Heading into the 2025 season, the Dallas Cowboys' backfield looked like a question mark. With Miles Sanders and Javonte Williams atop the depth chart, there were more doubts than answers. But Williams didn’t just quiet the critics-he ran right through them.
The 25-year-old delivered a breakout campaign, turning what many saw as a potential weakness into a legitimate strength. He was one of the league’s most productive backs, showing off the power, vision, and burst that made him a standout in Denver before injuries slowed his momentum. Now, with free agency looming, the Cowboys face a pivotal decision: re-sign the emerging star or pivot to a new plan.
If Dallas can’t lock Williams into a long-term deal, they’ll need to explore other options-and that’s where things get interesting.
One name that’s starting to surface is Tyler Allgeier, the Atlanta Falcons’ backup who quietly put together a strong season in a limited role. Despite playing behind Bijan Robinson, Allgeier made the most of his touches, racking up 514 rushing yards and eight touchdowns. That’s impressive production, especially considering he was working with roughly half the carries Robinson received.
Allgeier’s efficiency isn’t a fluke. Back in his rookie year, he posted over 1,000 rushing yards on 210 attempts, proving he can handle a full workload when given the opportunity.
And stylistically, he fits what Dallas likes to do. The Cowboys leaned heavily on inside zone concepts in 2025, and Allgeier’s downhill running style could mesh well with an offensive line that ranked top-10 in run-blocking, according to PFF.
Should the Cowboys decide to go the free-agent route, Allgeier presents a compelling case: affordable, experienced, and scheme-compatible. He’s not a flashy name, but he’s the kind of back who can grind out tough yards, move the chains, and keep the offense on schedule.
Of course, there’s also an in-house option to consider. Jaydon Blue, a fifth-round pick out of Texas, is entering his second year and could be ready for a bigger role.
He’s got upside, no doubt, but banking on a young back to carry the load is a gamble-especially for a team with playoff aspirations. Allgeier, on the other hand, is a plug-and-play option who’s already proven he can produce at the pro level.
The ideal scenario for Dallas is simple: bring back Williams and build around a back who just had a career year. But if negotiations stall or the price tag gets too steep, pivoting to a player like Allgeier could be a smart, low-risk move. He won’t generate headlines, but he might just help keep the offense rolling.
Bottom line? The Cowboys have options. But with free agency fast approaching, they’ll need to make a call soon-and the next move in the backfield could say a lot about how this team plans to contend in 2026.