Brian Schottenheimer gave the Cowboys another self-inflicted wound on Thursday night, and this one came at the exact moment Dallas still had a chance to change the feel of the game.
After Dak Prescott hit George Pickens on an 18-yard touchdown to pull the Cowboys within one possession in the fourth quarter, the obvious move was to kick the extra point and cut the deficit to seven. Instead, Schottenheimer went for two. Dallas missed, and suddenly the Cowboys were down eight.
That decision changed the math the rest of the way. If Dallas got the ball back and scored again, it would need a touchdown and another two-point conversion just to tie. The presence of Brandon Aubrey only made the call look stranger, especially since the Cowboys made him the highest-paid kicker in NFL history this offseason.
The move drew even more attention because it came in a 24-16 home loss to the previously 0-4 Tampa Bay Buccaneers, a team that entered the night with an undrafted rookie at quarterback. It was a national audience watching Dallas stumble again, and the loss only added fuel to the growing questions around Schottenheimer.
There were other problems, too. Christian Parker’s defense was shaky again and allowed Bucky Irving to run wild, but the Cowboys still got stops on Tampa Bay’s final two possessions.
That gave the offense a chance to go drive the field and force overtime. The problem was that Schottenheimer had already put Dallas behind the eight-ball with the failed two-point try.
The offense never did enough anyway. Dallas has one of the most talented offensive personnel groupings in the league, but it still couldn’t get to 20 points against a Buccaneers team that has been a mess. Todd Bowles came in as the coach under the most pressure, but he still clearly out-coached Schottenheimer.
Now the Cowboys are 2-3 and could be looking up at both the Giants and Eagles in the NFC East race. That’s a brutal spot considering Jalen Hurts is melting down and New York is starting Jameis Winston.
For Dallas, the bigger issue is how often it keeps beating itself. Penalties, poor effort, and a badly timed two-point attempt turned a winnable game into another bad loss. And if that keeps happening, the noise around Schottenheimer’s job security is only going to get louder.
In Other News...
Bucs Upset Win Left Dak Prescott Seething After A Wild Postgame Scene
The Cowboys home loss to Tampa Bay on Thursday night already had the feel of a damaging one, and the night only got stranger after the final whistle. In the tunnel at the stadium, a viral exchange unfolded when a stadium worker called Dak Prescott embarrassing, turning a rough defeat into the kind of postgame scene that tends to linger long after the score is forgotten.
Prescott was clearly bothered by what happened and addressed it in his postgame press conference, explaining why the comment struck a nerve. For Dallas, the frustration went beyond the upset itself, spilling into a moment that put the quarterback in the middle of an unexpected confrontation and added another layer to a night the Cowboys would rather move past quickly. [Read more 🡒]
George Pickens Said What Had Him So Frustrated After Cowboys Loss
George Pickens had one of his best games of the season in the Cowboys 24-16 loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at AT&T Stadium, finishing with nine catches for 130 yards and a touchdown. Even with that production, the evening ended the way too many Cowboys losses do lately, with a missed chance to turn a strong individual performance into a much-needed win.
Pickens was visibly frustrated afterward, and it was easy to see why. Dallas never managed to put together a late push strong enough to seriously threaten Tampa Bay, leaving the receiver to walk off with the kind of stat line that usually feels good and the kind of result that does not. The bigger concern for the Cowboys is how often that gap has shown up when they need a comeback most. [Read more 🡒]
Dak Prescott Debate Just Got Even Worse After Cowboys Loss
The Cowboys loss to the Buccaneers dropped them to 2-3 and only sharpened the conversation around Dak Prescott, whose uneven night fit into a debate that has followed him for years. He finished 24 of 42 for 316 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions, a performance that gave Dallas plenty of offense in stretches but not enough clean play to escape Tampa Bay with a win.
Stephen A. Smith added another layer to the scrutiny on ESPNs First Take, saying Brock Purdy has been better than Prescott because of his success in the biggest moments and Prescotts limited playoff track record. For the Cowboys, it is the kind of comparison that tends to linger when the results are coming up short, and every rough outcome only makes the discussion around Prescott harder to quiet. [Read more 🡒]