The Cowboys came out of Thursday night with more than a loss to Tampa Bay. They also walked away with another ugly reminder that the Jake Ferguson extension is looking worse by the week.
Dallas already looks shaky on defense without Micah Parsons, and the Buccaneers rubbed that in as Bucky Irving ran wild through a unit that got gashed even after all the personnel changes. But the pain doesn’t stop there. One of the first big moves after the Parsons trade was handing Ferguson a four-year, $52 million extension with $20 million guaranteed, a deal that made him the fourth-highest-paid tight end in the NFL at the time.
That move had plenty of skeptics when it happened, especially because it felt like Jerry Jones was trying to prove a point about paying his own players. Right now, it’s hard to call it anything but a mistake.
Ferguson was a major culprit in the loss. In a game that should have fit his skill set, he dropped two passes, including the one that eventually became Dak Prescott’s game-sealing interception. The ball bounced off Ferguson and floated directly into Alex Anzalone’s hands while Dallas was trying to climb back into the game.
The numbers around Ferguson only deepen the concern. Per Marcus Mosher, since 2024, Ferguson is tied for the third-most fumbles (8) among all running backs, wide receivers, and tight ends.
Even worse, he’s the only player in the top 11 with fewer than 400 touches. He has 151, which works out to a fumble roughly every 19 touches.
For a tight end who isn’t getting heavy volume, that kind of production doesn’t leave much room for error. And there isn’t much else in the profile to hang onto, either.
Ferguson’s best trait now is what he can do in the red zone, but on a roster with CeeDee Lamb, George Pickens, and Javonte Williams, that edge doesn’t move the needle much. His athleticism has also slipped since the ACL sprain in 2024, and he’s not the same player who could create after the catch a couple seasons ago.
That’s why the extension has gone from questionable to flat-out damaging. Ferguson is under contract through 2029, but that doesn’t mean Dallas has to ride it all the way out. The Cowboys could move on as soon as the offseason if they decide the non-guaranteed money isn’t worth keeping him around.
Until then, Brian Schottenheimer needs to cut Ferguson’s snap share. The backups aren’t perfect, but Dallas can’t keep giving meaningful reps to a player who is actively hurting its chances to win. And with wins already hard enough to find, the $20 million tied up in Ferguson looks even more wasteful when you remember where some of that money could have gone instead.
In Other News...
Cowboys Fans Already Have A Week 5 Scoreboard To Sweat
At 2-3, the Cowboys are already in the familiar spot of watching the rest of the conference as closely as they watch their own sideline. Week 5 brings the kind of scoreboard math Dallas cant ignore, especially with NFC East results carrying extra weight so early in the season and a handful of other matchups around the league shaping the playoff picture if the Cowboys keep drifting around .500.
The most immediate attention is on the division games that can either help Dallas close ground or make the climb steeper, with Washington set to have a significant piece back in the mix. There is also a deeper layer for Cowboys fans to keep in mind beyond the present standings, since a couple of other games this week have ripple effects tied to future draft capital from past trades, which gives the rooting guide a little more range than your usual early-October scoreboard watch. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Fans Have An Uncomfortable Week 5 Reality To Root For
The Cowboys head into the week at 2-3 after the loss to Tampa Bay, and for all the frustration around that start, the bigger picture may now be just as important as the next snap. With NFC East and NFC North results carrying extra weight, Dallas fans have reason to keep one eye on the standings and another on the draft board, because this season is already shaping up to affect more than just the playoff chase.
Philadelphias roster keeps shifting, and Washington could be getting Jayden Daniels back, which adds another layer to a division race that already feels volatile. For Dallas, the uncomfortable part is that these outcomes now matter in more than one direction, with the teams own future assets also hanging in the balance as the season unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Sent A Frustrating Message With One Brandon Aubrey Decision
The Cowboys found themselves in a familiar kind of fourth-down debate during their recent game, except this one came with Brandon Aubreys leg in the middle of it. Facing 4th and 10 from the Tampa Bay 47-yard line, Dallas chose to punt rather than trust its kicker from extreme range, a call that spoke as much to game management as it did to confidence in one of the leagues most powerful legs.
Aubreys recent run of blocked and missed long attempts likely hung over the decision, and it left the impression of a staff trying to avoid another costly swing-and-miss in a tight situation. Still, the contrast with Dallas later choosing to go for a two-point conversion only sharpened the debate, because it suggested the Cowboys were willing to take risks, just not that particular one. [Read more 🡒]