The Cowboys had plenty of problems against the 49ers, but one of the strangest was self-inflicted: DeMarvion Overshown barely got on the field.
Overshown returned from a one-game absence and was available, yet he played only five defensive snaps. Given what happened the week before, it’s hard not to read that as discipline after his costly decision to run onto the field in street clothes to celebrate a forced fumble against the Colts, which drew a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty.
There’s an argument for accountability there. Schottenheimer had every reason to send a message. But the punishment looked extreme when stacked against how Dallas handled George Pickens and CeeDee Lamb last year, when both were benched for only the opening drive against the Raiders after missing curfew.
And the timing could hardly have been worse. San Francisco spent all afternoon attacking the middle of the Cowboys’ defense, while Overshown watched from the sideline for nearly the entire game.
That’s what makes the decision so hard to defend. When healthy, Overshown has been Dallas’ most complete linebacker. He’s not perfect, but he brings downhill speed, finishing power and enough coverage ability to be the closest thing the roster has to a well-rounded off-ball linebacker.
Instead, Shemar James played every defensive snap, and Dee Winters was on the field for 58 of 65 defensive plays, according to Pro Football Focus. Both were among Dallas’ lowest-graded defenders in a game where the entire unit got worked over.
Winters posted a 29.0 PFF grade. He had three stops, missed two tackles and gave up four catches on four targets for 75 yards and a touchdown. Brock Purdy finished with a perfect passer rating of 158.3 when throwing at his former teammate.
James wasn’t much better, finishing with a 29.6 PFF grade. He allowed just 17 yards in coverage, but he got pushed around against the run, struggled to work through traffic at the second level and couldn’t consistently take advantage of the lanes created up front. He also was part of the confusion Dallas showed before the snap more than once, which reflects poorly on him as the unit’s primary communicator.
The Cowboys didn’t have many other answers. Rookie Jaishawn Barham has been taken out of the off-ball linebacker rotation and played all 21 of his defensive snaps against San Francisco on the edge.
Overshown, meanwhile, had been flashing before Week 9. He made splash plays in back-to-back games against the Eagles and Cardinals, then barely saw the field against a San Francisco team that was much tougher than either of those opponents.
That’s true. But it also raises the obvious question: if this was about discipline, why was the response so severe?
Missing curfew is serious. So is running onto the field in the middle of a game in street clothes.
No one is pretending Overshown’s mistake was smart. Still, the gap in punishment stands out.
Lamb and Pickens sat for one possession. Overshown was effectively shelved for an entire game.
Schottenheimer deserves credit for holding players accountable. That part is clear. But against a 49ers offense that kept hammering the middle of the field, Dallas may have sent its message at the expense of one of its better defenders.
Overshown practiced in full to close out the week and had averaged 51 defensive snaps in his previous three appearances before Sunday’s five-snap night, which amounted to 8 percent of the defense’s work. When he’s healthy, he’s usually on the field.
If the benching was for discipline, the Cowboys could have made their point without going all the way to that extreme. Bench him for the first drive. Maybe the first quarter.
Not the entire game.
In Other News...
Cowboys Power Ranking Jump Ignores One Problem Fans Can't Unsee
The Cowboys have been easy to read in one respect this season: when the offense is rolling, it can look like one of the leagues most dangerous units. Dak Prescott has helped drive that reputation with a sharp passing attack, and the latest performance only reinforced how explosive this side of the roster can be when everything is clicking.
But the bigger picture is harder to ignore, even as the team climbs in power rankings. Dallas keeps showing the same split personality, with one side carrying the load while the other leaves too much to clean up. Analysts have pointed to the defense as the glaring concern, and until that part of the roster steadies itself, the Cowboys will keep living with the same uncomfortable question about how far this version of the team can really go. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Make Telling Christian Parker Change After 49ers Collapse
The Cowboys are making a notable adjustment on defense after another rough outing, shifting the burden of game-day play-calling away from Christian Parker in the wake of the loss to the 49ers. Parker is staying on staff, but the move underscores how seriously Dallas is treating the recent slide on that side of the ball and how much pressure has built around the units performance.
Mike Pettine, the senior defensive assistant, is stepping into the game-day role as the Cowboys look for a steadier voice and cleaner operation on Sundays. Parker will remain with the team for the rest of the season, but this is still a significant change for a defense trying to stop the bleeding and regain some confidence before the year moves any further along. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Defense Just Put Christian Parker Under Even More Pressure
After 10 weeks, the Cowboys have made a notable shift on defense, moving the play-calling responsibilities away from defensive coordinator Christian Parker and handing them to senior assistant coach Mike Pettine. The change comes on the heels of a string of uneven defensive outings, including the kind of performance against the San Francisco 49ers that tends to force a team to rethink who is steering things on that side of the ball.
Parker is still with the team, but in an undefined defensive role, which leaves some intrigue about how much influence he will continue to have as the Cowboys try to steady that unit. For now, the message is clear enough: Dallas is looking for a different voice in the headset, even if the broader picture on Parkers future with the staff is still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
