The Dallas Cowboys appear poised to bring back Javonte Williams after a breakout season that gave their ground game a much-needed jolt. But even with Williams likely returning, Dallas still has work to do in the backfield. The depth behind him is thin, and the team can’t afford to roll into 2026 relying solely on unproven or inconsistent options.
Miles Sanders, who struggled with injuries and inefficiency throughout the season, is unlikely to return. That leaves Malik Davis and Jaydon Blue as the current backups-young players with potential, but neither has shown enough to be counted on as a reliable second option. For a team with playoff ambitions, that’s a risky setup.
Enter Tyler Allgeier.
The Atlanta Falcons’ power back has been floated as a potential fit in Dallas, and honestly, it makes a lot of sense. Allgeier is built for the kind of dirty work that doesn’t always show up in highlight reels but wins games in December and January.
At 225 pounds, he’s a bruiser who thrives between the tackles and doesn’t shy away from contact. He’s the kind of back who can wear down a defense over four quarters-and in Dallas’ zone running scheme, he could be a natural fit.
Allgeier’s rookie season in 2022 was no fluke. He cracked the 1,000-yard mark and added four total touchdowns, proving he could carry the load when called upon.
Since then, he’s been playing second fiddle to Bijan Robinson in Atlanta, but don’t mistake that for a lack of productivity. Even in a limited role, Allgeier has topped 500 rushing yards in each of the last three seasons.
That kind of consistency, especially with fewer touches, speaks volumes about his ability to stay ready and contribute when needed.
For Dallas, the appeal is clear: Allgeier could be the thunder to Williams’ lightning. While Williams brings burst, agility, and big-play potential, Allgeier offers a physical presence that can help grind out tough yards, especially in short-yardage and goal-line situations.
He’d also help take some of the wear and tear off Williams, who dealt with health issues late in the 2025 season. Managing Williams’ workload will be key to keeping him fresh for the stretch run, and Allgeier is the kind of back who can shoulder that burden without missing a beat.
And the best part? He won’t break the bank. Spotrac projects Allgeier to command a one-year deal worth around $1.8 million-a reasonable price for a proven contributor who could play a significant role in a committee backfield.
If the Cowboys want to keep their offense balanced and their top back healthy, adding a veteran like Allgeier should be more than just a consideration-it should be a priority.