The Dallas Cowboys still have plenty to sort out in Oxnard, but the backup running back job may be the one that refuses to come into focus.
After one preseason game and nearly three weeks of practice, most of the roster battles are beginning to settle. The final two preseason games should help with the rest.
But at running back, the picture is somehow messier now than it was when camp opened. And after Brian Schottenheimer’s Thursday media session, it’s fair to wonder if Dallas’ RB2 isn’t even on the current roster.
Schottenheimer was asked to name players who had gone beyond expectations in camp, and the list did not include Jaydon Blue or Phil Mafah, according to Nick Harris of the Star-Telegram. Javonte Williams did make the cut. So did two rookies, Caleb Downs and Camden Brown, along with several others.
That omission may have been intentional, or it may have simply reflected what Schottenheimer saw from the group. Either way, it lined up with what happened in Saturday’s preseason win, which only added to the uncertainty around Blue and Mafah.
Blue and Mafah both had a tough time getting much going. The offensive line didn’t give either back much help, and that was especially rough for Blue’s style. He can make things happen once he’s in space, but he had a harder time between the tackles, where he tends to hit the hole early and doesn’t often power through contact.
His best moment was a 13-yard catch-and-run out of the backfield. Outside of that, he didn’t do much to change the conversation.
Mafah’s night was even harder to judge because he left early with a chest injury. He has since returned to practice, which is at least a good sign for his availability against the Cardinals, but he only got five touches total - four carries and one catch.
The Cowboys seemed to want all four backs - Blue, Mafah, Malik Davis, and Israel Abanikanda - in the 7-to-10 touch range. Everyone but Mafah got there. That means he can’t really afford another setback before camp ends.
Davis and Abanikanda, meanwhile, made stronger cases in Week 1 of the preseason. They benefited from better blocking and were working against the lower end of Seattle’s defensive depth chart, but they still looked better than Blue and Mafah. A good showing is a good showing.
Davis is the tricky one. Dallas appears to want to get younger at running back, and he turns 28 in December.
Still, he has only 90 career carries, so he’s not exactly worn down. More importantly, he’s the most complete back on the roster behind Javonte Williams.
Whether that matters enough to keep him around is the real question.
Abanikanda feels like the more obvious long shot for the active roster, but he could still end up sticking on the practice squad and getting called up on game day. That seems like his clearest route, at least for now. And if you’re wondering why that would be the case, the answer may be in the fact that he has appeared in just six regular-season games since being drafted in 2023.
The closer Dallas gets to cutdown time, the more this starts to look like a position the team might solve from outside the building. Waivers and the trade market should have options when roster moves hit.
Blue, Mafah, Davis and Abanikanda still have time to take control of the job. If one of them does, it would make life a lot easier for everyone. But that clock is ticking.
In Other News...
Cowboys Could Make One More Bold Defensive Swing
The Cowboys spent the offseason trying to rework the look and feel of their defense, bringing in Christian Parker as defensive coordinator and adding multiple new pieces in an effort to raise the units ceiling. Even after that wave of change, the front office may not be done looking for help, especially at cornerback, where a proven young player could still fit into the long-term plan.
NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported that Steelers cornerback Joey Porter Jr. has surfaced as a possible trade target for Dallas, with Porter entering the final year of his rookie contract and Pittsburgh potentially open to moving him. The appeal is easy to see for a Cowboys team still chasing more stability on defense, but any real pursuit would come with a price, and for now it remains only a possibility rather than a deal in motion. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Face A Few Tough Roster Calls Fans Should Watch Closely
The Cowboys are entering that part of the calendar when promise turns into math, and the numbers get tight fast. Ahead of the 2026 season, Dallas is looking at a few roster spots that could turn into real decisions, with edge rusher Williams, defensive back Bell and quarterback Milton all sitting in the mix as the team sorts out its depth chart and priorities.
Williams is fighting through a crowded edge rusher room, Bell brings the kind of versatility teams like but also has off-field issues hanging over his case, and Milton is locked in a backup quarterback battle with Sam Howell. Coaches have already weighed in on their performances, but nothing is settled yet, which is exactly what makes these calls worth watching as roster cuts draw closer. [Read more 🡒]
Jerry Jones Makes Clear Cowboys Are Not Taking This Lightly
The Cowboys heated joint practice with the Saints carried a real cost, with the NFL fining both clubs $500,000 after multiple fights broke out between the two teams. Jerry Jones called the penalty significant and said Dallas plans to appeal, a sign the organization is taking the leagues response seriously even as training camp intensity spills over the line.
Donovan Ezeiruaku is also expected to face an individual fine for his role in the incidents, adding another layer to what was already an ugly day on the practice field. For a Cowboys team trying to build momentum in camp, the episode is a reminder that the league is watching closely when emotions run high, and the fallout could linger beyond the field work itself. [Read more 🡒]