while also creating a clearer path for younger defensive linemen to play more. It is the kind of roster-management move that can make sense in the abstract, especially for a team trying to balance present needs with future flexibility.
Still, the reaction has not been uniformly positive, because the choice invites an obvious comparison to Kenny Clark, who remains on the roster. One ESPN analyst questioned whether Dallas may have let the better long-term defensive tackle go, and that kind of second-guessing tends to linger when a front office is trying to sell a move as part of a bigger strategy. For Jerry Jones, the challenge now is not just defending the logic of the trade, but proving the Cowboys got the right side of the defensive line equation. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys May Already Regret One Offensive Line Depth Decision
The Cowboys decision not to tender Brock Hoffman looked like a routine depth move at the time, but it has taken on a different feel with the interior line picture shifting again. Hoffman had quietly given Dallas useful flexibility as a backup center and guard, the kind of insurance policy teams tend to miss only after it is gone.
Now the concern is less about what Hoffman was then and more about what Dallas has left behind him. With the lines depth chart already thinned, the Cowboys are leaning more heavily on T.J. Bass behind Cooper Beebe, and Hoffmans ability to handle multiple interior spots makes the choice to move on from him look increasingly questionable. [Read more 🡒]