The Cowboys are back on the clock, and a fresh name has surfaced just before Tuesday’s trade deadline: Jets edge rusher Will McDonald.
NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reported that McDonald has asked to be moved after growing unhappy with his role in New York. His playing time has dropped sharply, falling from 66% of the snaps over the past two seasons to 46% in 2026.
"Jets pass-rusher Will McDonald IV has informed the team that he wants to be traded, sources say," Rapoport stated. "McDonald has played sparingly this season and is extremely frustrated with his usage."
That reduced workload is tied to the Jets’ offseason additions on the edge. New York brought in David Bailey, Joseph Ossai and Kingsley Enagbare, and McDonald has been the odd man out.
The Jets do have some leverage here. McDonald still has one year left on his contract, so they don’t need to rush into a deal. At the same time, that extra year of team control could make him more attractive in a trade, since he wouldn’t be a pure rental and deadline bidders often pay up when the market gets tight.
For Dallas, the fit is obvious. The Cowboys need edge help badly, and the group they’ve assembled has not delivered enough pressure. Their edge rushers have produced 7.5 sacks this season, with Rashan Gary, Malachi Lawrence and Von Miller combining for four of them.
As a team, Dallas has 17 sacks, which is tied for the 11th-fewest in the NFL.
That lack of production has been even more damaging because the coverage behind it has also been shaky, leaving the Cowboys searching for a way to generate more disruption up front.
McDonald would at least bring proven pass-rush production. He has 18.5 sacks over the past two seasons and has three in nine games this year, which would still lead Dallas’ EDGE group.
The price tag could land around a fourth-round pick, and the Cowboys do have a 2027 fourth-rounder available. But their draft cupboard has already been thinned out by previous trades, and moving that pick would leave them with only three selections next year.
So Dallas has a real decision to make: is McDonald good enough to justify another draft pick going out the door?
The Cowboys have made it clear they need a top-tier edge rusher to have a real shot at fixing this defense, and even that might not be enough. McDonald is not in that elite tier, which could make Dallas hesitate before paying the price.
In Other News...
Cowboys Flipped The Finish When A Colts Star Broke Down
The Cowboys got a timely break in a game that had been tight for much of the afternoon, and it came on a play where Sauce Gardner could not hold up at the end. Gardner had been steady for most of the day, but one crucial lapse helped swing the finish in Dallas favor and left the Colts staring at another loss in a skid that has now reached five straight.
For Dallas, it was the kind of closing sequence that can change the feel of a season, especially against a team already under pressure. Gardners rough ending also renewed the scrutiny around his value since arriving from the Jets, while the Colts now have to sort through both the defeat and a schedule that does not offer much relief ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Caleb Downs Just Gave The Cowboys Something They Desperately Needed
The Cowboys needed a defensive jolt in a tight game against the Colts, and rookie safety Caleb Downs delivered one at exactly the right time. Dallas came away with a close win to move to 4-5, and Downs was right in the middle of it, making his presence felt all over the field as the secondary helped keep Indianapolis from finding much rhythm through the air.
Downs was especially effective when the Colts tested him, limiting their success in coverage and earning the highest coverage grade among the defenders in the game. For a Cowboys defense that has been searching for steady play and timely stops, his performance stood out as one of the clearest reasons the team was able to finish the job. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Face A George Pickens Decision Fans Never Expected
Speculation around George Pickens has started to swirl at an awkward time for the Cowboys, with the trade deadline approaching and the team trying to steady itself through a rocky stretch. Michael Robinson of NFL Network added fuel to the conversation by suggesting Dallas could be in seller mode, even raising the possibility of Pickens landing with the Chiefs. It is the kind of rumor that tends to catch fire quickly when a teams season feels unsettled, especially around a receiver the Cowboys have publicly described as part of their long-term plans.
The chatter only picked up after Pickens was held out of Sundays game because of injuries, giving the rumor mill another reason to run. For now, though, there has been no official trade and Dallas has not backed off its stated desire to keep him, which leaves the situation in a familiar holding pattern: plenty of noise, a looming deadline, and one of the teams more intriguing offensive pieces at the center of it all. [Read more 🡒]