Brian Schottenheimer’s first game in charge of the Cowboys didn’t exactly scream fresh start.
Dallas went into Week 1 at MetLife Stadium with a new-look defense, a new coaching staff and the same starting offense back in place for 2026. By the time the Cowboys walked off after a 28-20 loss to the Giants, the biggest questions weren’t about one side of the ball alone. They were about the tone the whole team set - and whether Schottenheimer helped or hurt it.
The offense opened with a strange look right away. Dallas lined up in 11 personnel with Jake Ferguson acting as the lead blocker from fullback, then tried an inside-toss to Javonte Williams that went nowhere after Ferguson and Ryan Flournoy missed their blocks on Abdul Carter. From there, the first series kept sputtering: a comeback route to CeeDee Lamb on the sideline fell incomplete, and George Pickens’ slant on third down came up just short of the line to gain.
The first major decision came on 4th-and-inches. Dallas tried to draw the Giants offsides, took a delay of game and then punted.
According to ESPN Analytics, the “go” in that spot was +1.7%. That conservative choice mattered because the Giants answered with a six-minute touchdown drive, and Dallas was immediately chasing the game.
Schottenheimer’s approach on fourth down was already a talking point last season, and this game only added to that conversation. With a defense that already looked vulnerable, the decision to punt instead of leaning on the offense set a cautious tone early.
The next Dallas possession was cleaner, but it still ended empty after a George Pickens drop on third down, with an illegal shift penalty declined. The Cowboys finally got something going before halftime, putting together a 15-play, 6:44 drive that ended in a CeeDee Lamb touchdown. Right after that, Dak Prescott threw an interception on an attempted throwaway on 3rd-and-5.
Because the defense struggled so badly, Dallas only had two more drives the rest of the night. Both ended in touchdowns.
The Cowboys also benefited from Giants penalties as the passing game started to settle in. Fans, meanwhile, were loud about Schottenheimer burning a timeout on the Giants’ opening drive of the second half, though it was later reported that Dallas only had 10 men on the field.
This wasn’t a total coaching collapse. The Cowboys came in with a balanced plan, and the final shape of the game was influenced by self-inflicted mistakes.
Schottenheimer’s play-calling wasn’t the issue in every spot. With the interior offensive line struggling to create running room, he leaned on Prescott when the Cowboys needed a must-have score, like the Lamb touchdown.
But the bigger problem was what the game said about the team’s mindset. The offense looked too conservative early, too careless with penalties and too short on toughness, focus and physicality for much of the night. Schottenheimer has talked plenty about culture since taking over, but in Week 1 the Cowboys looked timid and undisciplined.
Javonte Williams taunted the Giants secondary after scoring to make it a one-possession game with an Aubrey extra point or two-point conversion, which Schottenheimer said was his plan after the game.
Week 1 can mislead, and the Cowboys offense did find a rhythm in the second half. The expectation is still that this group can climb back near the top of the league in scoring and offensive EPA sooner rather than later.
Still, if you’re looking back at the biggest swing of the night, the opening-drive punt on 4th-and-inches stands out. With the benefit of hindsight, and with Dallas’ defense unable to get stops when it needed them, that call feels like the kind of early mistake that can shape a game.
The concerns coming out of Sunday are pretty clear: Schottenheimer didn’t seem to trust his offensive line, he showed too much faith that punts would be followed by defensive stops, and the offense lacked explosive plays, with Pickens dropping two attempts on downfield chances. Add in the penalties and the sloppiness, and it looked a lot like the kind of football Cowboys fans have seen too often over the last 30 years.
Fourth-Down Decisions: F
Timeout Usage: B
Team Preparation: F
What grades would you give to Brian Schottenhiemer on Sunday?
In Other News...
Cowboys Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Backfield Problems
The Cowboys are still sorting out the depth behind Javonte Williams, and their latest move says the backfield remains very much a work in progress. Dallas signed Tyler Goodson off the Atlanta Falcons practice squad and added him to the 53-man roster, a sign the team wanted a more immediate answer in the room after cycling through options at the position.
To make it happen, the Cowboys released veteran running back Israel Abanikanda, who could still find his way back to the practice squad. Goodson is expected to share backup duties behind Williams, but the shuffle only underscores how unsettled the spot has been and how closely Dallas is monitoring the group as it tries to stabilize the offense. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Week 1 Report Card Delivers A Harsh Verdict Fans Will Debate
Dallas opened the season with a loss to the Giants, and the early report card did not leave much room for optimism. The evaluation dug into individual performances across the roster, weighing the good against the bad after a game that featured too many mistakes to overcome, and it was especially notable that no Cowboy earned an A grade.
Penalties and a handful of defining plays shaped how the night was viewed afterward, turning what might have been a simple opening-week setback into a broader critique of execution. For a team expected to get the details right from the start, the grades offered a blunt reminder that the conversation in Dallas is already about where the cleanest performances came from, and where the biggest questions are still waiting to be answered. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Linebacker Worries Just Turned Into A Bigger Problem
The Cowboys came out of their game against the Giants with more questions than answers at linebacker, and the concern goes well beyond one shaky afternoon. DeMarvion Overshown and Dee Winters both had trouble holding up in coverage and against the run, giving up completions and looking vulnerable in the kind of traffic the middle of the defense has to handle.
Overshown also drew a late-hit flag, a reminder that the margin for error at that spot can be thin when instincts and discipline are still catching up. Taken together, the performance raised a bigger issue for Dallas: whether either player truly fits the MIKE role the way the defense needs, or whether the front office has to keep looking for an upgrade before this becomes a longer-term problem. [Read more 🡒]