The Cowboys are back in the kind of game that makes bookmakers pause and bettors squint at the board.
Dallas enters Week 6 at 2-3 after a baffling upset loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and Sunday Night Football brings another tricky assignment against the Green Bay Packers. The problem with trying to price the Cowboys is that they live in two different worlds at once: one of the league’s most dangerous offenses, and a defense that has been a disaster by the numbers.
That contradiction is exactly what makes Dallas such a headache to model. The offense sits top 10 in almost every major metric and even cracks the top five in a few spots.
The defense, meanwhile, is last in several categories and bottom five in others when it is not sitting dead last outright. That kind of split creates a team that is hard to judge with any confidence from week to week.
Ty Gour, a Sports Trader at Fanatics Sportsbook, said that unpredictability is the issue when the Cowboys land in shootouts.
"Most of their games end up in shootout game scripts, which, from a modeling perspective, can be difficult at times just because of the unpredictability in a shootout environment. If both teams are scoring on every drive, it can make a mediocre offense look amazing, and it can make a mediocre defense look abysmal. It's just something to keep in mind in these games."
That same problem carries over to player props, especially when star pass catchers are involved.
"That's an area that we tend to have to work a little extra hard on: player props in these kinds of games, especially big-time receivers like CeeDee Lamb or Christian Watson. They're going to have inflated props in these types of games compared to other weeks".
For bettors, the Cowboys have become a simple read in theory, if not always in practice: if they are favored, fade them; if they are catching points, take them; and if the spread lands near a pick'em, lean to the over. The logic is straightforward - Dallas scores too easily to dismiss, but gives up too much to trust laying points.
That brings this week’s matchup with the Packers into focus. Dallas is listed as a 1.5-point underdog for Sunday night, and in what projects as a coin-flip game, the over is the angle being played.
Odds refresh periodically and are subject to change.
If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
In Other News...
Cowboys Lose Another Key Piece In A Night They Couldnt Afford It
The Cowboys entered Sunday night already needing things to break their way, and losing KaVontae Turpin in the first half only made the margin for error even thinner. Turpin, who usually handles kick return duties, went out with a rib injury against the Packers and did not return, leaving Dallas to patch together yet another important spot on a night when it could ill afford another setback.
Jerry Jones still sounded encouraged by where the team is headed, pointing to the progress he sees despite Dallas sitting at 2-3. But a game like this serves as a reminder of how fragile that optimism can be when key pieces keep disappearing, especially on special teams, where Turpins speed and field-flipping ability are part of what makes this roster harder to defend. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Turn To Rookie As Pressure Builds On Struggling Defense
Pressure is rising on a Cowboys defense that has struggled to find its footing, and the next answer is coming from a rookie. Dallas is turning to Malachi Lawrence to start at outside linebacker against the Green Bay Packers, giving the first-round pick his first career start after taking him 23rd overall in the 2026 NFL Draft.
Brian Schottenheimer has seen enough from Lawrence recently to make the move, and the coach signaled that more opportunities should follow. For a defense trying to steady itself, the decision gives Dallas a new look up front and a chance to see whether its young edge rusher can bring some needed energy into a difficult spot. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Sit Atop An NFC East Mess That Just Got Worse
The NFC East has spent the last few weeks looking like a division stuck in reverse, and the Cowboys loss to the Packers only added to the mess. With the Commanders set to enter Sunday as underdogs against the 49ers, the leagues most unpredictable division is suddenly staring at a stat line nobody wants attached to it: a chance to go winless in back-to-back weeks when every team played, something that has not happened since the 1970 NFL-AFL merger.
For the Cowboys, the bigger frustration is that the standings are still wide open even as the losses pile up. The Giants are sitting atop the division for now, but the upcoming slate could reshuffle everything again, leaving Dallas, Washington and the rest of the East to sort out whether this is a temporary rough patch or a much deeper slide. [Read more 🡒]