Cowboys Face A Risky Left Tackle Decision To Fix Their Defense

Could trading Tyler Guyton for Jordyn Brooks be the strategic boost the Cowboys need to solidify their defense?

The Cowboys have spent the offseason trying to fix what was, by their standards, a brutal defensive year. And now a mock trade has handed them a pretty clean path to chase one of the names that’s been hanging around Dallas for a while: Miami Dolphins linebacker Jordyn Brooks.

FanSided’s Wynston Wilcox floated a deal that would send Tyler Guyton and a 2027 seventh-round pick to Miami, with Brooks coming back to Dallas. Wilcox also made clear this isn’t the kind of move the Cowboys need to rush into. In his view, it’s more of a deadline play than something that happens right away.

"The Cowboys are going to see what their young players do through the preseason and evaluate if it’s worth turning to more stability. Once they’re hovering around a playoff spot, they’ll make a desperate move and that feels like this. Don’t be surprised to see Jerry Jones pull the trigger."

That timing makes sense for Dallas, especially with Guyton still sitting right in the middle of the biggest question on offense. The Cowboys’ offensive line was recently ranked No. 18 in the NFL, and a lot of that uncertainty comes down to whether Guyton can settle in as the full-time left tackle the team once envisioned. If he doesn’t, Dallas could decide the trade-off is worth it.

Brooks would bring a lot back the other way. He put together a huge season in 2025, finishing with 183 total tackles, 3.5 sacks, a forced fumble, three passes defended and 20.5 stuffs, which led the NFL in tackles. He’s coming off a breakout year that put him among the best linebackers at his position.

Dallas already has some pieces in place at linebacker, too. DeMarvion Overshown has been projected as a breakout candidate, but the big question is whether he can stay healthy. Dee Winters also gave the Cowboys a solid season with 101 total tackles.

If the Cowboys keep Overshown and Winters and then add Brooks later in the year, that group would look awfully strong.

As for the tackle spot, moving Guyton would likely open the door for fourth-round pick Drew Shelton. If not, Nate Thomas has already shown he can handle the role, having played 17 games and started four. Both Shelton and Thomas can also play right tackle.

And from Dallas’ perspective, giving up a seventh-round pick wouldn’t be much of a sacrifice. The Dolphins, in the middle of a rebuild with Jeff Hafley, could use draft capital wherever they can get it.

In Other News...

George Pickens Just Sent Cowboys Fans A Needed Message Before Camp

With training camp set to open July 29 in Oxnard, the Cowboys are heading into the summer with a familiar offensive core and a new layer of intrigue around George Pickens. Dallas returns all 11 starters on offense, and Pickens has already made one of the clearest statements he can make this time of year by showing up for Dak Prescotts annual offensive skill position player retreat in Utah, where the group spent time together before the real work begins.

For a team trying to keep its passing game on track heading toward the 2026 season, those early gatherings matter, especially with Pickens still settling into the Cowboys rhythm after a spring that included a late arrival to OTAs before he joined the mandatory portion of the offseason program. The next question is how all of that translates once camp starts and the pads come on, because the Cowboys are counting on their new receiver to fit quickly into an offense that already has a lot of continuity. [Read more 🡒]

Cowboys Offense Has A Thin Margin For Error In 2026

The Cowboys are heading into 2026 with a rare kind of continuity on offense, keeping the entire unit together while the defense absorbs most of the change. That stability sounds good on paper, but it also leaves a few familiar pressure points in place, especially along the line and in the backfield, where young players are still being asked to grow into bigger jobs. Tyler Guyton, Jaydon Blue and Cooper Beebe are among the names carrying that burden, with each one needing a better year if Dallas wants the offense to look more dependable than it did at times last season.

Brevyn Spann-Ford is another player worth watching as the Cowboys sort out how much they want to lean into their tight end depth behind Jake Ferguson. He outplayed Luke Schoonmaker last year and has moved into the TE2 spot, which gives Dallas another potential piece if the offense uses more two-tight-end sets. The bigger picture is simple enough: with so much of the offense already set, the Cowboys do not have many places to hide if one of these spots turns into a weak link. [Read more 🡒]

Jerry Jones Faces Another Massive Cowboys Decision On Quinnen Williams

Quinnen Williams is barely settled into what should be his first full season in Dallas, but his long-term future is already the kind of conversation that tends to follow premium talent around the Cowboys. Jerry Jones has never been shy about moving early on core players when it helps with cap planning, and Williams fits the profile of a defender whose value can climb fast if he looks like the difference-maker Dallas expects.

The timing matters because defensive tackle money keeps rising, and the Cowboys know how quickly a bargain can turn into a premium. Williams has already drawn enough attention to make an extension a real possibility before the season gets rolling, and Dallas may prefer to get ahead of that market rather than chase it later. [Read more 🡒]