The Cowboys went into the season expecting their rookie class to help prop up a defense that needed it. Eight games in, that group has done more than just fill spots - but not every first-year player has taken the same path.
Caleb Downs has been the most dependable of the bunch. Malachi Lawrence has flashed enough to earn more work.
Jaishawn Barham started fast, then hit a rough patch. And L.T.
Overton has quietly carved out a real role in the middle of a crowded defensive tackle room.
Downs, in particular, has given Dallas something steady on a defense that has been anything but. He hasn’t played like a finished product, and nobody should have expected that from a rookie defensive back, especially one adjusting to a new position while working alongside backups at different spots. But he has held his own.
According to Sūmer Sports, Downs is tied for 11th among safeties with 11 impact plays. He’s tied for seventh with 10 run stops, and only Jesse Bates has forced more fumbles. His best work has come against the run, and his defining snap came this past Sunday when he stonewalled Jeremiyah Love on the goal line.
He’s also shown up as a blitzer. Downs has an 83.2 PFF pass-rush grade, which ranks fifth at the position.
Coverage has been the tougher part. Downs is allowing 0.87 yards per coverage snap and has given up 227 receiving yards so far. That was always going to take time for a first-year nickel cornerback, and even with those growing pains, he’s been the least of Dallas’ issues in the secondary.
Lawrence’s season has been more of a roller coaster. Brian Schottenheimer recently said the first-round pick deserved more playing time, and Lawrence answered with his best outing of the year against Tampa Bay: two pressures, a sack, multiple QB hits and a batted pass.
Since then, though, the production has cooled. He didn’t log a pressure against the Packers or Eagles, then finished with two pressures and another QB hit against Arizona. The upside is obvious, but the week-to-week consistency is still coming.
Through the season, Lawrence has posted a 12.6 percent pass-rush win rate, which ranks 38th among all edge rushers and third among rookie EDGEs. He now has to wait a bit to build on that after suffering an ankle injury in Week 8. Brian Schottenheimer said it’s a multi-week injury, and it’s not yet clear whether Lawrence will land on IR.
Barham’s story has gone in the opposite direction. He burst out of the gate with 12 defensive stops and a couple of pressures over his first three games, and the move to MIKE linebacker has looked like a smart one. Christian Parker has had a rough first season as defensive coordinator, but converting Barham into an off-ball linebacker was the right call.
Through Week 8, Barham has as many impact plays - 16 - as Jordyn Brooks, Nakobe Dean, Ventrell Miller, Quay Walker and Jacob Rodriguez. He’s tied for 11th among linebackers with 17 run stops and ranks eighth with an 11.2 percent run-stop rate.
The issue is coverage. Barham is still losing track of his responsibilities in the flat and working through the quarterback’s eyes and pre-snap motion. That has shown up in the numbers: he’s allowing 1.41 yards per coverage snap and 8.81 yards per target.
His playing time has dropped, too. After averaging 47.5 snaps over the first six games, the third-round pick has played just 37 snaps over the last two weeks, per PFF.
DeMarvion Overshown’s return lines up with that, though Dee Winters has also missed the last two games. Shemar James has been on the field more than Barham lately.
Overton rounds out the class with a quieter but useful season. It’s not easy to stand out in a defensive tackle room with Quinnen Williams doing so much damage every week, and Elijah Garcia has also become a real depth option. Even so, Overton has kept a steady role, playing about 20-25 snaps a game.
The Alabama product has helped against the run with five impact plays and two stuffed runs, and he has missed only one tackle. He’s also shown some pass-rush juice from his days as an EDGE, producing six pressures - almost as many as Lawrence.
For a fourth-round rookie, that’s a solid start. Overton has found a lane behind Quinnen Williams, Kenny Clark and Otito Ogbonnia, and that’s no small thing.
In Other News...
Brandon Aubrey Just Added Fuel To A Cowboys Offensive Debate
Brandon Aubrey has become one of the more interesting voices around the Cowboys offense, even if his job description remains the same. In a recent interview, the kicker talked through how he prepares and how he sees the flow of games, offering a perspective that naturally comes with standing on the sideline and watching drives unfold. He stopped short of speaking for the coaching staff, but his read on the situation was clear enough: once Dallas gets into field goal range, the decision-making can get more conservative.
That view lands in the middle of a broader debate about how aggressive the Cowboys should be when drives stall near scoring territory. Through Week 9, Dallas had attempted the fewest fourth-down conversions inside field goal range, a number that fits the cautious approach Aubrey described. It is the kind of detail that does not settle the argument on its own, but it does add another layer to how the Cowboys are weighing risk, points and the trust they place in their own offense. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Defense Keeps Making The Micah Parsons Debate Even Worse
The Micah Parsons trade has only grown harder to defend as the Cowboys head into Week 9 against the Indianapolis Colts. Dallas sent Parsons to Green Bay in 2025 for Kenny Clark, and the move was supposed to help reshape the defense, but the unit has not looked the part since losing one of the leagues most disruptive players.
Brian Baldinger recently pointed to the Cowboys defensive struggles as a major reason the team has slid to a 3-5 record and faces an uphill climb in the playoff race. With the season already hanging in the balance, every rough stretch on that side of the ball seems to reopen the same uncomfortable question about what Dallas gave up and what it has gotten back. [Read more 🡒]
Jerry Jones Is Defending A Cowboys Issue Fans Know Too Well
Jerry Jones pushed back this week on the familiar criticism that the Cowboys are reluctant to spend big when it comes to coaching, saying paying top dollar for successful coaches has never been the issue in Dallas. It was the kind of message Jones has delivered before, but it landed at a time when the Cowboys are trying to steady themselves for a game against the Indianapolis Colts and keep the focus on football rather than the usual questions about how the organization operates.
The timing matters because Dallas is already juggling roster concerns, with injuries thinning out the depth chart and the defense still looking for more disruption up front. With the NFL trade deadline approaching, the Cowboys are at least exploring the possibility of adding a pressure player to help that side of the ball, a move that would fit the urgency of the moment even if the bigger debate around how Dallas builds and supports its coaches is far from settled. [Read more 🡒]