No. 17 has never been one of the Dallas Cowboys’ crowded numbers, but the list of players who wore it still tells a pretty interesting story. It includes kickers, receivers, quarterbacks, and even a couple of names who went on to be better known on the sideline than on the field.
Brandon Aubrey is the current holder, and he’s already piled up franchise and league records in just a few seasons. But when it comes to the best Cowboys player ever to wear No. 17, the answer is Don Meredith.
Meredith wasn’t just a good quarterback for Dallas. He was the first real franchise QB the Cowboys had, the one who helped push the team from an expansion-era curiosity into a legitimate contender during the club’s early years.
His path to Dallas was unusual from the start. A two-time First-Team All-American at SMU, Meredith was tied to the Cowboys before the franchise had even officially entered the NFL.
When the 1960 NFL Draft was held in November 1959, Dallas still hadn’t been admitted to the league. Team owner Clint Murchison signed Meredith to a five-year personal services contract through another one of his businesses, with the understanding that Meredith would play for Dallas if the club got in.
Chicago Bears owner George Halas, who played a major role in helping get the Cowboys approved, then selected Meredith in the third round of that draft with the 32nd overall pick. Once Dallas was admitted in January 1960, the NFL honored Meredith’s deal with Murchison, and the Cowboys sent a third-round pick in the 1962 draft to the Bears.
Even with all that local buzz, Meredith did not open the Cowboys’ first season as the starter. That job went to Eddie LeBaron, a veteran who had already made three Pro Bowls with Washington in the 1950s. Meredith spent only a handful of games in the lineup over his first couple of seasons, then got more chances in 1962 before taking over full-time in 1963.
From there, his rise matched the team’s. By 1965, Dallas had its first non-losing season, finishing 7-7 in second place in the Eastern Conference.
Meredith threw for 2,415 yards and 22 touchdowns, which ranked seventh and third in the league. A year later, he made his first Pro Bowl, earned Second-Team All-Pro honors, and finished third in NFL MVP voting after posting 2,805 yards and 24 touchdowns.
That season ended with Dallas at 10-3-1 and in the NFL Championship Game, with a trip to the first Super Bowl on the line. The Cowboys lost 34-27 to the Green Bay Packers, who then beat the Kansas City Chiefs in the AFL-NFL World Championship Game.
Meredith got back to the Pro Bowl in 1967 and led Dallas to another shot at the NFL title, only for the Packers to beat the Cowboys again in the famous "Ice Bowl" at Lambeau Field. He made a third straight Pro Bowl in 1968, then retired abruptly after a rough postseason showing against the Cleveland Browns.
By the time his Dallas career was over, Meredith had thrown for 17,199 yards and 135 touchdowns, both still good for sixth in franchise history. He was later inducted into the Cowboys Ring of Honor in 1976.
In Other News...
Cowboys Fans Are Loving This Embarrassing Giants Coaching Moment
A preseason hype speech is supposed to stir a team, but John Harbaughs latest moment with the Giants did the opposite. The head coach leaned hard into the New York Giants message, only for the players reaction to fall flat enough that the clip quickly became a punchline online, with plenty of fans and commentators treating it as more awkward than inspiring.
For Cowboys fans, it was the kind of sideline stumble that is easy to enjoy from a distance, especially with the Giants carrying extra attention into the season. The bigger question now is whether that disconnect was just a bad viral moment or a sign of a team still trying to find the right edge before the games start to count. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Were Quietly Tied To A Quarterback Story Fans Did Not See Coming
Brendan Sorsbys path to the NFL took an unexpected turn when his attempt to enter the supplemental draft was turned away, pushing him back toward the 2027 class instead. The quarterback had already drawn attention from several teams, and his situation became more notable because his NCAA eligibility was lost after a sports gambling issue, a background that made any pro interest feel a little more complicated than the usual developmental quarterback chase.
For Dallas, the connection is easy to understand even if the timing is not. The Cowboys have Dak Prescott atop the depth chart, but they are always looking ahead at the position, and a player like Sorsby could have fit as a long-term backup or eventual successor if the process had moved differently. For now, the story is less about a fit than a missed opportunity, with the leagues decision leaving open whether the Cowboys will circle back when Sorsby is eligible again. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys May Already Be Losing Faith In Their Latest QB2 Fix
The Cowboys still have a real question behind Dak Prescott, and it is one that did not get any easier once the offseason dust settled. Joe Milton, who was the primary backup last year, is now in a camp battle with newly signed Sam Howell for the QB2 job, giving Dallas a competition that feels less like a formality and more like a test of which passer can steady the position.
Howell brings more experience and a financial commitment that could help him stick on the active roster, while Milton is still trying to show he can be more accurate and consistent. His preseason work last year left room for doubt, and if that does not change quickly, the Cowboys may have to decide whether he is better suited for the practice squad than for the role they hoped he could fill. [Read more 🡒]