When the Dallas Cowboys traded for George Pickens last offseason, eyebrows were raised. Known for his "antics" during his time with the Pittsburgh Steelers, many wondered if this move might backfire.
Yet, under the guidance of Brian Schottenheimer, Pickens silenced the skeptics. He racked up 1,429 yards and 9 touchdowns, earning his first Pro Bowl selection and establishing himself as Dallas' top offensive weapon in 2025.
Now, as he approaches free agency, the Cowboys face a pivotal decision: What should they do about Pickens' contract? According to insider Mike Fisher, the plan is to use the franchise tag, securing Pickens for around $28 million for the 2026 season.
But the conversation doesn't stop there. A potential long-term deal, possibly spanning four years and totaling $120 million, is on the table.
That would mean an average of at least $30 million per year, which could help manage his cap hit.
But has Pickens truly earned that level of commitment from Dallas? ESPN's Damien Woody suggests caution.
On GetUp, Woody stated, "I would tag him. I would basically say, show me again because I'm not dismissing the years he spent in Pittsburgh.
It's one thing to do it in a contract year, and you put up that type of season. I still need to see you do it again before I fully commit long-term to a player like George Pickens."
Woody's perspective highlights a key concern: Can Pickens consistently deliver at this high level, both on and off the field? The risk is real. If the Cowboys tag him and he doesn't play or refuses to sign, it could open a Pandora's box of issues.
Given his contributions in 2025, retaining Pickens seems wise. But committing to over $30 million per year?
That's the million-dollar question-or rather, the $30 million question. Dallas must decide if what they witnessed last season is enough to believe Pickens has truly turned a corner, both professionally and personally.
When considering such a significant investment, there can be no room for doubt.