The Dallas Cowboys are gearing up for a pivotal offseason, with their defense needing significant upgrades to become a true contender in 2026. With two first-round picks in the upcoming NFL Draft, the Cowboys have an opportunity to reshape their defensive lineup under new coordinator Christian Parker and head coach Brian Schottenheimer.
Dallas has a history of leveraging the draft effectively, but recent trades for players like George Pickens and Quinnen Williams show a willingness to make bold moves. Now, there's buzz around another potential blockbuster trade that could shake up the draft landscape.
The proposal involves the Cowboys trading their No. 12 and No. 20 picks to the Cleveland Browns for the No. 6 pick, along with the Browns' No. 39 pick. This strategy aligns with the Trade Value Chart popularized by Jimmy Johnson and could position Dallas to draft Ohio State safety Caleb Downs, a player many consider the best in the draft.
Downs, who started his collegiate career at Alabama, is viewed as a generational talent. His time at Ohio State saw him earn All-American honors twice, showcasing his versatility and range that have scouts excited about his potential.
Given the unlikelihood of Downs falling out of the top 10, Dallas sees Cleveland as a strategic trade partner to leapfrog the Washington Commanders at No. 7 and secure a top-tier prospect.
Former Cowboys scout and current radio host Bryan Broaddus initially described the trade as a "big-time overpay," but acquiring the No. 39 pick in the second round could make the deal more palatable. This move directly addresses the Cowboys' pressing need in the secondary.
With starting safeties Malik Hooker and Donovan Wilson both aging and injury-prone, the Cowboys are in a position to inject youth into their defense. Pairing Downs with Parker, a former secondary coach, could establish a strong foundation for the team’s future.
While traditionally, Dallas hasn't prioritized safeties in the draft, Caleb Downs might be the exception. His potential as a plug-and-play asset could make an immediate impact, justifying the aggressive approach. If the Cowboys see Downs as the key to revitalizing their defense, this bold move might be the perfect way to kickstart their rebuilding efforts.