Joe Milton’s first start for the Eagles gave the Cowboys plenty to think about, even if it didn’t give anyone a clean answer.
Philadelphia handed Milton the keys against the Giants last Sunday after Jalen Hurts’ season-ending injury, and the results were a messy mix of promise and problems in a 19-11 loss. Milton finished 18-of-34 for 169 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions. He was sacked seven times and lost a fumble on one of those plays, but he also added 64 rushing yards, most of them coming when he broke the pocket rather than on designed runs.
That uneven line told the story. Milton showed the athletic traits that have kept him on the NFL radar since his Tennessee days, but the rough edges were there too.
Philadelphia’s offense was already a mess before he got the start, so the whole thing was hard to judge in a vacuum. Some of the sacks were on him, especially when he held the ball too long, but others came from protection breakdowns that left him with no chance.
For Dallas, though, the bigger issue is what Milton’s debut says about a decision made back in August. After more than a year of developmental work in the Cowboys’ system, Milton was cut during final roster trimming, then stashed on the practice squad. The Eagles grabbed him a few weeks ago, and now he’s suddenly part of the conversation again.
The Cowboys chose Sam Howell as their QB2 this season, and that call made sense to plenty of people. Milton’s lack of experience and polish were part of why Dallas went that direction. Still, some fans never warmed to the idea of exposing him on the practice squad after he had shown well in the preseason.
The price Dallas paid for him was modest - a fifth-round pick, with New England sending back a seventh in the deal. That’s a far cry from the fourth-rounder the Cowboys sent to San Francisco for Trey Lance, a move that brought no pick back at all. But because the Lance trade already sits in the background, the Milton situation has drawn even more scrutiny.
Dallas has bigger problems than backup quarterback right now. The Cowboys are 4-5, and Howell hasn’t played a meaningful snap. Even so, the quarterback pipeline matters, especially with Dak Prescott turning 34 next summer and carrying plenty of mileage and durability concerns.
If Milton had lit it up for Philadelphia and helped hand the Giants a loss, there would have been some real sting in that for Dallas. As it stands, the question is still hanging there: did the Cowboys make a mistake by letting Joe Milton get away? If he gets more starts in Philly and more time in that offense, there may be more evidence soon.
In Other News...
CeeDee Lamb Knows What Could Derail Cowboys Against The 49ers
CeeDee Lamb is already looking past the relief of Dallas close win over the Indianapolis Colts and toward the kind of matchup that tends to expose a teams weak spots. With the 49ers coming to Arlington on Sunday afternoon, the Cowboys are staring at a meeting with the NFCs top seed and a roster that has only gotten more dangerous after adding wide receiver Keenan Allen.
For Lamb, the biggest concern is not Xs and Os so much as the emotional edge that can creep in after a big result or a big stage. The Cowboys have spent enough time around high-pressure games to know how quickly a rivalry-caliber matchup can turn if the focus slips, and this one arrives with plenty at stake for a team trying to keep its footing against one of the conferences most complete opponents. [Read more 🡒]
Dak Prescott Knows What Sunday Means For The Cowboys
Dak Prescott did not need to be reminded what Sunday means for the Cowboys. The 49ers have been a stubborn roadblock for Dallas, with the Cowboys dropping their last four matchups against San Francisco, including two playoff meetings, and the recent history has only sharpened the attention around this Week 10 showdown at AT&T Stadium.
Prescott spoke to reporters with the focus squarely on ending that stretch against a 7-1 San Francisco team that has looked the part of a contender. For Dallas, the timing makes the game feel bigger than a regular-season test, and the 4:25 p.m. ET kickoff gives the Cowboys a chance to answer a familiar challenge on their home field. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Fans Suddenly Have A Jason Witten Coaching Debate
Jason Wittens first college coaching win at Oklahoma gave Cowboys fans something unexpected to chew on, and it had nothing to do with the current roster. Working as the Sooners interim offensive coordinator, Witten picked up his first victory in that role, and the result was enough to spark a familiar kind of Dallas conversation: what if the former tight end eventually comes back home in a bigger way?
Bob Sturm floated Witten as a possible name for a future Cowboys coaching opening, putting him on a short list to replace Brian Schottenheimer if the season keeps sliding. With Dallas sitting at 4-5 and the coaching situation already feeling shaky, the idea has a way of hanging around even if it is still more debate than decision. [Read more 🡒]