Jalen Carter leaving Philadelphia would sound like a win for the Cowboys at first glance. The Eagles defensive tackle has already made himself plenty of enemies in Dallas, and his spit directed at Dak Prescott last year - followed by no apology - sealed that villain status with Cowboys fans.
But the bigger picture is messier than that. Carter has been productive against Dallas, too.
In five games against the Cowboys, he has 1.0 sacks, 12 tackles, one tackle for loss, two batted passes, five quarterback hits and a fumble recovery for a touchdown. That’s not a monster stat line, but it is a reminder that he’s a very good young player, not just a name Cowboys fans love to hate.
And now there’s at least some buzz that Philadelphia may not be eager to hand him a big multi-year extension. That has opened the door to the possibility that Carter could be moved out of the division, which would normally be welcome news in Dallas.
Except one proposed deal complicates that.
Bleacher Report’s Moe Moton put together a trade idea for the 2026 NFL season that would send Carter from the Eagles to the Arizona Cardinals in exchange for defensive end Josh Sweat. On paper, it’s the kind of move that could help both teams. For the Cowboys, though, it’s not exactly a clean break.
Here’s how Moton framed it:
"Here's a blockbuster deal that could solve issues for both teams.
"According to Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer, the Eagles are 'hesitant' to sign Carter to an extension. Philadelphia has a need on the edge with Jalyx Hunt and Nolan Smith Jr. likely to compete for snaps opposite Jonathan Greenard. Hunt has made strides, but he has been a rotational player for two years.
"The Eagles can upgrade their pass rush by bringing back Sweat, who played for the team between 2018 and 2024. According to ESPN's Dan Graziano, the 29-year-old edge-rusher has 'let it be known' that he's not happy in Arizona. The Cardinals can swap him and draft capital for Carter, who's younger and can contribute to the pass rush on the interior of the defensive line."
For Dallas, the problem is obvious: Sweat is no stranger to tormenting the Cowboys. He spent the first seven years of his career in Philadelphia, was part of the Super Bowl LIX team, and has 6.0 career sacks against Dallas. His sweat-wiping celebration is already burned into the memory of Cowboys fans.
So yes, Carter heading out of Philly would be good news in one sense. But if the Eagles turn that into Sweat - and extra draft capital for Howie Roseman - the division doesn’t suddenly become easier for Dallas.
Sweat is older and hasn’t been a Pro Bowler since 2021, but he also posted a career-high in sacks last season with the Cardinals. He still has juice, and seeing him twice a year would not be a pleasant development for the Cowboys.
There’s also the ripple effect of Philadelphia’s current edge setup. The Eagles lost defensive end Jaelan Phillips this offseason, but already replaced him with Jonathan Greenard. Add Sweat to a group that also includes Jalyx Hunt and Nolan Smith Jr., and Dallas could be staring at a pass-rush problem that reaches all the way to left tackle.
So while Cowboys fans might be tempted to root for Carter’s exit, they may want to be careful what they wish for. A Carter trade could still bring Philadelphia a strong return, and that might end up helping the Eagles more than it helps Dallas.
In Other News...
Tony Romo Just Made A Painful Cowboys Legacy Admission
Tony Romos Cowboys career still carries the same hard edge it always did: plenty of production, plenty of memorable Sundays, and the one thing that never came. Even years after retiring, the former Dallas quarterback remains one of the franchises defining passers, a player whose numbers and records once sat at the top of the teams history books before more recent names pushed past them.
What lingers most, though, is the postseason gap. Romo went 2-4 in the playoffs and never got Dallas to the NFC Championship Game, a reality that has long shadowed his legacy in a city that measures quarterbacks by January results as much as regular-season brilliance. For a player who gave the Cowboys so much of their offensive identity, the unfinished business still hangs over the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Former Cowboys Quarterback's Comeback Took An Unexpected Turn
Will Griers latest stop in Carolina was supposed to give him another chance to reestablish himself, but the veteran quarterbacks return to the Panthers ended before training camp even opened. After coming back earlier this offseason, Grier has decided to step away from professional football, a turn that closes the door on a career that included two separate stints with the Cowboys and several years of bouncing around for another opportunity.
For Dallas fans who remember him as part of the quarterback mix, it is another reminder of how quickly the league can change for a player trying to hang on. Carolina now moves forward with Bryce Young, Kenny Pickett and rookie Haynes King in its quarterback room, while Griers exit leaves one more unresolved chapter in a career that never quite found steady footing. [Read more 🡒]
DeMarvion Overshown Enters A Make Or Break Year For Dallas
DeMarvion Overshowns path in Dallas has already been defined as much by setbacks as by promise. He missed his rookie season with a torn ACL, then finally broke through as a starter in 2024 before another major knee injury interrupted what looked like a real rise for the Cowboys linebacker.
Now the focus shifts to 2026, a season that could go a long way toward determining where Overshown fits in Dallas future. He played only six games in 2025 and finished with 28 tackles, so the next step is less about projection than proof, with his health and production set to matter even more as he moves closer to free agency in 2027. [Read more 🡒]