The Cowboys took a lot of heat for Brian Schottenheimer’s decision to go for two late in Thursday night’s loss, but that wasn’t the only coaching call worth circling. The more interesting one came much earlier, and it started with a punt that felt like a quiet admission.
Near the midway point of the second quarter, Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb couldn’t hook up on third-and-10. That left Dallas facing fourth-and-10 at the Tampa Bay 47-yard line. Instead of sending Brandon Aubrey out for a 64-yard try, the Cowboys punted.
That choice matters because Aubrey is viewed as one of the better long-range kickers in the league. At the same time, Dallas has recently watched two of those monster attempts go sideways.
Aubrey had a 59-yard try blocked by the Baltimore Ravens, then had a 62-yard attempt blocked by the Houston Texans a week later. Schottenheimer followed that by sending him out for a 65-yarder against Houston on the next possession after the block, and Aubrey missed it outright.
After that game, Texans coach DeMeco Ryans said they were partly able to block the kick because of something they saw on film from Dallas’ game against Baltimore.
That’s the kind of sequence that sticks with a staff. It also makes the punting decision against Tampa Bay feel less random than it might have looked in real time.
The Cowboys had reasons to be cautious, and those recent blocked kicks had to be sitting somewhere in the back of their minds. It also doesn’t help that the whole situation reflects poorly on Schottenheimer and, specifically, special teams coordinator Nick Sorensen.
Still, there’s no way to know for sure that fear over another block drove the call. The numbers around Dallas’ recent punt choices do hint at how unusual it was, though.
Fort Worth Star-Telegram reporter Nick Harris noted that the last time the Cowboys punted from across the 50-yard line was midway through last year. The last time they punted from inside the 47-yard line came late in the 2024 season, though Dak Prescott was already out for the year by then, which changes the decision-making.
In the end, the punt didn’t cost Dallas anything directly. Tampa Bay punted right back, so nothing came of it.
But the alternate version is easy to see. If Aubrey gets the 64-yarder, then the Cowboys can go for two later and turn the game into a three-point margin.
If they convert that, then the late-game math changes completely, with only a field goal needed to tie at the end of regulation. It’s all hypothetical, but it all traces back to one decision: Dallas passed on letting Brandon Aubrey try the kick.
In Other News...
Cowboys Fans Already Have A Week 5 Scoreboard To Sweat
At 2-3, the Cowboys are already in the familiar spot of watching the rest of the conference as closely as they watch their own sideline. Week 5 brings the kind of scoreboard math Dallas cant ignore, especially with NFC East results carrying extra weight so early in the season and a handful of other matchups around the league shaping the playoff picture if the Cowboys keep drifting around .500.
The most immediate attention is on the division games that can either help Dallas close ground or make the climb steeper, with Washington set to have a significant piece back in the mix. There is also a deeper layer for Cowboys fans to keep in mind beyond the present standings, since a couple of other games this week have ripple effects tied to future draft capital from past trades, which gives the rooting guide a little more range than your usual early-October scoreboard watch. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Have A Jake Ferguson Problem Fans Cant Ignore
Jake Fergusons rough afternoon fit neatly into a bigger Cowboys problem, because the offense could not afford wasted chances in a game where the defense was already getting pushed around. Ferguson has been a key part of Dallas passing game, but the tight ends recent decline has become hard to ignore since the ACL sprain, and the ball-security issues that have followed him since last season only add to the concern.
The timing makes it sting even more for Dallas, which committed to Ferguson long term after moving Micah Parsons. With guaranteed money now tied up in a player expected to be a stable piece of the offense, the Cowboys need far more than occasional flashes from a position that is supposed to help steady Dak Prescott. Instead, the discussion around Ferguson keeps circling back to the same uncomfortable question the team can no longer dodge. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Fans Have An Uncomfortable Week 5 Reality To Root For
The Cowboys head into the week at 2-3 after the loss to Tampa Bay, and for all the frustration around that start, the bigger picture may now be just as important as the next snap. With NFC East and NFC North results carrying extra weight, Dallas fans have reason to keep one eye on the standings and another on the draft board, because this season is already shaping up to affect more than just the playoff chase.
Philadelphias roster keeps shifting, and Washington could be getting Jayden Daniels back, which adds another layer to a division race that already feels volatile. For Dallas, the uncomfortable part is that these outcomes now matter in more than one direction, with the teams own future assets also hanging in the balance as the season unfolds. [Read more 🡒]